• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Palestinian refugee problem - source related study

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem over the last fifty years. Around 700 000 Arabs left their homes in Palestine during the fighting in 1948-9. The fighting was between Israel and the neighbouring Arab states. Most of the Palestinians went to the West Bank and the Gaza strip, though many also went to Lebanon, Syria and Jordan. It is thought that there are about 2.5 million Arab refugees today. After the 1948-9 war, the United Nations formed the UN Relief and Works Agency. This set up camps for the refugees and provided food, clothing, shelter and education. The conditions in the camps were really bad. They were cramped, with several families huddled together in tents without adequate food or sanitation. During the rain, the ground would become muddy, and made tents almost impossible to live in. Clothes and blankets were nearly always wet. Illness and disease was common, with young and old people alike dying of hunger, disease, or because of the cold, wet conditions. Some people said it was like a concentration camp, with very few being able to leave and work elsewhere. The Israeli's claim that it is the responsibility of the Arab states to take in the 700000 Palestinian refugees. However their argument is that they can't afford decent housing, education or health facilities. Also, if the refugees were absorbed into the host nation and stopped being 'Palestinians' then the Israeli's would have 'won'. This is why the camps became permanent. To sort out the refugee problem would take time and money. Many say the Israelis have a responsibility for the welfare of the refugees, and need to put a stop to all the misery and suffering. However the pride of the Palestinians means they won't accept anything less than getting their land back, which the Israelis don't want to do. Because of the awful conditions in the camps, and the pride of both sides, we can begin to understand why some sources were written, and the motives behind them. ...read more.

Middle

However it isn't useful because it is one sided and we don't know if we can trust what it says. It doesn't help us decide who is to blame for the refugee problem because it is only what one person is saying and we don't know if it can be trusted. Source D is an extract from comments made by Palestinian refugees on the work of the UN. It says that they refused houses and compensation from the UN to help them settle in their home countries, because they want 'nothing short of a return to our homeland'. It shows how much pride the Palestinian refugees have, as they want nothing less than getting the land back, which they believe, is rightfully theirs. It is different to the other sources because it is written by refugees, not by outsiders. This could make it more reliable, as they are actually there, however it could also make it unreliable because they are saying what they are for a reason: they want their land back. It is useful because it gives us a reason why the problem still continues - because the Palestinians are stubborn, and won't accept anything but their land back. It is not useful, because it only shows one side, and doesn't give a balanced argument. It also doesn't say anything about how the problem started. Source E is an Israeli view, made by the Israeli ambassador to the UN. It claims the Arabs have let the refugee problem continue for 'political motives'. It says there is plenty of room for the refugees in the 'vast Arab world'. It is blaming the other Arab countries. It says there is enough room for 'a million refugees'. This makes the Arabs look bad, as it looks like they are deceiving people into thinking the refugees have nowhere to go, when actually they have. This makes the Israelis claim to the land stronger as the Palestinians look bad. ...read more.

Conclusion

Arab sources suggest that the Palestinians were forced out of their homes by Israeli's, and that the state of Israel was founded on a war crime and is therefore illegal. They describe 'cold blooded' attacks by Israeli's and the 'massacre' of innocent people. They say that there was 'not a single order, or appeal, or suggestion about the evacuation from Palestine from an Arab radio station inside or outside Palestine in 1948'. This discredits the Israeli claim that the Palestinians were told to leave by their own leaders. Palestinian sources also claim that after the Palestinians were 'forced out' of their homes, they were then 'refused entry back in' by the Israeli's. In the Arab sources, Palestinians are seen as victims, having their lives controlled by Israeli soldiers, and have to resort to 'desperate acts of terror' to have their voices heard. Israeli sources suggest that the Arab leaders told the Palestinians to leave their homes, and that Palestine and Israel are rightfully theirs. They claim that the Jews are under constant threat from uprising Palestinian refugees, who are targeting innocent civilians and using violence to try and get their point across. One Israeli source claims that the refugee problem is being kept alive for political motives, to try and make the Israeli's look bad. It claims that there is 'enough room in the vast Arab world for a million refugees'. All of the sources cannot be completely reliable, because they all seem to have a motive. They don't give a balanced argument for both sides, and their basic aim is to make the other side look bad. It is hard to come to a firm conclusion about who is responsible for the refugee problem, and why it still continues today, because most of the sources contradict each other. There is not enough evidence for either side, to decide who is to blame overall. Ellie New 11WAP There has been a significant Palestinian refugee problem for the last 50 years. Do these sources allow you to come to a firm conclusion about who or what is responsible for the problem? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Middle east section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Middle east essays

  1. Terrorism. What is terrorism? 2. Why do terrorists ...

    Another similar event took place in 2004 when Chechen rebels seized a school in Russia which resulted in more than 200 dead. There have also been other kidnappings in Iraq such as Ken Bigley and two other men were held by Iraqi militants.

  2. Can terrorism ever be a legitimate and effective means of pursuing political goals?

    at reconciliation, in particular the Good Friday Agreement of 1998, violence still plays an important part of Northern Irish politics. This of course is an extremely brief overview of the extremely complex and historic problems that Northern Ireland suffers from but is important in explaining how a terrorist group can have understandable motives for attacking even a seemingly democratic government.

  1. Can Terrorism Be Stopped?

    live in Israel in order to keep them from co-operating with Israeli authorities. Israel as a country cannot be terrorized into disappearing the map although this has been the movement of the Arabs. Does terrorism pay? Can there be any moral justification for an act of terrorism?

  2. The Lebanon Civil War: Syria’s Role in Lebanon

    With that actions of the Army conflicts were became more serious. And all negotiations between neighboring Arabian countries were failed. They were failed probably because in the core of that negotiations were their own interests or interests of the power counties.

  1. U.S Policy Options Towards Iran's Nuclear Programs

    It is likely the attack of the nuclear program - a program deemed one of vital national importance by Iranian President Ahmadinejad - is equivalent to initiating long-term hostilities with Iran. The U.S must assume that Iran will seek to punish its' attackers, and brace for a response, not just

  2. Free essay

    why some palestinians dont agree with terrorism

    and is trying to make his marriage accepted. This dilemma has been going on for some time and as Jasmine explains "I feel like a refugee", the dispute between Palestinians and Israelis is affecting lives of innocent people who fell in love and could just do without the bother of politics and suffering.

  1. What are the main differences between the beliefs of Palestinian Arabs and Israeli Jews?The ...

    Palestinian Arabs b) Israeli Jews Many events have had a huge effect on shaping the views of both the Palestinian Arabs and the Israeli Jews. One event that had a great influence on both groups is the Six Day War.

  2. The Syrian Uprising

    Authoritarian System: One of the causes of the uprising is having an authoritarian system as the base and ideology of the current Syrian government lead by Bashar El Assad. This basically means having an authoritarian regime which means having a small group of heads, politicians and leaders controlling every aspect in the government.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work