• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Smoking In The Workplace - The European Prospective

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Smoking In The Workplace - The European Prospective Perhaps the most talked about legislative initiatives in recent times is the Public Health (Tobacco) Bill 2003. Its proposed effect has been described as draconian by the Vintner's Association and welcomed by the Anti-Smoking Lobby. Section 15 of the Bill, which amends Section 47 of the Public Health Tobacco Act 2002, allows the Minister of Health: (1) For the purposes of reducing the risk to and protecting the health of persons, the Minister may, by regulations, prohibit or restrict the smoking of tobacco products in- All or part of a licensed premises, registered club, or place of work... 'The exemptions granted to date by the Minister will see an estimated 80,000 workers not enjoying the protection of the ban'1. Despite the public and media debate over the economic effect on licensed premises, tourism and enforcement of the ban, one issue which has not been talked about is the effect that Ireland's membership of the European Union has had on this piece of legislation. It is the purpose of this essay to deal with this. "Tobacco use is the most significant avoidable source of disease and premature mortality. In the European Union alone, over 500,000 deaths per year are caused by tobacco consumption while globally 4 million die annually from tobacco. Smoking leads to significant death and disease from cancer, cardiovascular disease and respiratory disease in adults as well as severe health effects in children exposed to tobacco smoke. The death toll caused by tobacco consumption can and must be avoided."2 In introduction the ban on smoking in the workplace the 'the Government is seen as attempting to put its house in order in preparation for its EU Presidency in 2004. Workers rights seem to be topping the agenda in many areas'3. ...read more.

Middle

the deal with a problem that causes 500,000 deaths in the European Union per annum and is within the stated aims of one of the European Union Treaty Articles (Article 137EC) should be welcomed. However, the opposition, mainly by the Vintner's Association has been large. In spite of evidence to the contrary - 'According to figures from the University College London, non-smoking bar-workers take in up to ten times as much Environmental Tobacco Smoke ('ETS') as non-smokers in other professions. This puts them at a risk some 20-30% higher of suffering form "smoking associated" illnesses such as lung cancer. Mandate has put forwards evidence suggesting that the smoking ban will save the lives of 150 Irish bar staff annually'5 - the Vintner's Association argue that the resulting legislation will result in bar and restaurant closure. Two problems which have not been addressed in the public debate is firstly discriminatory effect of the exemptions granted (as was stated earlier an estimated 80,000 workers will not be covered by this ban) and secondly the pre-emptive effect of this law on possible legislation from Europe. Dealing with the pre-emptive effect of this legislation, it seems clear that preventing smoking is a clear objective of the European Community. The harmonization of laws in this area such as Directive 89/552/EEC, Directive 2001/37/EC and Directive 2003/33/EC as well as the non-binding resolutions and recommendations shows a aim at Community level to deal with the problems of Environmental Tobacco Smoke. Take the case of Pubblico Ministero v. Tullio Ratti6. Here Mr Ratti's Italian company had begun packaging and labelling its containers of solvents in accordance with two Council directives regulating the area. These directives had not yet been implemented in Italy, and the requirements of the Italian legislation on the matter were more stringent than those under the directives, providing penalties for those who failed to comply. ...read more.

Conclusion

problem, how can such a proposed law be in keeping with the spirits and aims of Ireland's membership of the European Community and also within the spirit and aims of the Irish constitution. Conclusion: The Public Health (Tobacco) Bill is a welcomed addition to the legislation aimed at protected the lives and the health of workers in this country. The most contentious point in the public debate regarding the prohibition of smoking in the workplace is its application to bars and restaurants. A compromise of sorts was posited; allowing smoking in designated areas which would be serviced by high levels of ventilation removing ETS, creating a safe area for workers. The ventilation compromise was an acceptable abrogation of the Tobacco Control Act 1995 in Finland, but scientific research has since established the futility of such safety measures. In September 2003 the EU Joint Research Centre published a Report on their findings establishing that high ventilation levels could not clear the harmful chemical compounds left by smoking. At best all ventilation could achieve was cosmetic in nature: the removal of the smell of tobacco. Team leader, Dr Kotzia, said the study led to only one conclusion: a mandamus upon the State to ban smoking in public places, in pubs and bars14. The Irish Presidency of the European Union will best be remembered, aside from the possible conclusion of the European Constitution, as the time when Ireland took the lead and banned smoking it the workplace, unconditionality. By removing the exemption for 80,000 workers currently in place, the country will uphold the spirit and aims of both the Irish constitution and the European Union and place this small country as a forerunner in designing community policy, the effect of which will protect the health and welfare of Community citizens as a whole. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. "What is the importance of the concept of citizenship in the development of EC ...

    A worker cannot be expelled except in cases justifiable under derogation from the freedom of movement. The residence permit is merely proof of the right granted by the Treaty which exists independently in the document. As a corollary to the freedom of movement protected by Regulation 1612/68 and Directive 68/360,

  2. How important is the European Parliament?

    Before this case, the European Parliament was only allowed to be a defendant in ECJ cases and not a plaintiff, the body who brings the case. The Comitology Case of a few months previously had not allowed the EP to bring a case against the Council, and thus the Commission.

  1. What does citizenship mean in the European context?

    But there are exceptions - which must be a matter of concern if citizenship is a normative practice and not a synonym for nationality. Indeed, the Amsterdam Treaty may encourage this. The same survey, however, also shows that substantial proportions of all five ethnic minorities have experienced racial threats and abuse which undermine their sense of security and belonging.

  2. Critically discuss how global economic trend may impact upon the future policies of the ...

    Inter-Continental Hotel Group and Hilton Group), which has a relatively high unemployment rate. Whereas if the incoming TNCs are investing for efficiency-seeking motives by acquisition, then direct job losses may occur through downsizing the labour forces(Cross, 1999). Undeniably, the level of investment is a factor helping to determine the success of a region.

  1. This essay is intended to have an in-depth appraisal of the implication of the ...

    Thus bring the union at a cross road, while those that believe in the vertical integration of the union have praised the constitution as a step in the right direction and want it adopted as it is, the horizontalist sees it unacceptable and unworkable ideas.

  2. The Institution of the European Union and Theories.

    Some Celtic languages, Welsh, and Asian languages are also spoken such as Urdu, Hindi and Cantonese. Religion is important in cluster one, the main being Christianity, the two types are Protestants and the Catholics as well as many other religions, such as Islam.

  1. Disneyland Resort Paris, Case Study

    once a year (i.e. a trip to Australia or Mallorca). * Undertake more short trips such as weekend visits to cities, ski areas or to wellness resorts. Lastly, unlike Americans, Europeans are unwilling to take their kids from school during the year for vacations.

  2. can the European Parliament be regarded as an effective legislative

    What this meant was that there was the implementation of the co-operation procedure, which 'requires two readings each by the council and parliament' (El-Agraa, 2001) of economic and monetary decisions. The first reading means that the European council must come to a majority decision over what is to be done

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work