• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Which EU institution is the most powerful

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Which EU institution is the most powerful? The European Union (EU) is currently made up of 25 countries, known as Member States, which together form the largest voluntary and peaceful block of countries in the world. Many people mistakenly view the European Union as a single body whilst in fact; the EU consists of a number of different institutions that together carry out activities on behalf of the Member States. There are many institutions but the main five being the Commission, the Council of Ministers (also called the Council of the European Union), the European Council and the European Parliament and the European Court of Justice. In this essay I am going to focus on these institutions and discuss which is to be considered more powerful. I will firstly look at each one individually and how it is organised then analyse its powers and responsibilities before comparing them and drawing up my conclusions. However I would like to note that there are many different interpretations and parameters of 'powerful' which make it difficult to answer the question. The EU was established in 1992 by the Maastricht Treaty. It comprises what are known as three 'pillars'. Firstly the EC; secondly, inter-governmental co-operation (i.e. between national governments) in foreign and security policy and the third pillar being inter-governmental co-operation in justice and home affairs. In the second and third pillars policy decisions are made by unanimous cooperation between members and cannot be enforced. Therefore for the most part, the governing institutions of the EC pillar have limited input in these pillars. ...read more.

Middle

assisted by their Foreign Ministers and the President of the Commission meet as the European Council known as Summits to the media. The European Council meets at least twice a year in Brussels under the Presidency, which is held by a member state and changes every six months. They meet primarily to define general policy guidelines. While not established by the Treaties of Rome, it was informally introduced at the Paris Summit 1974. The European Council was formally recognised as an official body of the EU in the TEU. There are three main tasks for the European Council. Firstly to provide a forum for discussing topics and policies that fall outside of the Treaty, usually relating to the future development of the Union. Secondly to facilitate the legislative process, by removing barriers in the Council of Ministers. The HOSG have the authority to resolve problematic issues that have been blocked by a lack of consensus; they are also able to construct package deals covering several policy areas. They also create policy and guidelines for the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP). Over the years the European Council has risen to the top of the EU's decision making hierarchy and is now a major agenda setter. Direct elections to the Parliament, monetary union, and the initiative of an EU rapid reaction force have all been launched at European Council level. Major Treaty reform also is agreed at this level.2 The European Parliament is the only democratically elected body of the EU. ...read more.

Conclusion

The EU institutions can be taken to Court as can member states if they are not fulfilling EU law and the Court's decisions are final, giving the Court great power and responsibility over all the institutions. However, member states have limited the Court's power in the second and third pillars. The European Council, the most recent of institutions, categorises with the Council of Ministers to make 'The Council'. However, separately it could be more powerful than the Council of Ministers because it is here where major decisions and policies are made. It guides the EU for the future and resolves problems amongst the other institutions. However I would still argue that the Council of Ministers is more powerful as the European Council meet only maybe twice a year while the decision making Council of Ministers are influencing the EU all year round with the majority of legislative. It is clear how the member states are not willing to pass legislative powers to a supranational body such as the Commission or other EU institutions but instead pass the legislative powers to the Council which consists of national government ministers, this is characteristic of a confederal system with federalising tendencies. Moreover the EU has moved away from the limits of a neo-functionalism system and more towards liberal intergovernmentalism. This has again removed some of the powers of the Commission and given greater significance to the role of the Council of Ministers as a legislative body representing the interests of the member states. Indeed, there is no question that the member states have lost powers to the EU and have less political and economic independence than they did at the outset of the EU. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level European Union section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level European Union essays

  1. The European Commission - transforming the framework of the EU set up by the ...

    Therefore, as all commissioners must favour all countries evenly, the fact that the larger countries, such as the UK, seems to be a somewhat pointless exercise, and implies that they are their on behalf of their countries, even though they are there on behalf of the EU.

  2. Free essay

    Labour and Conservative parties policies on the EU have become increasingly similar. Discuss. discuss

    they are against this because further integration means giving up more sovereignty. Therefore while Labour is pro-enlargement in order to stop federalism, conservatives are pro-enlargement not only because they are anti-federalist but also because a larger Europe means less integration, therefore no loss in sovereignty.

  1. How important is the European Parliament?

    Before this case, the European Parliament was only allowed to be a defendant in ECJ cases and not a plaintiff, the body who brings the case. The Comitology Case of a few months previously had not allowed the EP to bring a case against the Council, and thus the Commission.

  2. Disneyland Resort Paris, Case Study

    Questions 1) More than a decade later, has Disney's top management completely addressed the lack of cultural sensitivity observed at the opening of the first park in 1992? Although Disneyland Paris has made adjustments to its alcohol policy (reversing it), its dining facilities (offering a more diverse dinning options ranging from three-star-restaurants to affordable fast food or take away restaurants)

  1. EU functions

    At first all parties are involved and the judge creates a summary of the statements made, then there is a public hearing, lawyers of the parties argue there cases and can be questioned by the advocate-general. The advocate general then gives their opinion on the case and is followed by judge's final judgement.

  2. WAS THE ROYAL COMMISSION OF 1832-1834 THE MOST IMPORTANT INFLUENCE ON THE TERMS OF ...

    This attitude as well as the worsening agricultural conditions influenced the terms of the New Law particularly the abolition of outdoor relief for the able- bodied poor. Undoubtedly the Whig government was a major influence on the terms of the new Poor Law.

  1. What Are The Functions Of The Four EU Institutions? How Are European Laws Made?

    The third most important in law making powers is the commission. The commission is like a civil service if you will. Each member state appoints a commissioner, but the commission also includes all of the specialist staff that makes up the various departments.

  2. The EU's CFSP and the Iraq Crisis: A Catalyst for Change?

    Blair, being much more pro-EU than previous administrations, began efforts to increase EU security cooperation, including a famous summit between Britain and France at Saint Malo in 1998 in which the two countries declared their commitment to a common EU security and defense scheme.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work