• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The relationship between censorship and student publications by specifically drawing on the Rabelais case

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

ESSAY Pushing the limits of free speech and then killing it is not an uncommon theme for today's student press. Civil disobedience and censorship of student publications has been a hot-button issue since the 1960s and remains a crucial, yet under-examined area of free speech. In an assumed tolerant democracy which flaunts philosophical ideals like a free market of ideas, censorship laws have undermined the essential function of student newspapers as an outlet for challenging, insightful and investigative journalism. The following essay seeks to examine the relationship between censorship and student publications by specifically drawing on the Rabelais case. Accordingly, this essay further attempts to explore the legal and philosophical reasoning behind censoring student newspapers. In 1998, the Full Court of the Federal Court handed down its first decision which directly involved the right to political communication of a student publication1. The court held that an article advocating theft published in the La Trobe University student publication, Rabelais, instructed in matters of crime and was not protected by the implied constitutional freedom of speech.2 The appellants - four editors of the publication - argued that the article addressed issues of wealth distribution in a capitalist society and constituted political communication.3 Prior to Rabelais, Australian courts have never squarely confronted political communication in relation to the National Classification Code.4 Whilst the Federal Court's decision to uphold the findings of the Classification Review Board generated another proponent of control ...read more.

Middle

Bill of Rights expressly protect the rights of individuals to free speech, but an implicit rule applied by U.S. courts entitles student journalists to the highest level of First Amendment protection to sustain the traditional libertarian function of student publications. 14 The rule that student publications enjoy freestanding exemptions of restrictions underlying the First Amendment emanates from legislation based in the state of California, which expressly duplicates First Amendment rights to college and university students. 15 One can hardly ignore the advantageous effects of a similar law being implemented in Australia. Like the United States, it is widely maintained that student publications in Australia should remain wide-open free speech zones, where every form of speech is permitted and censorship controls are turned off.16 However, the recent introduction of the Voluntary Student Unionism bill17 before parliament has additionally threatened the agenda of student publications. Although the bill, which traces back to 197418, sets out to render universal student unionism voluntary, it could potentially be the first law that directly undermines students' right to free speech by defunding Australia's student press19. The Western Australian (WA) VSU model, which came into force in 1997, has cut funds directed to all student publications in the state, while other student advocacy bodies were lost completely.20 In conclusion, although Australia has a robust commitment to freedom of speech, on a practical level, this commitment is too often regulated by prevailing moral and legal protocols. ...read more.

Conclusion

Clayton also points out that a publication which incites crime must be banned under regulations by the OFLC, even though the publication may be of political nature. Note 4. 12 Note 4. See also Clayton, M. 1998 'Censorship, Free Speech and the Rabelais Case,' Legal Date, Vol. 10, No 1.; Clayton, M. and Borgeest, T. 1998, 'Free Speech and Censorship after the Rabelais Case,' Media and Arts Law Review, Vol. 3 at 194 13 Note 1. The Rabelais edition also discussed political issues of death penalty in the United States and pending execution of a former black activist, Mumia Abu Jamal 14 Goodman, M. (2005). Interview. [Interview with Christopher van Opstal, 23/05/2005] 15 Pursuant to s 76120 of the California Education Code, the 'governing board of a community college shall adopt rules and regulations relating to the exercise of free expression by students'. See California Education Code Section 66301. 16 Boey, H. (2005) Interview. [Interview with Christopher van Opstal, 19/05/2005] 17 Higher Education Support Amendment (Abolition of Compulsory Up-front Student Union Fees) Bill 2005 18 Aldrich, F. (2005). Interview. [Interview with Christopher van Opstal, 27/05/2005] 19 Note 13. If impending VSU is passed by the Senate in July, it will be necessary to cut funds to the printing of student publications. This will result to the disappearance of most student publications. 20 Hastings, G. (2004) 'VSU Legislation Experiences in WA, Victoria, and Federally,' NUS Research at 5 21 Pollak, M. 1990, Sense and Censorship, Reed Publishers, Sydney, at p. 284 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Communism essay review.

    This time they had more in common. Engels had rejected the Young Hegelians and other "radical bourgeois" acquaintances. And Marx had moved rapidly into communism. They had reached a common point. Marx had introduced Engels to the editors of a new radical journal in Paris called Vorwarts which after a

  2. How and why does Locke explain the creation, value and protection of property?

    property without royal appropriation and allow an individual to withdraw his consent to government at anytime. By constituting a government in terms of its role in "the preservation of property", Locke fulfills these aims eloquently. However, as with any doctrines there are problems.

  1. Power and Politics in Organizations: Public and Private Sector Comparisons

    In addition, many activities that are considered legitimate, and even praiseworthy, in the private sphere would subject public office-holders to arrest, prosecution, and possible imprisonment were they to practice them (Gortner, Mahler, and Nicholson 1987: 60-4). Consider, for example, the public's quite different reactions to words like 'broker' and 'influence

  2. Communism VS Democracy

    To argue from the other side, the word freedom could be linked to democracy in that those who are free would have democracy as their form of government, because to have total freedom would be anarchy, which would include freedom to limit the freedom of others, and the next logical

  1. 'Accidental Death Of An Anarchist' was written by Dario Fo, in 1970 - Contextualisation

    jokes, optical illusions, physical movement and the like. In 'Accidental Death Of An Anarchist', the Maniac is the chief device of farce, satire and even slapstick. Fo created Maniac from the template of the 'Jongleur' (originating from classical traditions.) This character would hide behind farcical, "mask of a fool and proceed to make scathing, satirical attacks on authority figures with the mask as his protection".

  2. Could one censor pornography, on Millean grounds?

    in an attempt to use the "elevated faculties"5 that we all possess. So in this light Mill believed that people should "not live according to customs or social traditions but rather on the basis of their own judgement - based on their own needs, desires personality and interests"6.

  1. Russia's Political Party System as an Obstacle to Democratization

    However, most of the new entrants were small parties and, as the results of the 1995 election showed, this proliferation mainly served to further fragment the political center. The results of the 1995 election belied any expectation that learning necessarily progresses from experience.

  2. T difficult for export orientated economics to sustain the land owning elites much longer. ...

    (Cammack, 1999). In Brazil the establishment of a 'constitutional regime' in 1891 created the new Republic of the United States of Brazil that allowed for a move away from the centralised ideology of the Dom Pedro's. This was modelled on the federalist system in the United States of America that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work