• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

free will and determinism

Extracts from this document...


Discuss the free will and determinism debate in psychological research. There have been many arguments questioning the existence of free will and determinism. There have also been endless debates regarding if individuals are capable of making their own choices or if behaviour is predetermined and controlled by internal and external forces instead of an individual's will. Free will is the notion that we are able to make choices in our behaviour, allowing us to separate our intentions clearly from events that have been caused by internal or external factors. One argument for the existence of free will is the psychological argument, stating that everyone has a subjective sense of free will, and that many individuals feel that they are able to make their own free choices. However, simply experiencing this sense of free does not necessarily mean that it is true. Skinner claimed that free will was simply an illusion, we think we are free as we do not understand how our behaviour is determined by reinforcement. ...read more.


Determinism is the notion that all behaviour is pre determined therefore predictable. Individuals make no choices in regard to their behaviour and following outcome. One argument for determinism is the predictability of human behaviour. People believe and are aware of their predictability as well as the predictability of others. Mischel's theory of personality on the other hand challenged this claim, as he suggested that people do not have one consistent personality, but it differs according to the situation. Meaning that we are only consistent when exposed to the exact same type of situations. However, Fleeson found in a more recent study that people are highly consistent even when exposed to different environments and situations. Another argument for determinism is that studies on human behaviour can be applied to the real world as seen in Rosenman's and Friedman's research into stress and cardiovascular disease, however studies that were orchestrated in a lab environment may not be applicable to the real world. ...read more.


This could give an example of free will as the process is mostly about thinking. The cognitive approach can also be seen as deterministic through the use of schemas, as schemas create expectations which determine our behaviours and perceptions Humanistic psychologists believe that we are all free to plan our own actions, in turn enabling us to plan our own destinies. Self actualisation is a key concept which was coined by Jahoda's ideal mental health and Maslow's theory on motivation, with it being the top need to be fulfilled. In conclusion the concept of free will is more philosophical then scientific as there is no real way to falsify it. Free will in effect can only exist in a deterministic world, as each of the choices that we make will ultimately have some kind of effect. Our actions would not be able to have an effect if cause and effect relationships did not exist, cause and effect is seen as deterministic as the appropriate cause will lead to the desired effect, therefore determinism is seen to be more likely to explain human behaviour then the concept of free will. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Social Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Response to the question

This is an excellent answer. The candidate demonstrates a clear understanding and appreciation of the task set to them and also shows capabilities of someone who can nicely structure a coherent and effective essay in order to satisfy the question's ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This is an excellent answer. The candidate demonstrates a clear understanding and appreciation of the task set to them and also shows capabilities of someone who can nicely structure a coherent and effective essay in order to satisfy the question's demands. There is perhaps a bias to the information about the free will argument in terms of the quantity of words written, but in terms of the points that the questions asks for, both are fairly balanced, with perhaps the determinism side being rushed and explained in lesser detail than the free will argument, thus showing the examiner that the candidate may have run short of time and quickly moved onto the next section. The candidate later goes on to discuss the views of important psychological approaches with regard to the free will and determinism debate in Psychology, each of which are fairly detailed though a more explicit reference to the beliefs about free will and determinism wouldn't go amiss and would nicely round off each of these paragraphs by directly addressing the question.

Level of analysis

The Level of Analysis, whilst very prescriptive and rigidly structured, is the best way to answer a question like this. Ideally, candidates are looking for an integrated answer that concerns other debates in Psychology along with the debate they are directly addressing (so for instance here, the determinism debate could link very easily with the Scientific Debate and also Quantitative Data). Some candidates find this hard to do, especially under strict time constraints, so my best advice is, if you're pushed for time, go for two simple strengths and two weakness for both free will and determinism (balance is important in a psychological discussion), as this will naturally encourage a fair analysis. I commend the candidates reference to psychological evidence with each strength and limitation given as this helps strengthen an argument by providing the examiner with real factual evidence to support the theories/debates/issues that are being discussed.

Quality of writing

The Quality of Written Communication here is very good. The candidate, from a Psychology perspective, uses a number of appropriately applied terminologies that give the examiner an indication of their ability to construct effective discussion using the language of the professionals. The candidate also uses spelling, grammar and punctuation proficiently, with no errors throughout.

Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by sydneyhopcroft 24/07/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Social Psychology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Describe what psychologists have learned about environmental disaster and/or technological catastrophe.

    4 star(s)

    Evaluate what psychologists have learned about environmental disaster and/or technological catastrophe The first evaluation issue is Methodology, and the fact that most of the research into disasters and catastrophes is carried out after the event and therefore it is impossible to make comparisons of responses before the disaster.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    The effect of the Level of Processing on the amount of information recalled

    4 star(s)

    The same age group of participants was used. The target group was of mixed ability year 11 students. Participants were both male and female. The time limit given for answering the questions and, effectively, remembering the words and time allowed for recall was the same each time.

  1. Marked by a teacher

    What are ideal types? How useful are they in helping us to understand contemporary ...

    for causal relationships, Weber distinguished between the social and natural sciences and therefore moved away from what he considered to be the positivist pretence of a completely objective 'science' of sociology. Webers belief was that it is futile to aspire to complete objectivity because all knowledge about the world is

  2. Pro and Anti Social Behaviour

    Bateson et al (1981) asked female participants to take the place of 'Elaine', a confederate, who was receiving electric shocks. The findings showed that participants who were led to believe that a placebo drug they took led to empathetic concern offered to take the shocks even when they were given the opportunity to leave.

  1. "Anti-Social Behaviour is caused by a person's family background"

    was able to improve the structure of my questionnaire so that the questions were more understandable. Also, people seemed to leave out the question about their parents occupation, this may be because the question was to personal or because it involved them writing it, instead of simply ticking a box.

  2. An Investigation to see whether the halo effect is present when rating personality ...

    individuals were efficiently assigned to Condition 1 and Condition 2, Condition 1 were given the 'attractive picture' first to rate on personality traits and then the 'unattractive' picture whereas in Condition 2 participants were given the 'unattractive' picture first to rate followed by the 'attractive' picture.

  1. Discuss the Free will vs. Determinism debate

    Disregarding any form of individual intelligence, it reduces complex behaviours into a series of stimulus response units that respond to reinforcement. Therefore, this explanation may be more applicable to simpler, non-human behaviour, limiting the generalisability of the applications to the real world.

  2. Conformity & Obedience to Authority.

    Once this had been established, the participants did not complain much about the experiment and carried on. The experimenters absence seemed to give a greater feeling of personal responsibility for their own actions and it became clear that many people would inflict a greater amount of pain if someone else took responsibility as it took away the guilt.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work