• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The House of Lords, is their need for futher reform?

Extracts from this document...


The House of Lords has always been a talking point in British politics, mainly over the fact that they are an unelected body and have no democratic right to determine the laws of the country. Although their power has been reduced over the years, many would argue that it is just not enough and some would argue that it should be abolished. In this essay I will look at the reasons why people want the Lords to be abolished however I will also look at the key functions that are carried out in the House of Lords. I will then conclude stating whether I feel the House of Lords should be abolished and if not what (if anything) should be done to reform the House of Lords. The House of Lords is argued to be undemocratic and should not play a part in the British political system. There is also the argument that we cannot claim to be a democracy while the House of Lords hold power to rule the decisions of the elected government. ...read more.


Due to these reasons the House of Lords could easily be argued to be both sexist and racist. Members of the House of Lords although are not directly paid, such, they are given a generous attendance allowance. This basically means that they are paid for turning up and not paid in correlation to their contribution. However there are some definitely good reasons for keeping the House of Lords. Firstly they play a vital role in the legislative. The House of Lords can scrutinise these bills and highlight any areas which they have any concerns with. The Lords can scrutinise the bills in much more detail than the House of Commons which means they can amend any problems that are found. They can also stop a bill from passing into law although the House of Commons can overrule this after a certain period of time has elapsed. Then there is the role of Scrutinising the work of the executive. ...read more.


Another reason to put forward to continue to with the House of Lords is simply to share the burden of the government more evenly. Parliament has an enormous deal of work to do, and the House of Lords currently does its fair share of it. However, the benefit of sharing the work must be balanced against the costs, particularly when conflicts between the chambers result in an increased workload for both. In this essay I have looked at the Major criticism of the House of Lords as well as the key function that are carried out by the Lords. I feel that there are some major issues relating to how democratic the Lords are and the lack of minority groups that are a part of the Lords. However I do feel that the Lords do have an essential role to play in British politics and I feel that it should not be abolished. I feel that there should be new elected peers who would be elected using proportional distribution to give a better representation in minority groups within the Lords. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Government & Politics Revision Notes

    The List system This system involves multi-member constituencies. In a closed list system, each party submits a list of candidates for each constituency, but the ballot paper contains a list of political parties rather than a list of individual candidates. Seats are allocated to the party according to the proportion of votes won, a quota is calculated to determine how many votes are needed to win a seat.

  2. Is There A Need For Constitutional Reform?

    By 2003, though, the honeymoon was over. The Assembly seemed to be regarded as an irrelevance by many Welsh voters, and a decline in Plaid Cymru's performance mirrored the fall in popularity of the nationalists in Scotland. In both Scotland and Wales, the main warnings voiced before the event by anti-devolutionists had seemed after 1999 to be coming true.

  1. 'Britain is in desperate need of electoral reform. The FPTP system is undemocratic.' Discuss.

    42% of the vote and in 1997 when Labour won a majority of 179 seats on only 43.3% of the vote. FPTP is disproportional as the percentage of votes rarely matches up to the percentage of seats. This 'winner's bonus' ensures a Parliamentary majority for the winning party, but it

  2. House Of Lords Reform - What did the 1999 act reforming the lords ...

    This also means that if they were professionals, they would not be politicians, which might get rid of the idea of political biased. In the Lords, the low attendance meant that the conservatives didn't actually have a majority in the lords of the regular attendees.

  1. Draft a memorandum to the government evaluating the merits and demerits of differing reform ...

    From this perspective directly elected second chamber 'could be the missing piece of the constitutional jigsaw, serving as a pinnacle of the structure and a focus of unity' as Sir Ivor Richard and Damien Welfare see this option. However, fundamental problems arise with this system of reform.

  2. Discuss the contention that the House of Lords is irrelevant.

    In the next 7 years the House of Lords opposed 3 acts; the European Parliamentary Elections Act in 1999; the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act in 2000 and the Hunting act in 2004, showing greater use of their authority and fulfilling some of the necessary tasks the Lords need to carry out in order to retain some relevancy.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work