• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critical Review of `The awkward moments test: a naturalistic measure of social understanding in autism`

Free essay example:

Critical Review of `The awkward moments test: a naturalistic measure of social understanding in autism`

Autism spectrum disorder encompasses a range of deficits which are described by the

triad of impairments; qualitative impairments in social interaction and qualitative

communication areas and narrow or rigid routines and/or interests. Another aspect of

autism spectrum disorder is the weak centre of coherence and the notion of theory of

mind; of which there is many tests to test this. The awkward moments test is used to

represent a measure of mental state in individuals; in this case, individuals with

autism. The test is designed to assess an individual’s ability to read another person` s

thoughts manifested by their behaviours such as: verbal and non – verbal

communication, recognizing the social cues involved in communication. This ability

is known as the theory of mind, Dennett (1978) proposed `…if a person was unable to

understand the thoughts or intentions of another person, much of social interaction

and communication would be a mystery`. Diagnosis is a complex process which can

contribute to individual needs such as education needs of an individual. The awkward

moments test can demonstrate difficulties for individuals with autism spectrum

disorder and there has been a great deal of research into autism, similarly, there is a

multitude of research into the notion of theory of mind a lot of which is with children

and in this study, adults are utilized as the participants.

The study involved qualitative accounts from participants when presented with a short

film in which social interaction occurred between individuals. The participants were

asked to infer as to the mental states of the actors in the films. There were 31

participants used in this study in all, 16 individuals with high functioning autism and a

comparison group of 15 individuals; these were selected to broadly match the autism

group in terms of intellectual ability and reading competence. The Wechsler Objective

Reading Dimensions (WORD) was used for basic reading and reading comprehension

for each of the groups as the awkward moments test requires the ability to read and

write. Each participant took part in the awkward moments test; it involved being

presented with a short film of interactions between people and then being asked a

question about a specific part of the film; questions inferring to their mental states.

The strange stories task was also used in this study to contribute to the experimental

prediction as the awkward moments test on its own would not be enough evidence

alone.

The results showed that they supported the experimental prediction. The participants

used in the study were selected carefully; using tests a range of tests to determine IQ

scores of participants and controlling this by having a control group with similar IQ.

Theory of mind tests and IQ tests showed a correlation between the control group, but

not in the autism group, however previous studies (e.g., Happé, 1995; Sparrevohn &

Howie, 1995)

This study has set out to study theory of mind in individuals with autism spectrum

disorder using a number of tests, the main test being the awkward moments test. The

main test is demonstrates a link between autism and the theory of mind. Simon Baron

– Cohen and colleagues developed a test of whether or not children with autism

understood false belief, named the `Sally – Anne Task`. This task involved an

imaginary situation of two dolls acting out a scene which involved one doll putting a

marble into a basket, once out of the room the other doll places the marble into

another container. The child is asked where will the first doll look for her marble and

depending on the answer given it will give an indication as to whether or not the child

has developed theory of mind or not. Tests like these are specifically designed to test

theory of mind and now there are other areas which have been discovered since theory

of mind was proposed. These areas include mental state language words like `think`,

`know`, `believe` in speech, they also have great difficulty understanding or engaging

in deception. With this in mind, it is difficult to conduct tests on individuals with

autism spectrum disorder. A question that arises from study is how do these findings

relate to an individual with dual diagnosis such as downs syndrome and autism

spectrum disorder?

Although the study uses participants with a range of autism spectrum disorders; it

does not fully account for others with more debilitating autism spectrum disorders,

however it does give some valuable insight into theory of mind of individuals. An

important point is that each participant is an individual and each individual brings a

different aspect to the autism spectrum. It is noted that there is a genetic possibility as

to the causal links of autism spectrum disorders and the role of the environment in

autism.

References

Dennett, D., (1998) `Beliefs about beliefs`, Behaviour and Brain sciences, vol.4, pp.568-70.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Developmental Psychology section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related AS and A Level Psychology Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related AS and A Level Developmental Psychology essays

  1. "Northern Lights" by Philip Pullman - review

    and a lot of unusual or made up words such as "alethiometer" which is a mysterious truth-seeking or future-telling device. Another example of this is "D�mon". A D�mon is a Soul-like companion to each individual human being. D�mons are generally of the opposite gender to their human counterparts.

  2. Free essay

    A qualitative study to explore the meaning of identity using interview data and relating ...

    but the second interviewer tended to ask more open-ended questions to both where either one had the opportunity to answer (and usually Tony tended to answer first). An interesting occurrence was when he asked a question about their children's experiences and Jo actually looks at Tony as if she is

  1. Using studies from the list below, answer the questions which follow: Rosenhan (sane in ...

    It was learnt that it is not possible to conclude that the differences in brain activity did cause the individuals to commit murder and the results definitely do not suggest that violence is determined by biology alone. Neither do the results tell us what caused the differences in brain activity

  2. Intelligence is impossible to define or measure

    age was less than average, whilst the younger one might have a lower mental age than the older child yet have greater than the average of its age group. Therefore given the need to compare children of different ages, Stern, a German psychologist suggested the Intelligence Quotient, known as I.Q,

  1. PERSONALITY DISORDERS

    The high rate of suicidal ideation in borderline personality disorder correlates with high rates of suicidal behaviour (Morey, 1993) with approximately 6% succeeding in their attempts (Perry, 1993, M.H Stone, 1989, both cited in Barlow & Durand, 2002) The concept of spectrum personality disorder suggests that personality disorders are an

  2. Blue Remembered Hills - review

    The girls via for his attention when they play mummies and daddies. Angels plays mummy and wife to Donald, Donald plays the husband and Audrey doesn't know what to be. Angela says that Audrey can be her naughty daughter, but Audrey refuses.

  1. For this assignment I have decided to look at the disorder known as ADHD ...

    By insisting that ICD-10 criteria are met before treating for ADHD, clinicians in the U.K. are depriving a group of children with significant impairment (who fulfil DSM-1V criteria) proper treatment and intervention (Munden and Arcelus 1999). It is thought that only one in ten children with ADHD in Britain has been identified and is receiving help.

  2. "Hieroglyphics" by Anne Donovan.

    Her teachers did not know how to deal with her. In history her teacher, Miss Niven, allowed Mary to continue to draw hieroglyphics when the others in the class were progressing with the next topic: "and the rest ae the class moved on tae the Second World War but ah

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work