• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"His contribution to the cause of Italian unification was negligible." How valid is this assessment of Mazzini.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Michaeljohn Kalakoutis IB History HL Mr. Hengstler December 11, 2005 "His contribution to the cause of Italian unification was negligible." How valid is this assessment of Mazzini. Giuseppe Mazzini, the founder of the revolutionary party, "Young Italy" during the build up to the Italian unification, is regarded through different perspectives. Mazzini is considered by some historians to be an idealistic, intellectual man, but by many Italian historians as "nothing by a terrorist" (page 18). These two antithetic opinions on Mazzini, define whether his contribution to the cause of Italian unification was in fact negligible or not. Mazzini was an intellectual man, whose political opinions were of much controversy and whose actions raise question marks over his motives and his significance in the unification of Italy. Giuseppe Mazzini's contrasting opinions on important matters such as the Monarchy, the Catholic Church and Christianity and the People greatly affected his influence and popularity in Italy, as well as people's opinions of himself. ...read more.

Middle

Mazzini preached that Christianity should be replaced by democracy and that God was no longer speaking through the scriptures of the Church, but through the people of Italy. Thus, God's will was what the people wanted, which was national independence and unity and is the reason Giuseppe founded "Young Italy." Mazzini's main weakness was the lack of support for his secret society, "Young Italy" which was mainly due to his lack of understanding of the peasants' needs. The peasants, making up 80-90% of the population of Italy would have turned Mazzini's "Young Italy" movement from a minority support based revolutionary party, to a popularly supported political party. As Mazzini did not regard the peasants of much importance, it is little wonder why he was widely regarded by many as an anti-revolutionary by the general population of Italians. ...read more.

Conclusion

Perhaps the only consolation Mazzini has of his fruitless efforts to supposedly unite Italy, is that he identified the reason why no Italian revolutions had succeeded. Unity and cooperation amongst the Italian revolutionary parties. "Young Italy is Unitarian because without unity there is no true nation." (Page 15) Mazzini identified the point of weakness in the failed attempts of Italian revolutionaries however he was never once successful in his own efforts, which is why his motives and actions are a topic of debate amongst historians. Mazzini's tendency to contradict himself, for instance by opposing the Monarchy yet requesting to work in collaboration with the Monarch, justifies certain views that Mazzini was a nuisance to the bid for Italian Unification. Giuseppe Mazzini can be considered a "dangerous enemy of free and united Italy" (page 17) whom had made "frantic efforts to keep the country divided," (page 17) and his contributions to the cause of Italian unification can be considered negligible. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Communism VS Democracy

    One critical distinction must be made regarding Berger&rsquos understanding of the term, and that is that the term democracy does not include all the civil and human rights associated with liberal democracy(Daniels) Similarly, by capitalism, this work will not use any other connotation of the term other than describing the

  2. Evolution of Democracy and the Athenian Constitution

    of his incorruptibility his friends and associates like Aspasia and Pheidias were tried and persecuted by his opponents on false charges. When things went against the Athenians in the Peloponnesian War they, in their anger, voted to end his command and fine him (Plutarch, p: 202).

  1. Marxism Can Only Be Appreciated Retrospectively

    the workers are unhappy as they have no choice but to work for the capitalists and are not able to chose what they want to do with their lives. Marx believed the exchange value of a product reflects that the quality and variety of Work that has gone into it's production but has not been accounted for.

  2. Of all the individuals involved in the unification of Italy, none played a more ...

    He was immensely intelligent but nevertheless suffered from great depression. He turned his thoughts to politics and becoming a revolutionary nationalist when he was sixteen during the aftermath of the 1821 revolution in Piedmont. He was inspired by the idea of political devotion to the cause.

  1. Pat Parker & Associates

    "Copyright law provides that "work for hire" be expressly agreed on in writing as being "specifically ordered or commissioned". [1] While a contract was completed between Parker and the Democratic Party, the terms of that contract are subject to debate as to how copyright should be interpreted.

  2. Russia's Political Party System as an Obstacle to Democratization

    outcome of these elections than they had in previous election years (McFaul 2000b, 14-15).3 Although space constraints preclude an extended discussion of the development of local and regional political structures, suffice it to note that politics at this level is organized around informal "parties of power"-networks of local elites, such

  1. What are the similarities and differencesbetween the sciences and the arts as intellectual discipli.

    It's explanations fall far short of what would be needed to satisfy human curiosity. Religion, in general, does a much better job of explaining what needs to be explained about human nature. However, Scientists in recent years have attempted to give their work a status of being unquestionably correct.

  2. What is meant by the Clash of Civilisations? What criticisms can be made of ...

    Therefore there is no conflict between civilizations and only the local conflict in which Chechens desire independent state from Russia. To support further, we can argue, Basks separatists or the IRA are not seen as part of different Civilization and so their separatist attempts are not seen as the wars

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work