• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does the UK have a Prime Ministerial government?

Extracts from this document...


Does the UK have a Prime Ministerial Government? (40marks) The Prime Minister is very much a staple of British politics today and it can be seen in the last thirty years that there has been a power shift in UK politics very much in favour of the Prime Minister. Traditionally, the UK government operated under a theoretical system known as cabinet government which is basically the idea that all members of the cabinet should have an equal say in policy making with the Prime Minister being 'first among equals' in the cabinet. However, in recent times it can be seen that the UK government has moved to a system known as Prime Ministerial government which is when a prime minister uses its powers and influence to dominate all areas of government including the dictation of government policy. It can be seen that the powers of patronage the Prime Minister has, the control and bypass of the cabinet by the PM and the fact that the PM is in appearance the head of the country, all of which suggest a move towards a prime ministerial government in recent years. However, it can be argued that whilst the PM appears to be all dominant in fact the PM still relies on the support of its cabinet, its party and the strength of its party in parliament or in other words the success of the PM. ...read more.


Another way in which it could be seen that we operate under a PM government is appearance of the prime minister as a supposed head of the country. In recent years there has been an increased media focus on the PM (even leading to puppet parodies which can be seen to represent the national mood at the time) making them the focal point or at least seem to be of British politics, the increased media focus has also led to many voters voting for the prime minister candidate rather than the party they represent which also leads to more power as it shows the PM to be instantly recognisable and important so it commands respect. An example of the Media focus on the prime minister which made him more powerful as they would be seen as the figure head of the government is Blair coming out of the G8 meeting to address the nation and to drive to downing street to sort it out after 7/7 which made him more powerful as he was seen to care and be able to take action. Another way the PM appears to be the head of the country is in foreign policy, Prime ministers can be seen to be the head of foreign policy in terms of conflicts diplomacy and such for example, Blair is often seen as the man who made the decision to invade Iraq and Afghanistan which gives him the appearance of being ...read more.


The PM chooses all of the ministers and junior ministers and all who sit in cabinet so whether the MPs progress in their political career relies on the favour to the PM thereby ensuring support of the PM from the lower down MPs and if they do not support the PM they are forced to resign for example MP John Hutton was forced to resign after saying Labour under Brown would be a '****ing disaster*' which shows that whilst people may argue that PMs need support from its ministers it can be seen equally or more so that ministers need the support of a PM which shows a move to PM government as it show the PM making the decisions and also controlling its party. In conclusion, it seems that there has indeed been a move towards PM government in recent years especially considering both Thatcher and Blairs premierships and whilst it may be said that the style of government depends on the personality of the Prime Minister traits of a PM government still remained in the premierships of the likes of Brown and Major so overall its clear to certain extent that there has been a move to a Prime Ministerial government. However it does seem that this is facilitated by the party and the cabinet so one may argue that whilst indeed it is a Prime Ministerial government it is supported and facilitated by the government it is perceived to dominate. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. priministers power

    Too many dismissals create the impression that the Prime Minister is nervous, or not in control, or heads a divided Cabinet. Macmillan's ' night of the long knives', the dismissal of half his Cabinet, made him appear panicky and weak.'

  2. To what extent does the prime minister dominate the UK political system?

    Campbell was simply announcing a decision Blair had already made, giving the cabinet little choice but to agree. However the most well known example is the Iraq War. In 2003, Blair persuaded the cabinet to go to war despite huge doubts in the Government, leading to the resignation of two ministers.

  1. Prime Ministerial Government

    Throughout Blair's duration he had the power to sack Frank Dobson, Michael Meacher and Glenda Jackson. At the later part of last year, Brown exerted his power of patronage by having a re-shuffle in his Cabinet due to the slumping poll rating of Labour.

  2. Increase in Prime Ministerial power in recent years?

    This was a presidential-style shift by Blair who spent little time in the House of Commons; Blair even admitted he "never pretended to be a great House of Commons man" portraying that Blair preferred more of a presidential style of governance increasing his power as prime minister.

  1. Is it true to say that the UK now features Prime Ministerial rather than ...

    the whole cabinet, and instead opted for a more direct and quicker approach by selecting a handful of ministers who would be relevant to discuss the topic in hand, making the role of the cabinet very similar to a committee.

  2. A constant theme of modern British Politics is whether or not prime ministerial government ...

    Cabinet government consists of a collective executive where members share in decisions and are held to be collectively responsible. It is also the peak institution in a classified and centralised government system. The Prime Minister is the head of the cabinet and is more than the first among equals, but

  1. Comment upon the view that we are now living in an era of Prime ...

    However, some ministers such as those with responsibility for Transport or the Cabinet Office come and go depending on the importance attached to their particular portfolio by the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister controls various committees, including Standing committees, which during Margaret Thatcher's rule were concerned with matters such as economic strategy and overseas defence policy.

  2. Politics, Tony Blair's of ruling

    Blair has imposed a tough disciplinary regime on his 419 MP's; on 7 May 1997 he lectured them on the need for strength, unity and discipline, and said he would not tolerate 'juvenile oppositionists'. Blair announced without any consultation that Prime Minister's question time would be reduced from two fifteen-minute

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work