• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent had psychological research shown Eye Witness Testimony to be reliable and accurate?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent had psychological research shown Eye Witness Testimony to be reliable and accurate? There are many cases that both help and hinder the reliability and accuracy of EWT (Eye Witness Testimony). One experiment conducted by Loftus and Palmer showed strong results of unreliability and inaccuracy. They gathered a group of American students and showed them a video of a car accident. They then asked them several questions including "At what speed do you think the cars were going when they (hit/smashed/collided/bumped/contacted) each other?" Only one verb was used per participant. Loftus found that the estimated speed changed depending on the verb they used. The verb affected part of the participants' memory of the incident. This is strong evidence to show that EWT is highly unreliable as it can be affected by leading questions such as that of Loftus and Palmer's. But this theory can be criticised by the idea of demand characteristics. ...read more.

Middle

The same thing could apply to EWT. Eyewitnesses could change their account of a crime without even realising just because it makes it more familiar to their own existing schema, therefore making their testimony highly unreliable. This theory has highly ecological validity because schemas play a major role in everyday life. However, there is a study that suggests EWT might be highly reliable and accurate. Conway et al. conducted a study on Flashbulb memories. He believed that a significant event having distinctive meaning and emotional impact would be highly memorable, creating a flashbulb memory. He used Margaret Thatcher's resignation as an example and people's memory of the event were assessed. Conway found that 86% still had vivid, detailed memory of the event, thus creating a flashbulb memory. This shows that if the event is emotionally important enough, then EWT can be considered very reliable and accurate. It suggests that flashbulb memories are more enduring and so less subject to forgetting. ...read more.

Conclusion

This may include witnessing a crime. If a person was extremely traumatised by seeing a violent act, they may repress certain details, calling into question the accuracy and reliability of their testimony. However, this theory is hard to evaluate because they are extremely hard to retrieve and creating them in an experimental condition would be highly unethical. But there is one study by Williams that took this into consideration by taking existing cases and analysing the victims of violent crimes. He found that 38% had no conscious memory of the event at all. This supports the idea that repression may cause EWT to be unreliable and inaccurate. There are few studies to suggest that EWT can be found as accurate and reliable. The majority of research seems to suggest that they are in fact inaccurate and unreliable. This is due to things like repression, which causes memory loss due to traumatic incidents. It is also due to witnesses rationalizing the events that they see and making it more familiar to their own schema. Overall, EWT cannot be depended on as a reliable piece of evidence. Sarah Feehan ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology essays

  1. In this assignment the Author intends to discuss, evaluate and research the reliability and ...

    considerably greater research and has led to many institutions improving their philosophy of care. Rosenhal, like other anti-psychiatrists is arguing that mental illness is a social phenomenon and merely a consequence of labelling although those who suffer from severe mental illness might disagree.

  2. How Minority views afects Majority - Conformity

    Furthermore, cause and effect relationships can be identified as there is an IV and DV. The Independent variable is whether the minority participants are shown previous and majority estimations of sweets in a jar or not. The Dependant Variable is the change that occurs as a result of the independent variable.

  1. 'It is clear from psychological research into memory and eye-witness testimony that accounts of ...

    other' and in others 'hit' was changed to 'smashed into' when the verb 'hit' was used the average speed was considerably lower than when the words 'smashed into' were used. This supports the statement as if questions asked to the eyewitness where phrased in a different way it may distort there memory and change it completely.

  2. "Eyewitness testimony differs from many other aspects of memory in that accuracy is of ...

    This distracts attention from the appearance of the criminal. Some might also argue that the presence of a weapon increases stress and thereby causes still further reductions in accuracy. Regardless of what is made of these studies, it is clear that only a few studies have attempted to explore this

  1. Memory's Impact

    The table is a summary of both averages for the emotional and neutral words remembered by the participants in condition A and condition B. Average number of emotional words recalled. (condition A) Average number of neutral words recalled. (condition B)

  2. Report on Psychological Research into Eyewitness Testimony

    The witness usually understands the importance of accuracy in the information they are giving and is often reminded of this fact, yet real life cases and laboratory studies have shown that recall is still not entirely accurate. It has also been said that due to the nature of Bartlett's experiment the results may not be consistent.

  1. Outline and evaluate factors influencing eye witness testimony

    They were then asked specific questions, including the question ?About how fast were the cars going when they (hit/smashed/collided/ bumped/contacted) each other?? The estimated speed was affected by the verb used. The verb implied information about the speed, which affected the participants? memory of the accident.

  2. Describe and Evaluate Research by E.Loftus into Eye Witness Testimony, the implications of the ...

    For example in Loftus and Palmer's 2nd experiment, the participants first formed some memory of the film they had witnessed. The experimenter then, while asking, "About how fast were the cars going when they smashed into each other?" supplied a piece of external information, namely, that the cars did indeed smash into each other.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work