• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The reform of the British Constitution remains an unfinished business. Explain & Discuss

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

The reform of the British Constitution remains an unfinished business. Explain & Discuss Constitutional reform is when the system of government and how government institutions interact is changed; in the UK this has also meant the codification of some parts of the constitution. Since 1997, under Tony Blair's Labour government, there have been many constitutional reforms the most important being devolution in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, the reform of the House of Lords and Commons and the creations of new legislation granting greater freedom and rights within Britain. However, some reforms are yet to be accomplished or in progress regarding the electoral and parliamentary reform. One of the most significant constitutional reforms made after the 1997 Labour victory was decentralisation, devolution allowed power o be distributed to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland but with Westminster still retaining legal sovereignty. This reform is seen to be most successful in Scotland, where the most power was devolved. Devolution organised and established the Scottish Parliament, which like Westminster meets weekly to discuss issues of the day concerning only Scotland. They have the power to execute primary legislation concerning domestic issues such as education, health and social services. ...read more.

Middle

This has brought about a more democratic system within the political system itself. Due to the un-elected nature of the House of Lords, further reforms were also made to lead it towards at greater democratic state. Under the House of Lords Act 1999, most hereditary peerages were removed and life peerages were introduced. Since then, calls have been made to ensure that the House of Lords is partially elected in order to be a credible second chamber. There is a minority who view that the upper chamber should be abolished altogether. These reforms still remain in progress, under the new coalition government agreement; proposals for a fully elected upper chamber through proportional representation and fixed terms of up to 15 years are in consideration. This would mean the Prime Minister's power to appoint Lords would be shifted onto the people for more representative democracy. There has been little substantial reform in the Commons; a few examples are timing-related changes such as the moving of Prime Ministers Questions from 1500 to midday on Wednesdays and the cutting of PMQ from 2 sessions per week to just 1. Also, time-efficient changes such as allowing MPs to vote electronically from inside the chamber and scrapping sittings on Fridays to allowed visitors to view and learn about parliament. ...read more.

Conclusion

The access to these documents would lead the government be scrutinised more ensuring they act in the best interests of the public. A fundamental example of the act operating is infamous Expenses Scandal of 2008 whereby Human Rights campaigners acquired the details of ministerial expenditure, which was then leaked to the public. This was an important step to clarifying the constitution and making government accountable to its people, and one of the few examples of the Freedom of Information Act in action. However, an event that undermines the FOI Act was when the Justice Secretary Jack Straw vetoed the publication of cabinet minutes over Iraq, showing that information would only be publicized when in the best interests of the executive. This is a constitutional reform that remains to be judged due to its short existence, the rights of citizens need to be clarified clearly in order to democratize Britain fully. In conclusion, Britain has made significant constitutional reforms and is progressing towards further improvements but currently the full extent of reforms are yet to be accomplished with many reforms being incomplete as in devolution, reform of parliament and other such matters. So, it could therefore be said that today, the reform of the British Constitution does still remain an 'unfinished business'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How effective is the British Constitution in protecting the rights of its citizens?

    3 star(s)

    This is very unlikely to happen since it is likely to cause a civil war. The right to vote is the expectation of any un-imprisoned person above the age of eighteen who lives in the UK, is a member of a commonwealth country, or lives in the republic of Ireland.

  2. Electing MPs to the House of Commons.

    The system is used: in the Australian Senate, the Republic of Ireland, Tasmania, Malta and Northern Ireland for local elections and elections to the European Parliament. Arguments used in favour: STV does more than other systems to guarantee that everyone gets their views represented in parliament and that they have a say in what is done by their elected representatives.

  1. priministers power

    when they are down they can be virtually powerless.' * For example, Mrs Thatchers style of Cabinet leadership led to more defeats than any other Prime Minister in Cabinet - for example on the key issue of EMS entry. * A great deal of Conservative opposition to Thatcher was personal - especially the bitter attack by Sir Geoffrey Howe in resigning from the government in November 1990.

  2. Is There A Need For Constitutional Reform?

    1999, which it did by a less comfortable margin than expected, and to ensure a relatively obedient administration in Edinburgh. This proved more problematical. Labour could govern only with the help of the Liberal Democrats, and it turned out to be a coalition that damaged both parties in terms of their popular support.

  1. Can parliament bind it's successors with the provision in the Northern Ireland Act 1998, ...

    It appears clear that Parliament can indeed bind it's successors as to the 'manner and form' of legislation. Different forms and procedures for legislation, such as getting two-thirds majority, or 70% majority for example, to repeal Acts might be

  2. 'Britain is in desperate need of electoral reform. The FPTP system is undemocratic.' Discuss.

    Londonderry is a mainly Catholic town, but the large Catholic area is only one constituency, whereas the smaller Protestant area has been split into three constituencies to give the Protestants more seats in Parliament. In Scotland and Wales, they have an average of 14,000 less voters in their constituencies than

  1. House Of Lords Reform - What did the 1999 act reforming the lords ...

    If the peers were part of a political party or followed a certain ideology, then if they were to disagree with that party's policy, then the peers could not be deselected or forced out of a job like MP's can under party whip systems.

  2. "Constitutional reform had gone too far, or not far enough?" Discuss

    House of Lords to be elected, similar to a senate present in America and Australia. The members would be elected by proportional representation instead of FPTP, as this has been strongly argued by the Liberal Democrats to be undemocratic. However, due to the coalition, a compromise had to be made

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work