• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explain the Success and Failure of Constitutions.

Extracts from this document...


Explain the Success and Failure of Constitutions Constitutions can be defined in a variety of different ways. Duchacek , in 1970 described constitutions as "power maps", in which the formal powers of the state are described and distributed. A more explicit definition can be gauged from Robertson , who describes the constitution as, "a set of rights, powers and procedures regulating the structure of, and relationships among the public authorities and between the public authorities and the citizens." This long definition is condensed by Watson , who describes constitutions as the "rules of the political game" and "the laws that govern the governors." Constitutions usually have come into existence to facilitate a "fresh start" following the demise of the past regime via revolution, independence, or a change in society. Constitutions are not infallible and can fail if the conditions are right; those conditions will be discussed in this essay. ...read more.


Even supposedly rigid, written constitutions can respond to changes in society, an important property if that constitution is to succeed. In the United States, judicial constitutional interpretation plays an important part in placing a constitution written over two hundred years ago into the context of the modern day. Chief Justice Hughes' statement; "We live under a constitution. But the constitution is what the judges say it is." This may not be wholly accurate, but judicial interpretation has been an important factor in the continual evolution of the American Constitution, which encouraging its success. Finally, the success of constitutions can be attributed to the economic factors within the state. Germany and Japan have for the past fifty years possessed successful constitutions, which can, to a degree be attributed to their very strong economies. Following the Second World War, the allies, by buoying up the economies of these two nations, prevented them from falling to the short-term problems, such as nationalism and communism. ...read more.


Many of the fledgling governments fell, as single rulers, often helped by the military filled the vacuum. Countries whose democratic governments survived, for example India and Pakistan experienced the move toward strong centrally controlled government, undermining the democracy the constitution represented. It is often not the constitution that fails, but the regime that facilitates the change because it is weak, and cannot remain in office for too long a period. The constitution may succeed in providing the checks and balances of power, but if the regime lost the support of the military, there would then be scope for change Constitutions are not always liable to succeed; the above examples indicate that. A successful one allows change, can be interpreted by the judiciary and is assisted by a healthy economic climate. A failure is doomed to be ineffective because it is too restrained, and not allowed to change as society develops. Explanations for the success and failure of constitutions can be diverse, particularly in today's global society; the reasons above are only a selection of what can constitute a constitutional success or failiure. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United States section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United States essays

  1. Federalism essay

    Like Germany, the Constitution of the United States is built around the concept of the separation of powers and a system of checks and balances. This Constitution was drawn up in 1787 by the Founding Fathers, to replace the weak confederation that had existed since the Declaration of Independence.

  2. Castlereagh had limited success in the context of British Foreign Policy between 1815 and ...

    Castlereagh was aware that if you were too harsh on a country then they may feel the need to look for revenge at a later date.

  1. Identify and explain all the factors which encouraged and discouraged change during 1863-77

    As a response to the Thirteenth Amendment the south introduced the Black Codes, this certainly discouraged any change. Black Codes intended to avoid the extension of voting rights to freed slaves. The intention of these codes was to make sure that African Americans never acquired land or property.

  2. How is Britain's constitution changing in the 21st century?

    If Britain does choose to become more integrated with Europe, the British constitution could be surrendered for a European one. Some EU members favour the idea of a European scaffold of rules, yet equally there are adversaries. Cohn-Bendit is adamant on this issue, 'Europe must have its own constitution, it is essential to Europe' (Cohn-Bendit, 2000).

  1. US Constitution Definition of Terms

    It was argued that the Elastic Clause gave Congress the power to establish a National Bank to hold the money. It allows Congress to pass laws that are needed as time changes. It was a point of much contention between those who favoured a loose reading of the Constitution and those who favoured a strict reading.

  2. presidential power how far does it go

    Hence, all three branches of the government have signed on to the fact that the original assumption that the United States is at war, and the reign of normalcy is temporarily suspended. The second step is to look at particulars.

  1. Assess the view that the US Constitution often ensures limited government

    They are the first 10 amendments to the constitution, ratified by the states in 1791, and are guaranteed constitutional rights, entrenched in the constitution[24]. Although called the Bill of Rights, these 10 amendments are essentially a ?bill of limits?, because the amendments limit the powers of the national government over the rights and liberties of individuals.

  2. American Government Term Paper #1. Discuss the theory of Checks and Balances as outlined ...

    Constitutional interpretation is not a mechanical enterprise. It requires judges to exercise judgment. It calls upon them to consider text, history, precedent, values, changing social, economic, technological, and cultural conditions, and the practical realities of the times.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work