Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3

To what extent does Parliament control executive power?

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

To what extent does Parliament control executive power? Although Parliament to some extent controls executive power, there are limitations to the extent of this control. Government usually has an overall majority. The electoral systems put in place by parliament as a whole usually guarantee this, with the exception of May 2010. In the circumstances of a small government majority, the effectiveness of parliament can be increased due to the fact that normal voting patterns and predictable outcomes for government votes may not apply, meaning that governments power is reduced. A majority can mean that to a certain extent, Government can pass any law it wants to. However, the fptp voting system can undermine representation in the commons because it can mean that certain parties are over represented. This means that Parliament's control over certain parties can be limited. The power of prime ministerial patronage renders many Mps excessively docile and loyal. This means that as opposed to the Burkean view which suggests that MPs use their own judgement in acting on behalf of their constituents. The doctrine of the mandate, by contrast, suggests that MPs serve their constituents by 'toeing a party line'.

Middle

They attempt to force MPs to vote the way that the party would like them to. This can be seen as both persuasive and threatening. This can have great influence over careers. This is because ignoring the whip can be seen as party betrayal and can be very harmful to the future career of the MP within the party, depending on the severity of the whip which has been ignored. In extreme circumstances, this can lead to suspension from the party or can persuade a party to 'de-select' them. The whips therefore reduce the power of parliament because the votes, again, can be fairly predictable and a majority government's preferred outcome often occurs when back bench rebellion does not occur. MPs can often lack research back up, expertise and political support. This has been exaggerated in recent years with an increasing number of MPs and politicians following politics as their only career. In previous years, it has been more common for MPs to have other careers (usually within Law and Business), this would mean that their expertise would be greater.

Conclusion

They also cut across party lines which means they can be said to be independent. They report their findings and recommendations back to the commons. In recent years they have begun to assert themselves more strongly. Eg select committees produced a critical report on the privatisation of air traffic control in 2000. The government usually acts on their recommendations. However, the committees do not also have a great amount of time in which to operate. They can also lack the expertise, resources, staff, power and often the will to be more than an irritant to the government. The House of Lords, despite its lack of democratic legitimacy, has effectively blocked amended legislation when it saw fit. This means that parliamentary power is increased. The balance of power between government and parliament is variable in that a government majority can increase government power but a small majority can increase parliament power. The executive government does however act in an environment when it is constantly under scrutiny and constraints. The strength of these depends on the context of the situation. Simply, the government cannot do what it wants without the approval of parliament which means that effectively, parliament holds power and remains the central institution of the Great British political system.

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

4 Stars - The strengths of this essay lie in its competent command and explanation of the subject matter and the precise, analytical conclusion.
Where the essay could be improved is with a more coherent structure - points are not effectively grouped together, consequently the essay 'jumps around' and revisits earlier themes in a confusing way. In places points would be strengthened with a greater use of concrete examples.

Marked by teacher Dan Carter 26/09/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. Using these four passages and your own knowledge, asses the view that Thatchers electoral ...

    This ties in with the point made by Young, that voting was becoming increasingly based on the impulse of material success which is reflected in Evans argument that voters were being draw to the Conservative party in hope of âcontinued prosperity.â This shows that even though Labour fought a stronger

  2. "The advantages of a codified constitution now outweigh the disadvantages" Discuss (40)

    stability, the fact that there has only been 1 amendment in the last 20 years, whilst many of its amendments have been due to prominent political issues as opposed to smaller yet highly relevant social matters, is equally as damning in its refusal to keep pace with an ever changing western society.

  1. The reform of the British Constitution remains an unfinished business. Explain & Discuss

    This change would solve the otherwise perfect democratic progress of devolution. One more important change that has incurred over recent years is the reform of the Lords. This has changed the constitution so that the Lord Chancellor no longer sits on all 3 of the most prestigious political institutions of Britain.

  2. To what extent do leaders dominate their parties?

    Labour had wanted to appeal to the middle classes and Liberal democrat supporters for more support and as Prime Minister Blair can now enjoy more dominance over his party and is able to choose his own cabinet. Public support gives the Prime Minister a mandate and this is shown recently

  1. Some differences and similarities between the Australian and United States federal legislatures

    Both Parliament and the Congress supplement the work of the two houses with many committees. These committees scrutinise legislation, investigate current issues, examine government expenditure and do other detailed work to support the work of both houses. Members represent single member electorates (Australia)

  2. How effective is Parliament in checking Executive Power?

    This not only allows scrutiny of the work of the Minister but also scrutinises the political skill of them. Select Committees also serve an important role in scrutinising the Goverment.

  1. How can Coalition government affect the traditions of the Cabinet system?

    Also the Prime Minister traditionally is considered to be the Chief Spokesman for the government, the leading public figure in the government who speaks for and represents the government to the public. But now the Prime Ministers influence upon public opinion and mass media has declined as the Prime Minister

  2. How effective are backbencher MPs?

    For example, Tom Watson, in his first year of being an MP for Labour in 2001, launched a campaign to ban album sales of convicted sex offender Gary Glitter, proving that backbenchers are effective. A key function of Backbencher MPs is that they scrutinise the proposed work of the PM,

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.