• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Israel And Her Neighbours 1945 - c.1994.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Israel And Her Neighbours 1945 - c.1994. Assignment 2. Question a. Source A shows two women demonstrating outside the Israeli Embassy in 1973. One of the women is a Palestinian Arab who was born in Palestine and the other is an American Jew who was born in America. They are holding signs which state how the rule of "right to return" affects them. The message they are trying to get across seems to be that it is unfair that an Arab who was born in Palestine and considers it his/her home should not be able to live there, while the Jew, born in America can. The fact that the two women are demonstrating side by side, and fighting for the same cause with the same views shows that the Jews and Arabs are not all that different and some are able to get along and agree. Source B is an extract taken from a historical book describing the great differences between Arabs and Jews. The writer's view is that the two peoples differ so much in language, religion, culture, conduct and social behaviour that they could not possibly live together as one nation. The messages of the two sources are quite conflicting, as source B states that "there is no common ground between them", meaning that they are so different in every way that it would be impossible for them to get along, while source A contradicts this and proves that it is possible for Arabs and Jews to agree, and to act together in the same way. ...read more.

Middle

However, as it is a piece of political propaganda written by Jewish politicians, so therefore biased towards the Jews. It is not a useful source if you want to know about the real feelings and ideas of ordinary Jewish people in Palestine and also the Arab point of view. Source G is by a Palestinian Arab writer who grew up in one of the refugee camps outside Israel. He is talking about the experience of ordinary Palestinian Arabs living for a long period in the refugee camps, and always longing to return to their homeland. I think it is much more useful that source F in helping us understand about the feelings of a lot of ordinary people involved in the conflict. It is useful as it could help us understand why so many Palestinians chose to stay un the camps instead of being given homes somewhere else, and why the Palestinian national feeling is still strong. It is a first hand account, which does not talk about pride and right of lands, only the wish to return. On the other hand, source G is just the opinion of one person while source F represents the views of a group of Jewish leaders. Both these sources do however, give us an insight into the nature of the problem, and help us to understand what was going through the minds of many people at the time. ...read more.

Conclusion

I believe that the Jews definitely deserve a homeland of their own, and as is mentioned in source F, Palestine is holly for the Jews but you have to consider that in 1948, it was not theirs to claim, as it was already the home of many more Palestinian Arabs. Taking all this into consideration it is very difficult to decide who has a greater claim to Palestine, as both sides have a strong argument. But it is the only home to people and it is not fair that either should be left without a home to return to. However, I still believe that the Arabs have a greater claim for the land, because although the Jews had lived their many centuries ago, and claim it was given to them by God, they had no right to take it from the current inhabitants in 1948. Nevertheless the fact that the Arabs have even less land now, I think is partly due to them, because their attempts to overthrow Israel failed numerous times, and because of these failures and constant hostility and threats to Israel and also the fact that Israel won. Israel was able to take other parts of Palestine that had belonged to the Arabs. This has made the situation much worse for now the Palestinian Arabs live in refugee camps along the boarder, with no really land to call their home. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Middle east section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Middle east essays

  1. What are the main differences between the beliefs of Palestinian Arabs and Israeli Jews?The ...

    Jerusalem was now Israeli territory meaning they had their main religious site back. They must have felt safer too as they made their frontiers shorter and easier to defend. They now had control over where the Palestinians lived and how they lived. That was one significant thing for the Palestinians.

  2. History Coursework: The Arab-Israeli Conflict

    I know from my own knowledge that in 1972, 11 Israeli civilians were murdered at the Olympic Games. This tests the reliability. The source was also published in a history book, so is therefore probably reliable. Source E is a non-factual opinion of a "typical" Israeli in the 1970's.

  1. Armed Islamic Group [ Gia ]

    The organization receives financial and logistical aid from Algerian expatriates, many of whom reside in Western Europe. As has Egypt, Algeria has accused Iran and Sudan of supporting the GIA from training camps in Sudan. Most observers believe that Iranian and Sudanese aid to the GIA has probably not been decisive in the GIA's development or its activities.

  2. How did the village of Dier Yassin come to be fought over in 1948, ...

    of a coordinated attempt to force Palestinians out of the homes through the use of terror and fear. In Source A we are told that one of the groups who attacked the village was lead by Begin, who later became president of Israel; the government of Israel therefore in not

  1. There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for The last fifty-five years, do ...

    They claim there was no order for the Palestinians to leave the country so therefore the refugee problem must be that of the Jews. He checked the records and found no evidence that there was a message sent.

  2. Why have the Arabs used

    In source A it shows that Mao-Tse-Tung was successful and achieving China by force and "terrorism". In the source it says that "Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun". This means that they only way to achieve is by "terrorism" and by force.

  1. Why was the State of Israel successfully established in 1948?

    However Britain's post war policy of preventing Jewish immigration to Palestine was also influential in creating sympathy for the Jews especially in America. This was best shown in July 1947, when Britain refused to allow 4,500 Jewish survivors of the Holocaust to land in Palestine.

  2. Assess who or what is to blame for the Palestinian refugee problem

    The source is useful because it says WHY the Arabs are in the wrong, but also admits that some Jews are responsible. The source is not useful because she claims that it is "historically incorrect" to blame Deir Yassin but doesn't say why.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work