• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Contrast between American and Russian Political Cultures: Enlightenment and Despotism

Extracts from this document...


The Contrast between American and Russian Political Cultures: Enlightenment and Despotism Unlike the pluralist tradition in the US, Russian political culture was imprisoned by totalitarian Communism. Gorbachev's policy of glasnost'(openness) - accompanying the 'pererstroika' reconstruction initiative - enabled open discussion of public issues for the first time, with the introduction of the free press.. Russia had long consisted of a culture of regimental participation, whereas the USA has always encouraged voluntary participation. Despite this, civic-participation in America has declined. In Russia the opposite has happened.(Participate America,2004) In America, educational opportunities increased in the 1960's. This increased political participation giving marginal groups opportunities. On college campuses, students had the opportunity to voice their dissent through CND, women's rights groups and anti-Vietnam protest groups. In Russia, the biggest educational change came with the corrupt Brezhnev government, where secondary education steadily increased. This fact was reflected in the workplace and dissent movement. Dissent was beginning to slowly emerge by the 1960's because people were questioning the legitimacy of the Soviet system.(Gerber, 2000) Rejecting the rigid beliefs of the Stalin generation, this generation became more liberal-democratic, and began criticising the government. This is rather like what happened in the US. A parallel that can be made is that the poorer war generations in both countries were more conformist. The younger, better-off generations were more likely to be dissenters - therefore more politically active. ...read more.


One such right, is 'freedom of information'-an important scrutinisation tool in liberal democracies. Unfortunately, this is problematic in Russia. Putin has proposed a strategy to topple opposition. It is not as extreme as the CPSU's monopoly-censored journalism. However, Putin's vow to "control" and "make opposition media impossible" indicates a worrying direction. If Bush were to have and publicise such intentions, the constitutional statute of 'the freedom of the press' would act against him. Most rights reforms took place from 1920-1960 in the USA. In Russia however it was not until the 1990's. The Women's Democratic Initiative campaigned on issues like domestic violence, employment, sexual discrimination,& political inclusion. Only three women were ever in the CPSU, as opposed to the thousands among Republicans and Democrats. The freedom of speech granted to Russians is exactly what the Americans have as a constitutional principle. But this could be threatened by Putin's despotic behaviour, as well as the rather questionable 1993 constitution. A history of brutality has left the Russians with scarred memories. According to recent polls, 'power' to the Russians is associated with military force and physical coercion. To the Americans, power means legitimate authority,status,knowledge and wealth. Legitimate authority, a democratic principle, is granted through free-elections and the implementation of the general will, something that is relatively new to Russians. ...read more.


Stalin's constitution introduced direct elections by secret ballot and universal suffrage but prohibited opposition parties. Russia, unlike America,lacks the 'Enlightenment' ideas about freedom and the representation of rights and interests; essential to democratic society. This possibly explains the low civic-participation. Only a bare majority voted for the 1993 constitution. To add to his worries, President Putin has to put up with ethnic tension in Chechnya and terrorist attacks. Both administrations then have similar obstacles. President W Bush, ever since the 9/11 attacks, has used the war on terror to win over public opinion. An example of the impact of events on public opinion is the fluctuating stability in Iraq. Public opinion in Russia however seems to rest mainly on Putin's strong stance against inter-ethnic violence. To avoid further problems a'Law of Political Parties' was passed against any group undermining state security. Likewise, Bush introduced the Patriot Act to curb terrorism. In both political cultures then, the success of campaigns rest largely on security. In conclusion both political cultures show similarities despite their evolutionary positions in terms of democratic development, notably because of the inevitable baggage that accompanies a capitalist society. However, unlike the US, Russia lacks a precise separation of powers, a progressive Federal system and a coherent and practical constitution. All that is left therefore, is a rather embryonic democracy. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Compare and Contrast pluralist and ruling elites accounts of political power

    their basic thesis is that power is controlled and derived through collaboration amongst themselves. Opposingly pluralists deem that competition allows democracy as previously mentioned. Pluralists also cannot comprehend that people will not express their opinions, so will become members of interest groups which thus lets equality flourish.

  2. To what extent do recent elections in the UK and the USA support the ...

    (I. Crewe, 1983: 184) in the USA this has almost always been the case. Therefore it is easier to analyse voting between two parties. The dealignment thesis ignores the significance of the Liberal Democrat party in Britain as well as regional parties such as Sinn Fein.

  1. To what extent did the key political ideas directly Influence change and development in ...

    These ideals recurred in every demand by liberals for reform from that moment on. Following the rise of the new European Middle Classes in the early nineteenth century, a new challenge arose to those who had the power due to being born into the right family.

  2. Free essay

    The emerge of Alliance 90

    Both symbolic and descriptive representations are grouped into representation as 'standing for'. This notion indicates that no action, but certain characteristics are needed in order to constitute a representational relationship. 4. Representing as 'acting for': In this sense, "representation is a certain characteristic activity, defined by certain behavioral norms or

  1. Ideology Of Political Facism

    Fascist movements set out to regain the heroic spirit of this lost past through radical social transformations. In Nazi Germany (again, for example) the government tried to "purify" the nation by killing millions of Jews and other minority groups. The Nazis believed they could create harmonious community whose values were

  2. Compare and Contrast the Classical Liberal position with the Conservative position on the issue ...

    is very rational that some legal drugs such as alcohol and tobacco are more harmful then some illegal drugs (Penington, 1999). The Classical Liberals believe that drug use is a personal individual issue and recreational drug use should be legalized with restriction of access to minors (Help End Marijuana Prohibition, 2006).

  1. Compare and contrast Pluralist and Ruling Elite accounts of political power.

    If a state had the seven characteristics without having social diversity, then a group could use the 7 characteristics to rule over the rest through democratic means resulting in tyranny of the majority. Likewise, if there were no 7 characteristics then a group could then again rule with tyranny over the rest.

  2. M-theory is a solution proposed for the unknown theory of everything

    The ingredients of loop quantum gravity Loop quantization At the core of loop quantum gravity is a framework for nonperturbative quantization of diffeomorphism-invariant gauge theories, which one might call loop quantization. While originally developed in order to quantize vacuum general relativity in 3+1 dimensions, the formalism can accommodate arbitrary spacetime

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work