• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How effective is the House of Commons as a check on the executive?

Extracts from this document...


How effective is the House of Commons as a check on the executive? What is meant by the effectiveness of the commons check on the executive is basically, how able is the house of commons to prevent the Government (executive) from getting its own way or forcing its will upon the people of Britain. In theory the commons level of effectiveness is constant as each Member of Parliament has an opinion on every bill or motion that is put forward that is based on conscience. This is not practicable, however, as the party system and the party whips change this. The whips tell MPs which way to vote and can impose sanctions upon those MPs who rebel against the government. Therefore when considering the effectiveness of the commons as a check on the executive one must consider how that effectiveness can change with each general election. For example, John Major was extremely limited in the power he could exercise as Prime Minister as his the Tory party was the biggest party by only twelve seats and so he could easily be outvoted if a policy was widely opposed. ...read more.


Not all ninety six voted against the government at the same time though and so were not able to inflict a defeat. The largest rebellion saw one hundred and twenty one Labour MPs vote against war in Iraq. Ultimately though Blair's huge majority has prevented his legislation being defeated and so the executive has still been getting its way. The best chance for the government to be defeated was only last week. Charles Clarke's (home secretary) anti-terrorism bill scraped through parliament by a mere fourteen votes. The Liberal Democrats, who hold forty six seats, failed to appear in parliament for this vote and as such passed up the opportunity to veto Labour's legislation and inflict an embarrassing defeat upon Tony Blair in the run up to the election. In the commons the opposition is able to question government policy and raise public awareness about issues. The idea of the opposition party is that it constantly pushes and questions the executive and prevents the government simply doing as it pleases. However, given the recent performance of the Conservative party one could be forgiven for not realising that this was the case. ...read more.


They are designed in this way to be non-confrontational and all members of the committee put aside ideological differences when sitting on one in order to check on the Executive. One of the most well known or prominent such committees is the Departmental Select Committee for Transport, of which the outspoken labour rebel and personal enemy of Tony Blair, Gwyneth Dunwoody is chairwoman. The reports published by such committees are an example of effective checking on the executive as the government must give great consideration to the findings of the committee's reports. In conclusion I think that it is fair to say the effectiveness of the common's check on the executive is variable and dependent on certain conditions. There are times when opposition parties wield far greater power than the Conservatives currently do but there are other measures in place to check on the executive when opposition parties do not do so effectively. Despite the best efforts of party leaders and whips, there will always be those who vote for what they believe in and so ultimately there will always be some sort of check exerted upon the executive by the commons, however weak. 1,134 words. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "The House of Commons is a highly effective parliamentary chamber" to what extent do ...

    4 star(s)

    Another strength of the legislative system is that it provides lots of good opportunities for scrutiny of bills. Which means, although it contradicts my first point, governments do not always get their own way. The committee stage is a particularly good opportunity for detailed line-by-line scrutiny of a bill, where anomalies in the bill can be identified and amendments suggested.

  2. Electing MPs to the House of Commons.

    They got 15.8% of the vote in Scotland, and only 1.7% of the seats. The Liberal Democrats got 22.6% of the Scottish vote and a similar share of the seats (18.6%) because they had strong support in a few constituencies and minimal support in most of the others.

  1. How effective is Parliament as a check on the executive?

    Labour's election victory in 2005 saw them win 356 seats (out of 647) with just 36% of the vote. By comparison, the Conservatives and Lim Dems won 198 and 62 seats respectively with a similar share of the overall vote.

  2. Government & Politics Revision Notes

    * Small Party's have too much power- In a multiparty system a small party can be in a position to determine the composition of the ruling coalition. For example, if one large party wins 42% of the seats and another 38%, and a small party wins 20%, that gives the

  1. The Assassins A man, who is about thirty years old, was sitting at an ...

    He climbed three steps in one stride. He activated the helicopter and flew out of the unknown place to prime minister's house. The prime minister returned from a long day of doing...things to make the country a better place. He tried to contact Archilles for five hours but he didn't pick up the phone.

  2. The Vampires Attack As he walked up the rickety ...

    As you well know folklore tells us that they can be harmed by these things." The two men started testing out their new weapons on the Vampire, who appeared to get weaker with every weapon. After the crucifix and holy water the vampire had little life left in him if any and after the crucifix he seemed dead.

  1. Is the House of Commons effective at carrying out its various functions?

    This is quite an effective function as each piece of legislature is read very carefully line by line by the House of Commons, this is then sent to the legislation committee and amendments will be made, this is then sent back to the House of Commons, and the amendments are usually followed.

  2. Explain how Departmental Select Committees act as a check upon the government

    Some of these reports have influenced future policy. An example of a report is the report on the Inaction on Dangerous Dogs by the Environment Committee. They criticised the Government over their apparent inaction following a spate of well publicised dog attacks which have had several fatalities.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work