• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent does Parliament control executive power?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent does Parliament control executive power? Although Parliament to some extent controls executive power, there are limitations to the extent of this control. Government usually has an overall majority. The electoral systems put in place by parliament as a whole usually guarantee this, with the exception of May 2010. In the circumstances of a small government majority, the effectiveness of parliament can be increased due to the fact that normal voting patterns and predictable outcomes for government votes may not apply, meaning that governments power is reduced. A majority can mean that to a certain extent, Government can pass any law it wants to. However, the fptp voting system can undermine representation in the commons because it can mean that certain parties are over represented. This means that Parliament's control over certain parties can be limited. The power of prime ministerial patronage renders many Mps excessively docile and loyal. This means that as opposed to the Burkean view which suggests that MPs use their own judgement in acting on behalf of their constituents. The doctrine of the mandate, by contrast, suggests that MPs serve their constituents by 'toeing a party line'. ...read more.

Middle

They attempt to force MPs to vote the way that the party would like them to. This can be seen as both persuasive and threatening. This can have great influence over careers. This is because ignoring the whip can be seen as party betrayal and can be very harmful to the future career of the MP within the party, depending on the severity of the whip which has been ignored. In extreme circumstances, this can lead to suspension from the party or can persuade a party to 'de-select' them. The whips therefore reduce the power of parliament because the votes, again, can be fairly predictable and a majority government's preferred outcome often occurs when back bench rebellion does not occur. MPs can often lack research back up, expertise and political support. This has been exaggerated in recent years with an increasing number of MPs and politicians following politics as their only career. In previous years, it has been more common for MPs to have other careers (usually within Law and Business), this would mean that their expertise would be greater. ...read more.

Conclusion

They also cut across party lines which means they can be said to be independent. They report their findings and recommendations back to the commons. In recent years they have begun to assert themselves more strongly. Eg select committees produced a critical report on the privatisation of air traffic control in 2000. The government usually acts on their recommendations. However, the committees do not also have a great amount of time in which to operate. They can also lack the expertise, resources, staff, power and often the will to be more than an irritant to the government. The House of Lords, despite its lack of democratic legitimacy, has effectively blocked amended legislation when it saw fit. This means that parliamentary power is increased. The balance of power between government and parliament is variable in that a government majority can increase government power but a small majority can increase parliament power. The executive government does however act in an environment when it is constantly under scrutiny and constraints. The strength of these depends on the context of the situation. Simply, the government cannot do what it wants without the approval of parliament which means that effectively, parliament holds power and remains the central institution of the Great British political system. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level United Kingdom section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

4 Stars - The strengths of this essay lie in its competent command and explanation of the subject matter and the precise, analytical conclusion.
Where the essay could be improved is with a more coherent structure - points are not effectively grouped together, consequently the essay 'jumps around' and revisits earlier themes in a confusing way. In places points would be strengthened with a greater use of concrete examples.

Marked by teacher Dan Carter 26/09/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level United Kingdom essays

  1. To what extent have constitutional reforms since 1997 reduced the powers of the UK ...

    Even though the government does have the power to remove this act from parliament it has still reduced the power of the UK government. Lastly the labour government signed the Lisbon treaty which handed over more powers to the EU such as new powers for the European Commission, European Parliament

  2. To what extent does parliament control the executive power?

    During Tony Blair's final speech before he resigned in 2007, he mentioned that he "never stopped fearing" the legislature in all his years, but, do we 'judge' a century's worth of scrutinizing history- due some man's final words? As back-up; the House of Common 'Select committees' (introduced in 1979 with 16 committees in all in the Commons)

  1. Government & Politics Revision Notes

    > tyranny of the majority -Direct democracy may also produce what is termed the "tyranny of the majority" in which minorities are placed at a disadvantage with either discrimination against them and possible restriction on their freedom. This is sometimes viewed as "mob rule."

  2. To What Extent is conservatism an ideology?

    In the nineteenth century, when it was opposing the views of liberalism, it adopted the idea of an organic society. This is where society is described as organ, with all parts of society connected and working together, rather than merely a collection of free individuals.

  1. The reform of the British Constitution remains an unfinished business. Explain & Discuss

    Another significant limitation to devolution is the controversial West-Lothian Question. This is a democratic problem because whilst Scottish MPs can vote on issues concerning only England and Wales in Westminster Parliament, English and Welsh MPs cannot sit and vote in issues in the Scottish Parliament.

  2. Describe the formal process of statute creation and the role of the House of ...

    Also recently the number of ethnic minority has increased as there are now much more, women, and coloured MPs. Also parliament can pass emergency legislation for example, Terrorist Act, since September 11th. Another Advantage would be that, when House of Lords scrutinise the legislation, in the committee stage, on the

  1. "Parliament carries out none of it's function adequately". Discuss

    They have unlimited time to debate, so can probe deeply into all matters. However, the majority of the members are from the government, and these committees are supposed to be scrutinising the government. This isn?t a large a problem as it originally seems, though, as it?s made up of rebellious backbenchers, who don?t always follow the party line.

  2. How successfully does Parliament perform its representative functions in Modern Britain?

    On the other hand, others might argue that this proves that parliament is successful and efficient in performing its representative functions, because they could promptly pass a bill that could improve the economy. Parliament cannot always successfully perform its representative functions because of the procedure required in passing legislature.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work