• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine the changes that the continuing development of human resource management has brought about in the organisation with the emergence of trade unions in comparison to the effect from industrial relations.

Extracts from this document...


Abstract: In this topic, we are going to examine the changes that the continuing development of human resource management has brought about in the organisation with the emergence of trade unions in comparison to the effect from industrial relations. The unitarist approach of the human resource management and the pluralist approach by the industrial relations will be highlighted in our study in the survival of trade unions in the organisation. HRM refers to the policies and practices one needs to carry with the direct relationship of people-to-people in accordance with the strategic issues affecting the organization in order to fulfill the management position in the organization including recruiting, screening, training, rewarding, and appraising. HRM is important for all managers in such that that they do not hire the wrong person for the job. (Raymond, J. Stone, pg ? ) Industrial relations is about the behavior and interaction of people at work. It is concerned with how individuals, group organizations and institutions make decision that shape the employment relationship between employers and employees.Industrial relations may be approached from a number of perspectives. Industrial relations draws on a number of established academic disciplines such as economics, sociology, psychology, law, political science and history. ...read more.


Today, few organisations appear to have developped any pro-active HR strategies to encourage managers to take responsibility for managing their human resources. In fact, for monopolistic, tariff-protected and other industries sheltered from global competition, there is an incentive to ignore inefficient work practices and tolerate union excess because costs can be readily passed on to the customer.( Raymond, R. J., Stone, pg 589) . In practice, human resource management often supports the idea for employees to become anti-company and pro-union. Management abuse and neglect ensure that the only way for employees to secure dignity and protection at work is by joining a union. For example, a former union official describes a company where the female secretarial and clerical staffs were constantly tearing their stockings on the dilapidated wooden furniture. Management ignored all complaints until one of the clerks caught a splinter under her kneecap. The frustrated staff walked out and sought union help. Management, confronted with a strike and the union, immediately purchased new furniture. Indeed, this case is a clear indication that the continued development of human resource management often fosters the existence of trade union in the organisation. (Raymond, J. Stone, pg. 590). HRM have stimulated a change from a collectivist and legalistic approach to industrial relations to one emphasising individualism and non-third party involvement. ...read more.


According to Cohen, outside consultants reduces the status of the HR manager in the eyes of the employees, union officials and company management. Because HR managers does not accept direct responsibility for the conduct of negotiation, the HR function is perceived as weak and the HR manager as not having the ability, authority or confidence of top management. Interestingly in Japan, where the HR function is very powerful, outside influence in industrial relations is not tolerated. Indeed, when negotiaitions with unions are viewed as a strategic activity within the organisation and not merely a defensive response to union demands, line managers become much more active in the negotiation process.( Raymond, J. Stone, pg 614) The supporting study of the effect of HRM practices on trade unions clearly indicates that with the HRM policies and practices, trade unions are not bound to cease their significance in the organisation but it is indeed supported with few changes and a new approach to its increasing importance for the equal benefit of both the employer and employees in the organisation. List of referrences: Books: Deery, S.J., Plowman, D., Australian Industrial Relations (3rd edition). Sydney, Australia: Mc Graw-Hill. Plowman, D., Industrial relations ( edition). Raymond, J. Stone, Human Resource Management (4th edition). Queensland, Australia: John Wiley & Sons Australia Ltd. Robbins, S. P. et al, Organisational behaviour (3rd edition). NSW, Australia; Pearson Education Australia. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Trade Unions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Trade Unions essays

  1. Comparison between unitary and pluralist perspectives.

    It can vary in each situation depending on various circumstances. However the more a company accepts and supports the trade union, the more power the trade union will gain due to increased membership. As the pluralist perspective acknowledges rival leadership (trade unions)

  2. I have been asked to inform you, as secretary at Cooper & Courtney Solicitors ...

    When they found freedom and increased pay in Australia, they wanted to bring the idea of unions in nationwide. Unionism began in Australia in the 1840's when transportation ceased and workers did not have to compete with cheap convict labour.

  1. How far was the development of trade union rights hindered by divisions within the ...

    However, disputes between employers and their employees continued to be acrimonious. Moreover, divisions within the trade union movement itself continued to deprive the mass of unskilled workers of their rights. Although its clear divisions still occurred within the labour movement, the Committee on Industrial Organisation (CIO)

  2. Employee Organisations & Unions

    They classed it in the same category as pension provisions and holiday pay. If anything, they said, the number of people taking so-called "sickies" was dropping and they were against any plan that increased pressure on workers to come in when unwell.

  1. Explain fully and clearly the importance of negotiation within industrial relations to resolve disputes

    All businesses need to recognise that discrimination in society is widespread and that employment practices often discriminate against groups of employees, particularly women and ethnic minority workers. Trade unions campaign for justice for people who face discrimination at work and they advise employers on ways that they can achieve equal opportunities.

  2. What were the main effects of the 1979-1997 Conservative governments’ reforms to collective ...

    At this time the party also adopted "The Third Way". This replaced the previous Corporatist ideology behind the party. The Third Way is a 'middle ground' between the traditional socialist views of the old left wing party and the right-wing views held by the Conservatives.

  1. Conflict at work: Industrial Disputes

    An indication of the cancellation of industrial action on the part of the baggage handlers is the retreat of Servisair on the matter, who supposedly stated, in order to cool the matter, that in fact there would be no redundancies, but added that they could not offer any guarantees beyond the end of the summer.

  2. Discuss the view that industrial relations represents a redundant and anachronistic form of management ...

    Drawing on examples from Visser's (1994) work on industrial relations across Europe several examples of collectivism and effective trade-union action can be identified in countries where government legislation is less restrictive than it is here in the United Kingdom. Belgium and Denmark have both recorded increases in union density throughout

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work