• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Cabinets role in decision making has been marginalised in recent governments

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Explain the term cabinet committees. (5 marks) Much of the decision-making orchestrated within the Core Executive is performed by cabinet committees which are appointed by the Prime Minister. They have two principal purposes: to uphold the convention of Collective Cabinet Responsibility and to reduce the workload of the Cabinet and there are two types of cabinet committees: those which are ad-hoc that deal with unexpected or temporary issues (e.g. COBRA), the other being standing committees which are named and permanent. They usually comprise departmental ministers and a representative of the Treasury (each department needs to control its budgetary allowance). A minority of the committees are significant in the way in which the Government determines its policy; in this case, senior members of the Cabinet (including the Prime Minister) usually chair such meetings. Conclusions made in these committees are often then presented to the Cabinet for consideration in a wider context. For example, the London Organising Committee for the Olympic Games is responsible for liaising with the Government on the planning, construction and general evaluation in respect to the 2012 Olympic Games in London - the official Government policy is then based on their recommendations. However, in practice, the Cabinet Committees may not reach a verdict upon the topic which they set; in which case, the Cabinet will then lose time discussing a topic which may detract away from more significant policies - it may even cause damaging splits in the Cabinet as fellow department ministers stand at two different viewpoints. Consider how significant the doctrine of collective cabinet responsibility is in modern British politics. ...read more.

Middle

In this respect, the doctrine has been completely ignored and been utterly dependent on the influence granted to it by the Prime Minister. It has a key role in the effective functioning of a Cabinet Government, however, in an administration led by a figure who feels this is obstructive to progress, it has little or no weight unless it can somehow change public opinion, force a vote of no confidence and the resignation of the entire governing party. 'The Cabinet's role in decision making has been marginalised in recent governments.' Discuss. (25 marks) Traditional theory dictates that the Cabinet is the dominant decision-making body within the Core Executive, where Ministers convene to co-ordinate the policy making of individual departments and thus the overall work of the Government. All senior ministers are chosen by the Prime Minister and they are all collectively delegated the power to direct the Government. Under the doctrine of a Cabinet government, all members have equal status - apart from the PM who has the recognised position of primus inter pares (first amongst equals). Recently, however, the collective power held by the Cabinet has weakened somewhat, especially under Blair and Thatcher, though this has largely depended on the leadership style preferred by the PM in office. There are several predominant roles of the Cabinet which include: devising major policy (although this is often stated in the manifesto before election, priorities have to be made, legislative ideas converted into practice and contextual circumstances to be accounted for); addressing unforeseen major problems (such as the current H1N1 'swine flu' outbreak); harmonising the actions of ...read more.

Conclusion

Given all that, it would appear that the Cabinet is not currently functioning to the extent that traditional understanding would have us think it should. I utterly agree with the statement that the role of the Cabinet in decision-making has been deeply marginalised within recent administrations, and with that, I accept that the influence of the Cabinet is wholly and comprehensively linked to the context of the personality of the Prime Minister 'at the helm'. It is also true that Prime Ministerial power has acquired a new significance in recent years where they can forge decisions without the use of the Cabinet as a tool to manage or compass opinion. For instance, the EU has a significant function in top-level decision making insofar that it requires the divine attention of the Prime Minister alone, and not the Cabinet. As an informal ambassador for the United Kingdom, it is the responsibility of the PM to negotiate deals which secure: EU funding for the UK's economy, EU partner countries' assistance in the Afghan War et cetera and in order for him to do this, considerable autonomy has to be granted. The same is true for other meetings in the recent past, such as the G20 Meeting in London where the PM held high-level talks with other wealthy nations in order to establish a trillion dollar deal to effectively 'rescue' the world economy. All of this has been at the expense of a Cabinet which needs to be reckoned with, otherwise, in times of desperate need, the Prime Minister will not find support at his or hers' weakest moments in their premierships. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. How, and with what success, have governments attempted to improve the provision of health ...

    ISTC's were set up by the department of health in 2003 to perform common elective procedures on NHS patients. Their initial goal was to perform 250,000 operations over 5 years. Evidence from a Panorama documentary showed that some private contractors are paid 10% more than the NHS for operations and tend to be over paid.

  2. Where does the decision making power lie in the British executive: with the Prime ...

    Notable examples of Parliamentary sovereignty include the removal of Chamberlain from power in 1940 as Parliament lost faith in him and some of his Cabinet The extension of the Westminster model from this premise was based on analysis of governmental and party politics, the growth in strength and coherency of

  1. Evaluate the above statement and consider the extent to which you think it is ...

    the majority party, he does, this gives the House of Lords the potential to be a significant check on his power. However, the House of Lords has been subordinate to the House of Commons since early last century, and no longer retains its power of veto over proposed legislation.

  2. Unit 1 - Example of Evaluations

    The table is laid out fairly well and my questionnaire is easy to follow. It supplies enough questions to get varied and rich data. What could be improved if I produced it again One thing I would improve if I where to produce this document again would be to make

  1. priministers power

    o Advocates of the Chairmanship thesis point to the weakness of many Prime Ministers * 'When prime ministers are up, they are very, very up . . ., (Jenkins 1987, p. 184). but '. . . when they are down they can be virtually powerless.'

  2. Laurier Evaluation

    Laurier had good intentions, he tried to help answer the question that was raised, as to why to buy expensive items from central Canada when you can get the same item cheaper from the U.S.A.

  1. "To what extent have west European prime ministers full control of their cabinets? Discuss ...

    Parliamentary systems usually have a clear differentiation between the head of government and the head of state."4In having a parliamentary system in a country, the government consists of parliament, cabinet, and the Head of this Government is the party which is elected and the leader of this party is the Prime Minister.

  2. The Labour Government's response to the 2008 economic crisis was reckless and irresponsible. Discuss

    The announcement occurred less than 48 hours after Britain's leading share index, the FTSE100, recorded its largest single-day points fall since 1987. Alistair Darling, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, told the House of Commons in a statement on 8 October 2008 that the proposals were ''designed to restore confidence in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work