• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Why does philosophy play such a large part in the conversation about justice in Plato's Republic?"

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Why does philosophy play such a large part in the conversation about justice in Plato's Republic?" Plato, in common with thinkers both before and long after him, was a man of his times. Critiques of politics and society must be understood in relation to the context in which they were constructed, whether in support of or antagonistic to contemporary socio-political realities. Plato was born into the powerful city - state of Athens. Through her navy, the superlative sea - bound military force in the Greek world, Athens had developed a strong economy and feeling of dominance. Robert Hall notes "...the disposition of the Athenian character to pleonexia, to always getting more..." This thirst for power however, four years before Plato's birth, led to a clash with Sparta and an embarrassing Athenian defeat. This defeat Plato saw as illustrative of Athens' political shortcomings, the practical eventuality of their flawed underlying principles which, in the Republic, he attempts to challenge. A successful polis can never be realised until - and this is the basis of Plato's ideas - philosophers have become rulers, until politics is subordinated to knowledge and wisdom, to what is understood as 'philosophy.' ...read more.

Middle

In opposition here is the conception of justice as truly individual self - interest, whereby everyone is fighting everyone else, and self - interested 'justice' on a social scale, where the stronger are supposed to eschew self - interest for a common goal. As Socrates quickly makes clear, this argument will not suffice as a useful concept of justice. What it needs in definition is philosophy - the considered approach. Plato, through his narrator Socrates, slowly begins to build up his definition of justice. The body has, at its most basic level, needs. It is not self - sufficient, at least beyond that of mere subsistence. "[the body] certainly has needs. That is the reason why medicine has been discovered, because the body has defects and is not self - sufficient; medical skill was, in fact, developed to look after the interests of the body." Doctors, to use one of Socrates' many examples, "prescribes with a view not to his own interest but that of his patient." Each person's particular skill has its function within society, and using the body as an analogy, Socrates illustrates how everyone, keeping to and developing their own particular excellence, benefits themselves while also contributing to a more just and therefore better whole. ...read more.

Conclusion

the broods of desires within him, and not to rule them," but it is then the purpose of philosopher - rulers to educate and rule in a way which "impress[es] upon him [the man ruled by desire] from outside, so that as far as possible we may all be alike and all be friends, since we are all steered by the same helmsman." The 'ship of state' (the metaphor to which Plato here is referring) must be sailed by philosophers, those possessed with knowledge of the forms and not seduced through desire by mere appearances, which is for the benefit of all. Philosophy plays a large part in the discussion of justice in the Republic because this, the pursuit of philosophy, is the basis of the platonic project. This application of idealism to practical situations has dominated political thinking from Plato until the late nineteenth century; modern political philosophy has been summarised succinctly as 'footnotes to Plato.' Plato's ideas had practical ends - he established his Academy to train philosopher rulers and realise the proposals in the Republic, but it was theory which determined practice and without solid theory, practical failure (such as the defeat of his native Athens at the hands of Sparta) would surely follow. Bottom of Form ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Political Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Political Philosophy essays

  1. Liberalism Notes

    Paine a liberal? (uncompromising individualism, sympathies with manfacturers, hostility to government). Or a socialist? (Blueprint for the Welfare State, support for graduated income tax, inspiration for Chartists). More impact in USA/France than in Britain - seen as dangerous due to uncompromising republicanism, total opposition to hereditary principle, rejection of Christianity.

  2. Andrew Jackson: Common Man or Common Scoundrel

    By his early adulthood, Jackson had in actuality "[consolidated] his position among the budding aristocrats, the owners of slaves and horses, the holders of offices and titles" (Hofstadter 60). When visiting the South, however, he appeared as a genteel aristocrat and provided entertainment at the Hermitage.

  1. Socialist uses of workers' inquiry

    the wages sink - for, like the price of any other commodity, they are determined by the cost of production. Therefore, in the same manner in which labor becomes more unsatisfactory, more repulsive, do competition increase and wages decrease. The laborer seeks to maintain the total of his wages for

  2. Russia's Political Party System as an Obstacle to Democratization

    own parties' base of support to receive the endorsement of other parties and support from the electoral base of those other parties to win. Given the level of interparty rivalries that exist in Russia, such coalition-building is difficult to achieve.

  1. Power and Politics in Organizations: Public and Private Sector Comparisons

    Because these organizations are the tools of those who lead them and can be used to accumulate vast resources, a power struggle typically occurs over their control (pp. 14-17). And because of goal displacement that may accompany such power struggles, organizations may well become 'things-in-themselves' (pp.

  2. The study of international or rather global politics, seeks to provide an account of ...

    Philosophers such as Bodin and Hobbes also proceed from the concept of a state of nature characterised by competion and greed and acknowledge the neeed for rule of law to guard against anarchy. According to Machiavelli, government is founded on the weakness and insufficiency of the individual, who is unable

  1. Evolution of Democracy and the Athenian Constitution

    In Draco's time the changes in the military, fighting techniques and external threats caused further change in the socio-political structure. An ancient Greek poet describing a battle scene mentions how an organized column of armed and armored men stopped the charge of the cavalry.

  2. Marxism, Idealism and Nationalism

    The bourgeois represented the base of material interest. The relationship between the two eventually becomes exploitative because the members of the superstructure do not own productive property, nor do they control the means of production. All they can offer is their human labor for essential needs. Today some of these concepts still apply to our world, and some do not.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work