• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What might be the characteristics of a "good state" according to a minimum of three political thinkers you have studied during this module.

Extracts from this document...


James Sotheran SOCPL1063 - Political Thinkers Module Leader - Liz Sperling Essay - What might be the characteristics of a "good state" according to a minimum of three political thinkers you have studied during this module There will be similarities and differences in what makes a "good state" between the political thinkers which I have selected for this essay. These are Machiavelli, Plato and Marx. I will approach this question by describing each political thinker's ideas of a good state in turn, from what I have gathered from reading 3 relevant books by each author. These books are "The Republic" (Plato), "The Prince" (Machiavelli) and "The Manifesto of The communist Party" (Marx). I will then try to find similarities between these ideas. Of these 3 books, "The Republic" gives the most detailed and clear description of an ideal state. "The Prince" reads like a guidebook for a new ruler on how to maintain a hold on the principality, it's a political and military strategy. "The Manifesto of The Communist Party" describes the existing society, and the progress by which the new one takes over. The ideal state described throughout the Republic comes from a discussion of the nature of justice in the human soul, as I described in my thinker profile. Therefore Plato's idea of a good state is a "just" state. ...read more.


He believes that people respond best to the use of fear and that it should be employed as a means of control. In "The Prince" he asserts that "it is far better to be feared than loved if you cannot be both" (p.96). This statement seems to be supported by recent events in Iraq. The ruling Ba'ath party used instruments of terror to keep effective control of the people and now the regime has fallen, it appears that it was not love for Saddam that the majority of the citizens felt, but fear. They gave the impression that he was their hero, but it was only because they were living in terror of the regime's coercive measures. Machiavelli's ideal state relies on the co-operation of it's people in maintaining it. It takes priority over everything else, mankind's highest endeavour. What is striking about "The Prince" is that the citizens seem to be used as a means to an end, the end being the ruler of the state keeping their hold on power. Machiavelli believes in taking any action necessary, moral or not, to maintain order in the state. Here there is a difference between Machiavelli's and Plato's idea of rulers of the ideal state. Plato's philosopher rulers would find the use of cruelty morally unacceptable. Plato would condemn such a society as unjust, and cruelty as being part of an unjust soul. ...read more.


This is based on the idea that the acquisition of personal property results in competition between individual people and the neglect of the state and also a division between rich and poor and therefore the danger of discontent and internal revolt. These are precisely the views that Karl Marx has about the existing capitalist society. Plato's Guardians are living in a true communist society, living and eating together like soldiers, no money or personal possessions and the rest of the community providing their food. Another main similarity between the views of these political thinkers is that the best type of state is an autocracy, with no possibility of political opposition. This is a safe way to maintain power and also political differences of opinion would interfere with the running of affairs. The leaders of the state can behave with impunity. It is not surprising that these writers have no time for democracy, because if you had what you thought was the best possible idea for a state, why would you want people around with other ideas? And if the citizens are living in the best state possible, why would they want to vote for something else? Each of these political thinkers has their own ideas of a good state, some of which clash with each other. I have listed the finer details of each, and found some fundamental similarities between all of them, which apply from the ancient world to the industrial revolution. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "Explain And Discuss How The "Ideologies Of Welfare" Explored In This Module Can Be ...

    3 star(s)

    First, basic production facilities are owned privately. Secondly, economic activity is organised and coordinated through the interaction of buyers and sellers in markets. Thirdly, owners of land and capital as well as the workers they employ are free to pursue their own self-interests in seeking maximum gain from the use of their resources and labor in production, with a restricted role of government and state.

  2. Power and Politics in Organizations: Public and Private Sector Comparisons

    the Communist party, can prevail irrespective of whether the overall system is of the federal or unitary configuration. Pluralism and Federalism in the Firm? A pluralist and federal model of the polity ill fits the generally held image of the firm and of other private-sector organizations.

  1. "...the gulf between how one should live and how one does live is so ...

    He does not state this freely - he does not believe that rulers should be able to abuse this for their own ends. To give an example of this, Machiavelli would have condoned the shooting down of the 9/11 airliners before they hit as necessary for the safety of the

  2. Niccolo Machiavelli. Niccolo Machiavelli was born in Florence, Italy on May 3rd 1469. As ...

    Senigallia, this is where he witnessed Borgia killing two of his right hand men one of which his lieutenant, Ramirez de Lorqua who where unsuccessful in doing their job and send another two away to be killed. Machiavelli admired his way; he felt if he did the same then it might be possible to restore authority.

  1. Extent of key political ideas in directly influencing change and development .

    Therefore, it could be said that the unification of Italy was more directly influenced by the rise of nationalism than the unification of Germany. However, it was other factors such as economic necessity that made the nationalist's dream of a politically unified Italy and Germany a reality.

  2. Compare and contrast some of the ways in which major political thinkers have tried ...

    Hobbes argued that due to suspicion against each other (otomistic chaos) and great feeling of insecurity, there is need to establish a body that will be able to protect them from such fear and offer peace. This could only be possible when the individuals agreed among themselves to forego their

  1. Socialist uses of workers' inquiry

    Do you know of any cases when the workers have benefitted from the so-called pensions schemes, which are controlled by the employers, but the initial capital of which is deducted beforehand from the workers' wages? 97. Are there cooperative guilds in your trade?

  2. Compare and contrast Marx and Engels with Mill regarding social and economic progress

    Materialists therefore believes in 'the unity of theory and practice', thus explaining how the active side of materialism, the practical human activity, must be used to solve philosophical, theoretical problems. Marx and Engels believe that "The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point is to change it".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work