• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does a PR system produce weak governments ?

Extracts from this document...


How far do you agree with the view that electoral systems based on proportional representation inevitably produce weak governments? Proportional Representation (PR) as a title covers a wide variety of electoral systems where seats in parliament are more or less in proportion to votes cast. British Politics has used forms of proportional representation in elections for devolution in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. A form of proportional representation was used in the London mayoral election as well. But it has never replaced First-Past-The-Post in British national elections. PR, in one form or another, is used throughout Europe, has long been advocated by the Liberal Democrats and support for it has grown in Britain since the 1970s. This is partly because the first-past-the-post system (FPTP) failed in the 1970's to produce strong majority governments, and partly because the increasing third-party vote since the mid-1970s has highlighted the distortions of the present voting system. The 1997 Labour government promised a referendum on the issue, but the referendum itself was delayed and the amount of choice which might be offered to the electorate could be very limited ...read more.


They came 2nd in 2003, but worked their way up to 1st in 2007. However, their lead was tiny, only by a single seat, and so the government formed was weak from the very beginning, with heavy opposition from within the parliament from pro union parties like Labour and the Conservatives, who strongly oppose the intentions of nationalist parties like the SNP in terms of overall Scottish independence. The situation is similar in Wales, where in 1999 again there was a Labour LibDem Coalition, as neither party had a majority. Labour just managed to create its own government in 2003, but once again with no outright majority, and faced a tough time in office, and just like the SNP in Scotland, Wales's nationalist party, Plaid Cymru were the biggest gainers of a PR system, coming second in 2003 and narrowing the gap even further in 2007, gaining an additional 3 seats, all at the expense of labour. The single transferable vote system (STV) is another proportional voting system, this time used in northern Ireland, and once again has a history of creating weak governments. ...read more.


Parties like UKIP gained a significant 17% of the vote in 2004, accounting to 16% of the seats, as opposed labour's 22% of the vote and 25% of seats. Another significant benefactor of the PR system used are more extreme nationalist parties such as the BNP, who gained their first 2 MEP's in 2009 at labours expense. In essence protest voting lead to high percentages of the vote for "minor" parties, who under a FPTP system like in the Westminster elections would remain minor, ended up securing increasingly significant amounts of seats, further weakening the position of the parliament as a whole. In conclusion, and including the Greater London Assembly, which also uses a PR system and shows similar results, we can see that all the proportional systems used in the UK have consistently failed to produce a strong government, and in some cases have been forced into creating coalition governments made up multiple parties in order to create at least a reasonably efficient party, something that has not happened in Westminster since 1945 under a FPTP system. It is thus that we can conclude that electoral systems based on proportional representation inevitably produce weak governments. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. How, and with what success, have governments attempted to improve the provision of health ...

    are under inspection to ensure safety measures are in place as it subsequently emerged that no emergency blood supplies on site and vital medical equipment was no available. This has asked the question of whether the private sector is reliable for the quality of basic compassionate care.

  2. To what extent have governments and political parties agreed on how best to raise ...

    The amount of money going in could maybe spent better on existing schools as it is too early to tell the success of academies. NUT disagrees with academies as they believe that privatisation is wrong in which a 2 tier system is created and this gives birth to the death of the comprehensive ideal.

  1. There are two main types of electoral system in the UK:First Past the Post ...

    The number of constituency seats won under the First Past the Post election and the number won under the Additional Member System in Scotland in 1999 were: Party Constituency Seats Regional or 'List' seats Total Labour 53 3 56 Liberal Democrat 12 5 17 Scottish Nationalist 7 28 35 Conservative

  2. The Labour Party.

    not conform to the normal political ideas expressed by other parties and by the media. For many years now they have supported the Labour Party ahead of the Conservative Party, and in both the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly are in power via a coalition with Labour i.e.

  1. What is the main reason for the loss of faith and interest in our ...

    negative spin if they so wish, and it is also worth noting that most newspaper have an editorial political bias, which means that they are more likely to emphasise scandals which involve the opposing party. The only real restraints that they have are ethics committees, and the Laws involved with

  2. Electoral Systems.

    Research by Democratic Audit in 1997 showed that the results could actually be even more distorting than under First-Past-The-Post. * It also does very little to give a voice to those who have been traditionally under-represented in parliament. * There is no transfer of powers from party authority to the voters, and it does not produce a proportional parliament.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work