• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extend is Nationalism a coherent ideology?

Extracts from this document...


16/1/15 To what extend is Nationalism a coherent ideology? (45 Marks) Nationalism has taken a verity of forms over the course of its history, from Liberalism to Marxism, bringing into question the integrity of the ideology and begging the question ? is it in fact a coherent ideology? For an ideology to be considered more than a political doctrine, it must demonstrate that its core themes fit well together and has a certain amount of independence from other ideologies. For it to be coherent it must demonstrate some consistencies between different strands. Nationalism fails to meet both criteria and is both incoherent and not an ideology. Nationalism has been described as purely a psychological phenomenon with little substance. As such, national feelings can be seen being expressed by those who simply have an emotional attachment to their nation, or by a dislike of other nations. ...read more.


Although, while the theme of The Nation has been found to be coherent, Organic Community, which links directly into The Nation, has proved not to be as a result of liberal nationalists, perhaps in constructivist global-cooperation approach, seeing increasing different nationalities as citizens of the world. Additional inconsistencies are also found all too often in other circumstances as well. Due to this, nationalism can be described as having a schizophrenic political character ? seen by such polar opposites as expansionist nationalism and anti-colonial nationalism. The first strand advocates the expansion of its country?s border via, in most cases, military means in an obvious chauvinistic manner; such as seen by Napoleon during the early 19th century and then again by Hitler and the Nazi?s in the 20th century. Whereas the other, anti-colonial, campaigns for national Self-determination; sometimes against other nationalists that had invaded them. If the nation-state is indeed the highest and most desirable form of political organisation ? expressed by such by Wilson?s 14 points ...read more.


that colonial oppression is in fact an extension of the class system: the bourgeois in this context being the oppressing country and the would be independent nation-state the proletariat. In short, another ideology has to be coupled with nationalism to give it purpose and drive in its endeavours. Overall, the case for nationalism being a coherent ideology has been made in so far as it has been proved that it is not simply a psychological phenomenon. Beyond that, however, it can be seen that nationalism suffers from severe discrepancies within its core themes. It is safe to assert that when one strand of nationalism quite obviously violates the core principle of Self-determination, while another uses it to justify independence for its nation there is no coherently in the ?ideology?. To close, it is imperative that it is made clear that nationalism is a political doctrine ? onto which other ideologies can attach themselves to and explain nationalism in a way that makes sense to their core themes. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. To what extend is fascism a blend of nationalism and socialism?

    The socialists' elements in fascism have great limitations. Those ideas were marginalized as soon as fascist parties came to power because they wanted to receive support from big businesses. In fact, bourgeoisie proved to be the greatest supporters of Hitler in Nazi Germany.

  2. To what extent is Marxism a flawed political ideology?

    and the ruling class (bourgeoisie). Marx argued that once humans had created a society whereby they had the basic necessities needed for survival, one person or group would eventually seize control. This developed into a society consisting of slaves and slave owners, whereby production motivation was based solely on the need for trade, not profit.

  1. To what extent can Conservatism be considered an ideology?

    Conservatives themselves would even argue that they don't share an ideology. Some would argue that Conservatism is more a disposition rather than a coherent set of beliefs. It shares the notion of fear of change. Adding to this conservatism is situational: it is the defence of status quo.

  2. Marxism, Idealism and Nationalism

    Marx's idea that war and conflict is caused by capitalism has many flaws, but the presence of class division is easily identifiable in the United States under the capitalist system, but evidence that war is caused from capitalism is strongly lacking.

  1. Socialist uses of workers' inquiry

    cost of production (the instrument of production itself grows always more costly, as we have seen), and since this more extensive sale has become a question of life and death not only for him, but also for his rivals, the old struggle must begin again, and it is all the

  2. Breaking down the Walls: A Discourse of Ideology and "Otherness"

    I fully believe that the ideology of America, sustained by large institutions, creates a non-inherent belief that people of differing skin colors are also biologically different. Richard Wright does not open Black Boy with any kind of declaration against American ideology.

  1. The Search for independence, Macedonia

    Exactly the individuality of Macedonia has been disputed. To Macedonia and Macedonian's were given different names, difficult to pronounce and difficult to remember. Statues of kings and gods have been demolished, old manuscripts have been burnt, and graves have been erased.

  2. Assess critically Marx's distinction between ideology and science

    Stirner writes: "Whether the One God or the three-in-one, whether the Lutheran God or...no God at all but 'Man' instead...it makes no difference to one who negates the supreme Being itself, to one in whose eyes the servants of the latter are all together -- pious folk: the most rabid

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work