• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How Far Can the Weimar Constitution be Described as Creating an "Effective" Democracy

Extracts from this document...


How Far Can the Weimar Constitution be Described as Creating an "Effective" Democracy? For the first time in the history of Germany, the state was a democratic republic. The constitution was something of a fragile experiment, a guinea pig. Theoretically speaking, the Weimar Constitution could be described as the most democratic constitution the world has ever laid eyes upon, in practice, things were not as clear. Germany was to be a "Federal State," with each "Lander," (state) retaining limited control over local affairs. This recognised local differences within Germany, with each Lander being represented in the Reichstrat. Effectively small states had as much influence as bigger states. This system allowed for the Reichstrat to be a microcosm of German society, with local diversity taken into account, which is of course extremely democratic, because all citizens no matter how remote had somebody representing their local needs. The Reichstag was extremely democratic because the German public elected members of the Reichstag. Universal suffrage for adults over the age of 20, meant that every body, had a vote, to decide who gained a seat. ...read more.


that a democracy is not a dictatorship.) The president appointed the chancellor according to whether or not he had the support of the Reichstag, which was in turn a representation of society. People voted the Reichstag, the majority of which had to support the Chancellor. So assuming that the people agree on who should be the chancellor, with their representatives in the Reichstag, the president appoints the chancellor based on support of the people, which is very democratic. The peoples will prevailed with regard to who the president appointed as chancellor regardless of whether or not the president himself supported him, i.e. Hindenburgs appointment of Hitler as chancellor. Thus the people indirectly chose chancellor as opposed to the president; this is democratic. The president could dissolve the Reichstag and hold new elections if he didn't like the policies of the chancellor, allowing the chancellor to be held politically accountable to the people. Political accountability means that people account whether the situation is good or bad, based on their personal analysis they vote. This is democratic. Article 48 Emergency powers, existed to protect the democratic system, in the case of stale mate, or political grid lock, article 48 could be used to push through a policy, allowing the democratic process to progress. ...read more.


Extreme parties controlling power, means that the minority, is controlling the majority which is the opposite of democracy, whilst voter fatigue means that the Reichstag and thus chancellor do not actually reflect the views of the people, which is undemocratic. The Reichstrat system allowed tiny states, to have as much representation and thus influence as bigger states, meaning that the few people in the small states between have as much influence and power between them, as all the people in the big states put together; which is entirely undemocratic. The Bill of Rights, with minimum wages, caused disputes with employers and workers having to sit down and arbitrate wages. This actually led to unemployment as employers were forced to cut labour costs, so were employing more people. So it effectively lowers the rights of the workers, undemocratic. So to conclude, whilst the constitution was extremely democratic in theory, the things that made it so democratic in theory like proportional representation, in practice led to plurality and diversity of governments causing an ineffective democracy for most of the length of its existence. ?? ?? ?? ?? How Far Can the Weimar Constitution be Described as Creating an "Effective" Democracy? Clive Freedman Page 4 of 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Power and Politics in Organizations: Public and Private Sector Comparisons

    Above all, these managers of the future will construct different information and learning networks inside and outside the firm, ones designed to bolster their own organizational capacity. In short, comparative advantage will be in part the result of incorporating and rendering operational some of the leadership qualities reviewed in this chapter.

  2. Evolution of Democracy and the Athenian Constitution

    were instituted last and had the responsibility of the codification and preservation of the law. By this time all the offices were annual with the nine Archons selected from the aristocracy only on the basis of birth and wealth qualifications.

  1. Communism VS Democracy

    In modern democracies, supreme authority is exercised for the most part by representatives elected by popular suffrage. The representatives may be supplanted by the electorate according to the legal procedures of recall and referendum, and they are, at least in principle, responsible to the electorate.

  2. Does democracy bring peace?

    the universal extent it is capable; it would extirpate the system of war." Much of commercial pacifists' beliefs can be traced back to 18th century writer Adam Smith. Smith argued that the "wealth of a neighbouring nation, though dangerous in war and politics, is certainly advantageous in trade.

  1. Did Athenian democracy erode popular belief in divination? If so why?

    For example, in Herodotus, the Greeks more often than not, consult oracles before debating on the subject of whether military action should be undertaken. This is illustrated by the Delphic oracle of the wooden walls, which determines whether the Athenians should attack the Persians from their wooden ships, or hide

  2. Socialist uses of workers' inquiry

    Our insistence on the importance of inquiry on the spot (hot inquiry) is grounded on a basic assumption: an antagonistic society can never reduce one of its basic constituent elements - the working class - to homogeneity. Therefore it is necessary to study the extent to which it is possible

  1. Is consociational democracy democratic?

    In all democracies power is necessarily divided to some extents between the central and non-central governments in order to avoid a concentration of power25. The 'consociational' school, inspired by the writings of Tocqueville, sees decentralisation of power as the essence of democratic government26.

  2. How Far Can the Weimar Constitution be Described as Creating an "Effective" Democracy

    To add to the argument for political stability during this period, there were no political assassinations compared to the murders of Walther Rathenau & Mattias Erzberger under the "white terror," regime (1921.) The lack of political assassinations combined with the fact that only 50 people died in this period in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work