• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Employee Relations and Trade Union Recognition Within The Catering Sector.

Extracts from this document...


HRM 3005 Employee Relations Assignment Two - Employee Relations and Trade Union Recognition Within The Catering Sector Name: Claire Duff Student Number: Year: 4 Course: BA Business Studies Marking Tutors: Billie Osbourne and Dorothy Foote Introduction For The Attention Of The Human Resources Director The hotel and catering industry represents around 10% of the working population of this country. Two and half million in total. Conversely it is seen as a principle industry in many other countries. Within the UK, historic sites and counties which depend heavily on tourism, such as Cornwall and Devon, also rely heavily on this sector of industry to provide the services required. Without this added aid popular hotels would cease to function properly and other groups within the business world would suffer a knock on effect from lack of trade. So although the hotel and catering industry is a specific thing many other issues depend upon its success. With this in mind I am going to investigate the pros and cons and implications of instigating a potential claim for recognition of a trade union both now and in the future. This report has been completed after I have research and read copious papers on the subject. Terms and Conditions There are many reasons why the terms and conditions remain so poor within the catering and hotel industry. The main factor for any employee is obviously the pay and hours of work. Unfortunately, within this sector of industry, pay is substantially lower than in many other areas of business, with 30% of hotel and catering workers earning �3.60 per hour and with 50% earning less than �4.50 per hour. ...read more.


However due to the high job turn over, many people do not believe that trade unions really belong within the hotel and catering sector of business. Perhaps this is the reason why only 6% of the industry are trade union members. Finally the catering sector fills that it does not have the bargaining power that other industries have. For example the gas workers have the ability to paralyse the whole of industry in a way that the caterers would never be able to do. Managers Reluctance Towards Trade Unions From research it has been established that employers and managers within the hotel and catering sector are generally hostile towards trade unions. This skepticism has always been in the industry and in 1970 a commission on industrial relations acknowledged these findings. Managers see trade unions as a way to disrupt or interfere with the smooth running of their hotel/restaurant. "Managers disliked unions because they interfered with their prerogative, slowed down the decision making process, created dual sources of authority within the organization, were opportunistic and unsympathetic to and ignorant of the way in which the industry worked." (Trade unions in the hotel and catering industry, The views of hotel managers, Employee Relations, Bradford 1993, Volume 15, Issue 2, Start Page 61.) In the hotel and catering industry it is generally recognized it is the manager's responsibility to see that the employees are properly looked after and are getting job satisfaction. It is felt that the unions do not have the ability to add any more value to this situation. Also individual managers are allowed to run their hotels as they see fit which, could, if unions flex their muscles, contradict policies from the organizations head office. ...read more.


These benefits would also help the organization as a higher percentage of employee loyalty will be achieved and the need for continuous recruitment would decrease as job turn over should decline. The aim of the committee is to show the employees that management care and share their concerns. This would be the same function that a trade union representative would perform. With the committee in place an individual can raise a specific problem personally. Thereby nullifying the need for a trade union. Listed below are many factors that show the implementation of a trade union is not in the best interest of the organization. Employees * There are dual negotiation rights (two unions) * Poor employee recognition of the union (only 6%) * Employees question value for money * High percentage of casual / part time workers * High job turn over Employer * Disrupts the smooth running of an organization * No value for the employer * Unskilled labour equals low pay In conclusion I do not feel that increasing trade union membership within the hotel and catering industry is in our best interest. I also strongly believe that it is against the wishes of the majority of the employees within this sector. With my above proposals, which can be implemented with little expenditure, we as a company could sustain an enhanced relationship between us and our employees, without having to resort to involving trade unions. Although I wished to be pro-active towards implementing a trade union and hoped to advise on possible strategies to ease such a transition I find that the evidence is overwhelmingly against such a step. I feel it would be a dereliction of my duty to you and the board if I put forward a different solution. Richard. J. Hughes. Employee Relations Manager. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Trade Unions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Trade Unions essays

  1. Explain fully and clearly the importance of negotiation within industrial relations to resolve disputes

    The teachers want to increase the amount of London Allowance, as teachers in London cannot afford to live due to the high costs of living. Renting and owning property is very expensive and many teachers find it possible to pay their rent or mortgage due to the London Allowance.

  2. How far was the development of trade union rights hindered by divisions within the ...

    in the first decade of the twentieth century, a series of Supreme Court decisions further impeded attempts to give workers their rights, a prime example being Lochner v. New York (1905). To make the situation even worse for the workers, some factory owners even placed federal injunctions on unions that

  1. Account for the much lower level of strike incidence in Britain in recent years. ...

    They conclude that the economic effects of the legislation have been limited and, to some extent, perverse. The government's legislation affecting strikes therefore, seems not to have been a main reason for the decline in strike action. But it has changed the legal framework affecting strikes.

  2. Growth and Decline in Size and Density of Australian Trade Unionism.

    The peak of union membership occurred during the time when manufacturing plants were in operation with large scale of employees employed (ACTU 1999, p 7). Unions easily recruited new members during these times. Now days, manufacturing plants have decreased in numbers as have other industries: agriculture, mining, manufacturing, metal and maritime.

  1. Select any ONE U.K.trade union. Explore their current levels of membership, and services for ...

    officers and professional experts, not only in the workplace, but also within the UK and European Parliaments". 3 In addition to the massive financial, legal and industrial back up provided by Amicus, members are able to take advantage of a range of specially negotiated benefits and services.

  2. Describe and analyse the key developments in British industrial relations over the past 20 ...

    In his address to the 2002 TUC Congress, Bill Morris, member of the TUC's General Council with lead responsibility for employment law, said: "Today, I can report that the new Trade Union recognition scheme has been a success story ...

  1. What were the main effects of the 1979-1997 Conservative governments’ reforms to collective ...

    (Salamon pg293) For this reason since New Labour came to power in 1997 the government has heavily legislated in many areas, and employment has not been excluded from this. One act in particular has directly impacted on Collect Labour Law, which is:- The Employment Relations Act 1999.

  2. Discuss the view that industrial relations represents a redundant and anachronistic form of management ...

    Drawing on examples from Visser's (1994) work on industrial relations across Europe several examples of collectivism and effective trade-union action can be identified in countries where government legislation is less restrictive than it is here in the United Kingdom. Belgium and Denmark have both recorded increases in union density throughout

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work