• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Images are recalled better than words

Extracts from this document...


Images are recalled better than words. Abstract The aim of this experiment is to find out if images are recalled better than words. In order to test this, I conducted a lab experiment using 15 participants. There were two parts to the experiment. For the first part, participants were shown a list of words which they had to recall and then they were shown images. Subjects were given one minute to recall the words and images. The results were statistical findings that showed that participants were significantly better at remembering the pictures than the words. The overall conclusion is that images are recalled better than words which proves the experimental hypothesis. These findings may apply to a number of situations, including teaching methods as well as an aid for studying. Further studies may include a closer look at gender and/or age differences for short-term memory recall using the same method. Introduction. Conrad (1964) suggested that short-term memory codes all information acoustically, that is, according to sound. Visual information is encoded (transformed) to its acoustic (sound/language) codes. Shulman (1970) disagreed and thought that short-term memory also coded information visually and according to semantics (meaning). Heyer and Barrett (1974) suggested that visual images that are difficult to acoustically code may also be stored briefly in short term memory. Conrad conducted a study to prove his claim. he showed participants a list of consonants, for about 3/4 of a second. ...read more.


therefore this would be the best method to use for my research. however there disadvantages of conducting lab experiments. firstly The experiment is not typical of real life situations. Most experiments are conducted in laboratories - strange and contrived environments in which people are asked to perform unusual or even bizarre tasks. The artificiality of the lab, together with the 'unnatural' things that the subjects may be asked to do, jointly produces a distortion of behaviour. Therefore it should be difficult to generalise findings from experiments because they are not ecologically valid. Also Behaviour in the laboratory is very narrow in its range. By controlling the situation so precisely, behaviour may be very limited. A major difficulty with the experimental method is demand characteristics. Some of the many confounding variables in a psychology experiment stem from the fact that a psychology experiment is a social situation in which neither the Subjects or the Experimenters are passive, inanimate objects but are active, thinking human beings. Imagine you've been asked to take part in a psychology experiment. Even if you didn't study psychology, you would be trying to work out what the experimenter expected to find out. Experimenters too have expectations about what their results are likely to be. Demand characteristics are all the cues which convey to the participant the purpose of the experiment. using undergraduate students would therefore be unrepresentative of the general population. ...read more.


10 2 80 100 -20 20 -5 70 100 -30 30 -7.5 90 100 -10 10 -2 80 100 -20 20 -5 90 100 -10 10 -2 90 100 -10 10 -2 Sum of positive ranks = 13.5 Sum of negative ranks = 33.5 Discussion The results of this study supported the hypothesis in that images are recalled well than words. Fewer participants recalled words whereas recall of images was higher. Jacob (1887) suggested that short-term memory has a limited capacity of about 5 to 9 items this might be why participants could remember the images or words shown. Baddeley (1966) suggested that visual, acoustic and semantic all are ways of encoding things in your memory. This could suggest that participants in the study might have related the visual information with a meaning in order to recall the better. Pictures access semantic meaning more quickly and completely than words. Most of the participants were female this might have lead to biased results. If this experiment was to be done again than half of the participants should be female and the other half male. Scientifically women recall emotional events far better than men. Perhaps during the experiment participants might have related some of the images to emotional events in their life. According to the common code theory pictures and words both require analogous processing before accessing semantic information. It suggests that pictures require less time than words for accessing the common conceptual system. Overall the experiment suggests that images are recalled well than words. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology essays

  1. Investigating the short-term memory

    background theories listed above which help explain the findings of the investigation. The experimenter ensured that participants were treated and explained to clearly and equally. Random sample was used and it is strength of this experiment because its representative of the target population and everyone has an equal chance of being chosen.

  2. Will participants have a better recall of words when they are presented in an ...

    Half of the participants were asked to simply copy out the list of words, whilst the other half were asked to order them logically before writing them down. Recall was greater in those who had been asked to organise the lists of words themselves.

  1. To see whether giving people a displacement activity before recalling the words would affect ...

    be stored in the long term memory and the others would be displaced from the short term memory by doing the counting. Method Design: My independent variable is the displacement activity I am carrying out which is to do the three times table up to sixty.

  2. An experiment to investigate whether chunking leads to better recall.

    The middle of the list is somewhere between the two stores. This theory was supported by Murdock's research, which showed that people are more likely to recall words at the beginning and end of a list. This graph shows the affects of serial positioning.

  1. Investigating Levels Of Processing Using Images

    Incidental learning was used and results found retention was found to be 51% higher after semantic tasks. They concluded that Incidental learners recall as well as intentional learners, suggesting that it is the nature of processing that determines recall. o Level of Processing - D. Rumelhart & D. Norman (1978)

  2. An experiment to investigation the effect of sorting words by their meaning and sorting ...

    In psychology, this is known as the levels of processing. However, it may be argued that the student who re-writes the information in the textbook simply spends longer looking at the information than the student who copies the information straight out of the book so this is why they remember more of the information.

  1. Investigation into acoustic and visual encoding in short-term memory

    However, with repeated neural activity (e.g. brought about by rehearsal) a permanent structural change comes about and the memory is transferred to LTM where it is no longer likely to decay. One study, which looked into the displacement theory, was carried out by Waugh and Norman (1965)

  2. Find out if recall of words is better when recalled in the environmental context ...

    Debriefing allows participants to be assured that the experimental results will not be used to suggest their level of intelligence ect. It also allows researches to thank participants for their involvement. Consent - informed consent from parents of participants under 16 will be sought Confidentiality - will be dealt with

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work