• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate recent challenges to nativist theories of language development.

Extracts from this document...


TMA 05 Evaluate recent challenges to nativist theories of language development. Nativist's beleive that language is acquired through the operation of innate factors and that biological maturation governs development (Mareschall et al. 2006). For the purpose of this paper the word "innate" will be used in the same context as Grayson et al. (2005) did. Nativists propose that children are born with a formal language system known as Universal Grammar (Chomsky, 1995). The environment, in their view, only plays a part in aiding infants decide which of the universal rules to apply (Mareschall et al. 2006). To challenge the nativist view I will cover some aspects of language development where there is clear opposite views on how certain processes develop. The opposition is represented by empiricists, who believe that the environment is indispensable for development. The different approaches will be considered in light of their differences and ways in which they may contradict one another. Each theoretical point will be looked at alongside evidence from researches. It is worth noting that whilst these theories seem to be total opposites they to not deny the existence of one another but differ in the importance they place on each element (Mareschall et al. ...read more.


1998). Similar studies on temporal lobe damage carried out by researchers such as Stiles and Thal (1993) have given further neuroscientific support to epigenesis. Whilst Mia Lherpiniere X7374356 TMA 05 these studies do not dismiss the possibility of the left hemisphere being designated for language, they simply emphasise that "they are not critical since language can develop in a close to normal way without [them]" (Johnson, 1997, p. 142). Looking beyond the biological argument the debate carries on through two propositions of how children acquire and produce grammar: single and dual route theory (Mareschall et al. 2006). Children's inflectional morphology follows a curved pattern which begins with correct application of outer layers; for example adding "ed" at the end of a word indicates the past tense. Inflections then become disrupted as grammatical rules are over generalised producing common errors such as "goed". With experience children then seem able to apply regular and irregular forms of various tenses with ease. This pattern of development is called the U-shape (Plunkett and Wood, 2006). A conventional account for this process is that infants simply memorise the correct formation and as they discover grammatical rules they over apply them creating mistakes, then as the rules become more robust they eliminate the over-regularisations and adopt the correct format for nouns and verbs (Plunkett and Wood, 2006) ...read more.


On balance the empirical evidence supports the epigenetic view of modularisation a process by which genes and the environment work together to create self organisation (Karmiloff-Smith, 1992). Neuroscience further supports a view in between nativists and empiricist, whilst they are able to produce evidence that the brain is capable of supporting language in other areas it is unmistakable that damage to left hemisphere (the seat of language) can severely effect language development. How children acquire and produce grammar is debated Mia Lherpiniere X7374356 TMA 05 through single and dual route theory. Empirical evidence has given greater support to the single route theory which does not deny elements of nature but also incorporates nurture. Connectionist networks are becoming a common method to test theories and have been used to lend support to many language theories such as the distributional approach. Children through out the world inevitably learn their mother tongue whether it be by speech or sign (Karmiloff-Smith, 2002). What is substantive is whether this is due solely to operant conditioning of caregivers or to an innate principle of universal grammar. In view of the evidence presented in this paper it seems implausible that language can develop without the presence of both nature and nurture as Bruner (1983) conveys; "we shall make little progress if we adhere either to the impossible account of extreme empiricism or to the miraculous one of pure nativism." (Bruner 1983, P. 10). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Developmental Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Developmental Psychology essays

  1. Levels Of Processing

    This suggests that deeper processing leads to enhanced memory. Finally the experiment carried out by Craik and Lockhart 1972 using free recall is what this project will be based on. Their experiment supports their theory (the levels of processing model).

  2. Using studies from the list below, answer the questions which follow: Rosenhan (sane in ...

    Also, in the thalamus, the NGRIs had more activity in the right side, though no difference in the left side. Raine et al. did not believe that that other forms of psychiatric comorbidity can easily account for their findings, because differences in brain functioning in murderers show a different pattern to that observed in other mental disorders.

  1. Compare, Contrast and Evaluate the Nativist and Empiricist Views of Infant Perception

    The infant is then presented with a new stimulus, and monitored to see if there is a renewed interest in the novel stimulus and a longer time is spent looking at it (dishabituation). If the infant does show a renewed interest, it can be inferred that the infant can discriminate between the two stimuli.

  2. Psychology Cae Studies

    Methodology The subjects in experiment one were all from the same state school in Bristol, this means that they were a homogeneous group. The age group of the boys could have also been a factor as boys from this age group 14-15 are generally competitive with each other in Western society.

  1. To provide age/ability appropriate activities/experiences that will encourage the development of knowledge and understanding ...

    Like a house. Without the walls the roof will fall, with out the foundations to learning the child will have difficulties. All of the activities can be implemented by all of the children with in the Pre School. All of the activities can be implemented by all of the children

  2. This assignment describes and analyses my involvement with a 13-year-old client Joe Smith, who ...

    and two other siblings Jack (aged 16) and Tom (aged 18) who live outwith the family home. Mum and Dad have always lived together although never married. Parsons (1951) would deem this family as being deviant and undesirable as they do not conform to the functionalist perspective of the "Nuclear Family" (Thompson, 2001)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work