• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To What Extent Does the EU Display a 'Democratic Deficit'?

Extracts from this document...


To What Extent Does the EU Display a 'Democratic Deficit'? The EU is a supragovernmental organisation with significant powers over some areas of policy (such as trade and agriculture) in member states. In view of its considerable powers, many complain that the EU suffers from a democratic deficit, i.e., there are not enough democratically elected elements to the EU for its powers to be considered democratically legitimate. However, in order to determine if the EU has a democratic deficit, the term 'democratic' must be defined. 'Democracy' simply means rule by the people, and is in itself a vague term. However, in this context, the terminology is most likely referring to 'liberal democracy', the form of government widely used throughout the Western world. Several key points make up a liberal democracy; firstly, the government must be chosen as a result of regular, free, fair, competitive elections. The government (executive) should be accountable to the legislature; in many liberal democracies a system of checks and balances has to exist between the 3 main branches of government (Executive, Legislature and Judiciary). The rights and liberties of all citizens must be protected, often by a 'Bill of Rights' included in the constitution, which exists in most liberal democracies to set out the limits of the government and its powers. These are the essential factors of a liberal democracy, and so in order to determine to what extent the EU suffers from a democratic deficit we must consider each of these elements in turn and the extent to which they exist in the different institutions of the EU. ...read more.


This vacuum of press coverage of the European Parliament is a serious blow to its accountability, because scrutiny of the press and therefore the public is a key part of accountability in a liberal democracy. The Council of Ministers, the second part of the legislature also has a problem with accountability because the parliaments of member states have no control over the actions of government ministers within the EU. In many liberal democracies, a system of checks and balances is used to keep control of the 3 main branches of government, and ensure that one doesn't become too powerful. The Commission, which makes up part of the executive of the EU, is held to account by the European Parliament because the EP can dismiss the entire Commission. For example in 1999 this almost happened to the Commission headed by Santer, due to corruption charges. In the end however, the Commission all resigned before they could be called to account by the European Parliament. However, there is a weakness to this power because the EP can only dismiss the entire Commission, and not individual Commissioners. The lack of transparency in the EU institutions is a key problem for those who wish to call the EU a truly democratic institution, because accountability cannot exist without the transparency needed to scrutinise the actions of the EU. For example, meetings of the Council of Ministers, the more powerful arm of the legislature are not open to the public, although minutes are published. ...read more.


The constitution seeks to codify existing Treaties, as well as set out clearer guidelines for members to join and leave. Another of its aims is to make the EU more transparent and open to scrutiny, and therefore closer to fulfilling the ideal of accountability. From the outset it would seem that the EU has a severe democratic deficit; there would appear to be a severe lack of transparency and accountability within the Commission and European Central Bank, unclear lines of political authority and a weak parliament with no clear mandate to rule. However, on closer inspection, it can be seen that the situation isn't as bad as it would appear, with various checks already in place to ensure some degree of liberal democratic ideals are upheld. The future looks bright for the EU as well, with a new Constitution bringing in a more defined structure and even a Charter of Fundamental Rights, two huge steps towards a more democratic structure. Further steps have been suggested to reduce the democratic deficit within the EU. For example, some people feel that giving the European Parliament more powers through making all issues co-decision with the Council of Ministers will reduce the deficit. Indeed, an increasing number of issues are now decided using co-decision, showing a movement towards this. Other suggestions include changing the party list voting system to a less party dominated system such as Single Transferable Vote as used in Northern Ireland. In the distant future some people would like to see more of the EU institutions being directly elected, although many of the national governments are opposed to this suggestion, so it seems unlikely for the foreseeable future. ?? ?? ?? ?? Carrie Raynham 5/8/2007 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    ‘The main democratic deficit in the European Union is psychological, not institutional.’ Discuss.

    4 star(s)

    The German Government pressed ahead with the venture despite opposition from its own people. This example and the fact that referendums are held infrequently prove that ordinary citizens have little say on European affairs. The European parliament is, ostensibly, a mouthpiece for this trumpet but in reality it exerts little influence.

  2. The Institution of the European Union and Theories.

    State aid State aid is considered to be a scrutiny under competition policy, in many cases it is deemed as justifiable. State aid is expectable when it promotes economic growth in less funded areas. But it is deemed unfair when it is given to firms to have a competitive advantage over another firm or in the industry.

  1. Free essay

    Finnish Party System

    Following the end of World War II, the Communist Party became legal again. Together with radical socialists, the Communists formed the Finnish People's Democratic League which put forward candidates for election. The Agrarian Union heeded the rapid urbanization process and the decline of the agricultural population and changed its name to the Center Party in 1965.

  2. Which EU institution is the most powerful

    The Commission is made up of a President and the College of Commissioners (the political arm), and the Directorate Generals (DGs) and other specialised agencies (the administrative arm). The current Commission (1999-2004) consists of 20 Commissioners, including the President (Jose Manuel Borroso), who are appointed by common agreement among the

  1. What does citizenship mean in the European context?

    citizenship surely duties, the things the polity asks of its members, are as critical as that which it gives them. The demands of loyalty (not blind, to be sure), of service even, yes, of sacrifice, are as fixed a hallmark of citizenship as are rights.

  2. "To what extent will the proposed EU constitution affect, the procedure for EU/EC negotiation ...

    Parliament's powers in the legislative process were transformed from the weak and essentially unconstructive power of delay to a stronger and potentially constructive role in the drafting legislation. M. Westlake, The Commission and the Parliament: Partners and Rivals in the European Policy- Making Process (Buttleworths, 1994)

  1. Is there a democratic deficit at the heart of the European Union

    The Commission has no mandate whatsoever from the people, European voters do not elect their commissioners; member governments appoint whomever they wish (Blair appointed Kinnock (and family) and Chris Patten). This gives cynics a platform to say that these people are not always the most appropriate, but those who national governments want out of domestic politics.

  2. Effectiveness and Democratic Legitimacy: An Investigation of the European Democratic Deficit

    To many scholars this is the true essence of the democratic deficit. The European Union "lacks the constitutionally fixed balance of executive, legislative, and judicial powers underpinned by an electoral system of direct representation ordinarily found in federal systems." (Schmidt, 1997, 129)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work