• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Parkers participant observation describes The Boys everyday lives but what else does it do? Critically consider the impact of the study and its relevance to theory, methodology, and policy.

Extracts from this document...


Parker's participant observation describes 'The Boys' everyday lives but what else does it do? Critically consider the impact of the study and it's relevance to theory, methodology, and policy. In this essay I will be looking at the observational study carried out by Howard Parker, 'A View from the Boys' (1947). In this study Parker covertly participated to find out about the lives of a gang of adolescent boys from Liverpool. The study was looking into the sub-culture aspect of crime and deviance with a strong hold of Functionalism. Both the Functionalist and the sub-culture theories stress the learning of norms and values are crucial to the relation to crime committed. The sub-culture in Parker's study focused on the behaviour and beliefs of the boys that he studied that differentiated them from the public generally. The sub-culture in a 'View from the Boys' came about due to the boys being in a gang and separating themselves from the rest of the public and engaging themselves in criminal behaviour. It is possible to see that it would have been difficult for Parker to have gained access to the group. This is a difficult aspect of participant observation as the observer cannot go into a group without them being curious, which would affect their behaviour and would question the validity of the study. However, in Parkers case he was easily able to gain access as he had met some of the boys previously at a country holiday centre set up for Liverpool's deprived children. In addition to this it was necessary that Parker would fit in with the boys. ...read more.


As it can be seen in Roundhouse that the community was made up of large families that were knit up together by blood and marriage, it is possible to see that there was a certain element of social solidarity where the boy's future was concerned. All the families in the Roundhouse accepted the fact that the boys were not going to get a good job and this normalised criminality. This was giving a clear account of what actually took place in the Liverpool slums, rather then relying on the media or stereotypical views that were bought about the 'rough' area from where the boy's were from. Parker showed that there was an understanding in the neighbourhood and there was tolerance to some activities. For example, if the boy's stole something the neighbours wouldn't be offended as long as it wasn't from any members of the estate. This allowed there to be a very stable, solid community orientated approach to family life. By focusing on the working class males of Liverpool, not only did Parker study their behaviour but it could also be seen that he saw that their norms and values were completely different from the upper and middle classes. This came as a disadvantage to the boy's as it was the upper and middle class that determined what was to be seen as criminal behaviour as they weren't used to the lifestyle of the boy's and they did, to some extent have control over the making and defining of new legislations that were to be passed on anti-social behaviours. ...read more.


Overall, looking at Parkers study it is possible to see that he was successful in the sense that observed in great detail the lives of boy's from a deviant sub-culture. The study looked at the lifestyle of the gang and the study was very influential as it focused on what led the boy's to turn to criminal activities and therefore helped the government to introduce new policies that helped juvenile delinquency and council housing. The study helped to look at the social benefits that could be achieved in areas such as the Roundhouse, and also changes were made to try and decrease crime by enforcing anti-social behaviour laws on areas. The criminal justice system looked at and understood the reasons that the boy's behaved the way that they did and tried to resolve these problems. Parker, although criticised for the study did manage to defend his position as a covert participant observer by fitting in with the gang that he would have not been able to do had he told them his real identity. The study helped to look at working class males in a new light as their actions and behaviours were explained by Parker. Additionally the study looked at participation observation and it was debatable whether it should have been used as it was against ethics. The study allowed a closer and more analytic look at the reasons for and against participation observation. However, as Parker argued, it would have been impossible to carry out the study in any other circumstance. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Social Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Social Psychology essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Preventing and Reducing Crime

    3 star(s)

    A technique, called 'power assertion' by Hoffman (1984) was linked most often to families of delinquents. 'Power assertion' involves physical punishment and criticism with little rewarding of praise. (Brewer, K.) Other strategies would include 'love withdrawal', which is withholding of affection as punishment, and induction, which tries to explain and reason with the child.

  2. Assess the usefulness of participant observation in sociological research

    The idea was to win over the group leader Tally, but to also find out the gangs reasons for this issue about 'reputation'. This was another covert participant observation and once more backs up the statement about the pro's and cons of studying a deviant group as it illustrates that

  1. Research Methodology - Quantitative and Qualitative methods.

    Specialist qualitative research interview) (r) Interviewing Skills * Face to face * People like to be cooperative and avoid conflict => an unconscious indication of agreement or disagreement with a respondent's answer can affect the things they later say * Interview 'rapport' * Sensitivity, ability to talk freely and openly

  2. Anti-Social Behaviour Orders have been promoted as 'mixing the best of the civil and ...

    the threat of a large fine or imprisonment or both as mentioned above. It is essentially a 'last chance' measure - a threat to the offender that if he or she does not stop the antisocial element(s) of their behaviour they will be liable to criminal prosecution.

  1. Focus Group Research gives the researcher access to tacit, uncodified and experiential knowledge in ...

    Yet, as I have demonstrated this is not always possible. One of the vital requirements for the interviewer (especially in feminist and minority research) is awareness of gender differences in communication and power relations between participants. Greenbaum (1998) notes that for the interviewer to be able to obtain any knowledge

  2. Persuasion Theory.

    Therefore, they have to be "inoculated". This is done through TV ads, but also through the introduction of literature and video in health classes. But because everyone is different, attitudes will vary. It would be impossible to predict how each individual will react to a certain piece of information, so researchers (mostly advertising-based)

  1. On-line and off-line personae in the virtual communities.

    Leung (Eds.), OZCHI'94. Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the Computer-Human Interface Special Interest Group of the Ergonomics Society of Australia (pp. 33-38). Downer: ACT, CHISIG-ESA. * Dubrovsky, V., Kiesler, S. & Sethna, B. (1991). The equalization phenomenon: Status effects in computer-mediated and face-to-face decision making groups.

  2. essay of participant observation

    lie unless they are trying to make themselves look social desirable to the 'new' member of the group or to other members. The main disadvantage of a participant observation is that it is not very reliable, meaning that there is no real proof on how the researcher obtained his results

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work