• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the view that psychology offers a gender bias

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Discuss the view that psychology offers a gender-biased representation of human behaviour (30 marks) It has been claimed by some feminist psychologists (e.g Nicolson) that psychology is biased both at a theoretical level and also in the way that psychologists carry out their research. Many of the major theories in psychology either have shown a bias against women or have ignored women specifically, preferring to assume that their development would be no different from men's. The first of these approaches is described as an alpha bias, in that some theories suggest an enduring difference between genders, an example being Freud's psychosexual development theory. Many such theories offer a view of gender differences based on the ideas of biological essentialism, treating all differences as though they follow essentially from biologicial differences between the sexes. The second is beta bias, meaning that some theories ignore any possible differences between the sexes and present a theory (often based solely on the study of men) ...read more.

Middle

The difference between these stages is that one reflects social morality (e.g laws) whereas the other reflects morality of personal relationships. Kohlberg thought that the latter was less mature. This view was criticised by Gilligan who claimed that women were not morally inferior to men but spoke in a different moral voice, based on care and responsibility rather than being dominated by male notions of justice. She suggested that Kohlberg had obtained his results because of the very abstract dilemmas used in his research, but when using real life dilemmas (e.g whether to have an abortion), women showed just as much evidence of mature moral development. Critics of Gilligans theory (e.g Unger and Crawford) have argued that Gilligan's research was not comparable with the rather more abstract dilemmas faced by Kohlberg's subjects. Gilligan was also accused of showing a failure to explore factors other than gender which could be related to differences in moral reasoning (e.g social class, education, race/ethnicity). ...read more.

Conclusion

Questions about similarities and differences between the sexes are not just scientific questions, they may also be seen as highly political. Research has attempted to answer important questions about the differences between males and females using traditional experimental designs that lack the sensitivity to explore the questions being asked. The results of such research have then been used to exclude women from some occupations or to represent women as being victims of their own bodies. Menstruation has, in particular, captured the imagination of both scientists and feminists. The 'discovery' of prementrual syndrome, during which female hormones become so unstable as to aparently render some women capable of murder, has led to a great deal of experimental research in this area (e.g Nicolson, 1997). Nicolson argues that many of the performance and mood differences traditionally identified between premenstrual women and others were products of poor research design. Several other well-designed studies, she claims, reported no differences but these were not published, as their findings were subject to doubt. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Psychology of Individual Differences section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Psychology of Individual Differences essays

  1. The Gestalt Theory

    As the client becomes more attuned to the ways in which they interrupt themselves, the 'now', they will start to experience and feel the self that they have interrupted. The therapist can pick up on body language such as a clenched fist as if to punch someone or a swinging

  2. Define different theoretical perspectives used in counselling. Analyse the advantages and ...

    Individuals like Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow felt existing (psychodynamic) theories failed to adequately address issues like the meaning of behaviour, and the nature of healthy growth. However, the result was not simply new variations on psychodynamic theory, but rather a fundamentally new approach."

  1. Discuss research into one error of attribution (self serving bias)

    did badly teachers attributed this to the pupils' lack of effort or ability and saw it as the pupils' responsibility (self-protecting bias) however over time as the pupils began to improve, the teachers altered their attributions and explained their pupils' successes as down to their own efforts as teachers; they

  2. Discuss gender and cultural bias in psychological research

    Eagly and Carli claim that the task involved an activity that was more familiar to men and so the experiment was beta biased. All participants were also male, and so this uses a biased sample group and then generalises the results to the whole population.

  1. Consider the Problems Faced by Psychologists in the Definition of Abnormality

    These six criteria are outlined below: 1. Positive attitudes towards the self- To understand themselves as a person, so that they can accept their limitations and possibilities; to have realistic view of themselves. The person has a positive, healthy attitude towards himself in the areas of self-confidence, self-respect, self-reliance and self-acceptance; they are able to live with themselves as the person they are.

  2. Notes on Important Psychology Experiments and Theories.

    Skinner (1938) Learning ? Classical Conditioning Conclusion: Watson and Rayner showed that fear responses could be learned and even very young children could learn in the way suggested by classical conditioning. Method: Albert was 11 months old. He seemed to like a white laboratory rat and had no fear of white furry objects.

  1. Psychopathology, Theories and Treatment Revision notes (Psychology AS)

    approach * Brain scanning and tech has identified biological aspects of many conditions * Biological treatments are very effective * Reductionist ? it simplifies complex disorders to a simple set of factors and ignores other approaches * Genetic studies do not provide 100% concordance for a genetic link which suggests

  2. Discuss issues of bias in diagnostic systems

    Although this study was conducted in 1973, it provides some important evidence for a general inability to tell the difference between normal and abnormal behaviour. Thomas Szasz also suggested that it is wrong to use a mental illness metaphor to describe behaviour that does not conform to our expectations.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work