• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate the claim that the Senate is far more powerful than the House of Representatives within congress

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluate the claim that the senate is far for powerful than the House of Representatives within congress (30 marks) When the founding fathers set out the powers and limits of the House of Representatives and the Senate, they created a bicameral system with power shared between the two houses. Whilst it would be ideal for the 2 houses to have equal power and status, it is often argued that The Senate is more powerful than the House of Representatives. Is the Senate more prestigious and important in status and are Senators more powerful than Representatives? Some would argue not, The House of Representatives and Senate whilst each having exclusive powers, also have equal and concurrent powers in the passing of legislature, this makes the two houses equal unlike the bicameral legislative system in the UK. This equal sharing of power as set out by the Framers shows that Senate isn't more important than the House of Representatives in the passing of legislature. ...read more.

Middle

The Senate judiciary committee who have to approve all federal judges. These powers are seen as more important than the exclusive powers of the House of Representatives such as the initiation of money bills. Another indicator to the powerful status of The Senate is the benefits enjoyed by Senators, those of wider name recognition, both state-wide and nationwide such as Senator John McCain and also benefits such as a longer 6 year term, meaning they are not constantly under the pressure of re-election. They also appear to have a more important job through representing an entire state as opposed to only a congressional district. Senators are also benefited by the difference in membership numbers of The Senate and the House of Representatives, whilst a representative is one out of 435; a Senator is only one out of a hundred. This makes it a lot more likely for a Senator to chair a committee; an example of this is when the number of committees ...read more.

Conclusion

seen as more important as people see it as the next stepping stone from The House, and not as an equal part of Congress. In conclusion, whilst the powers of the Senate and House of Representatives are often equal and were created as equal parts of Congress - in reality the powers of the Senate have increased. This could be due to the increased need for foreign policy, meaning the power of ratifying treaties is more significant than when the Constitution was first written in the 18th century. The benefits enjoyed by Senators and the appearance of it as a promotion from The House, make it appear more important and powerful, however the increase in its importance and the prestigious ness is not in correlation with the increase in power - meaning that whilst the Senate appears a lot more powerful than the House of Representatives, a lot of this is appearance and the actual powers of the Senate haven't changed that much. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United States section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Overall this essay makes all the right points but lacks development and evaluation. Rather than write about all the ways that the Houses have equal power and then all the ways they don't, it would aid evaluation and analysis if argument and counter argument were given at the same time. The strength of an answer to a longer question is often determined by the evaluative nature of the essay and the examples and evidence presented to illustrate the points being made. This essay requires stronger examples and more depth.

***

Marked by teacher Jessica Jung 04/04/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United States essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "The Main Difference Between the UK And US Constitution Is That One Is Flexible ...

    4 star(s)

    If there is a conflict between any ordinary law and a constitutional law, the latter must prevail. At this point the Supreme Court was empowered with judicial review. This meant it could review any decision made by any part of government (apart from constitutional amendments) and deem them unconstitutional.

  2. "The conflicting interests of the Great Powers made its failure inevitable." Discuss this verdict ...

    People have different perspectives and wishes, and the Congress System wasn't any different. The common purpose of this congress was to ensure that Napoleon would never come back again, thus maintaining peace. But with Napoleon across the ocean on St Helena, with no chance of coming back, this common purpose was extinguished.

  1. Do the strengths of the US constitution outweigh its weaknesses?

    For example the Brown V Board of Education 1954, set out to deal with the segregation of Black African Americans from the rest of society via the Bill of Rights which is written into the constitution. Due to this court ruling a precedent has been since set, and many people

  2. Compare and contrast the extent to which the Cabinet has an important part to ...

    This is unlike the UK where the executive is responsible for nearly all legislation and controls the agenda except on 17 days when the opposition can and when time is set aside for PMB's.

  1. "Presidents have only the power to persuade" discuss.

    However, so far he hasn't been that lucky. Presidents who get a chance to appoint are lucky, and they put a lot of time into deciding who they should appoint. The FBI background checks and all the media coverage show it's importance.

  2. "Supreme Court Appointments are always controversial" Discuss

    The main controversial issues of the United States can also be decided in the Supreme Court, for example the issue of abortion. We also saw an effectively landmark case be decided in the Supreme Court, in the Bush v. Gore case, on December 12th 2000, the 2000 Presidential election, was effectively resolved in favour of George W.

  1. The power of the President is limited to the power to persuade. Discuss.

    Finally, in a democracy one of the most significant checks will always be the people- strength of public opinion, for example, against the Vietnam War, probably led to Johnson?s decision not to stand for re-election. In an increasingly media-conscious society, the role of the media and pressure groups is also significant.

  2. Is the USA still a federal state?

    Additionally had the financial crisis of 2008 not occurred would there be a bailout package, would the state intervene in private corporations to recover the economy? Therefore central government did not dominate the US political system for the sake of domination, rather to recover from security and financial events that required large scale intervention.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work