• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent has psychological research shown eyewitness testimony to be unreliable?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent has psychological research shown eyewitness testimony to be unreliable? Eyewitness testimony is the evidence that is provided by individuals whom have witnessed an event, crime or happening. EWT relies solely on recall from memory and normally includes accounts of events and descriptions of persons involved. Although EWT is used largely by the police on identifying suspects of a crime, giving great cause for concern over policing methods in our society. It has been proven by psychologists not to be entirely reliable. It has also been shown that it is not the witness themselves that are unreliable but more so the methods used by professionals to obtain testimonial statements. The main issue concerned with the unreliability of EWT lies in the effect of language. A school of thought is provoked by the studies of Elizabeth Loftus. She has carried out various experiments concerned with leading questions and language. ...read more.


Their study showed that eyewitness memory is very fragile and can easily be distorted by events that happen after the incident (post-event information), and the change of only one word in a question can have a huge effect on the participants memory. This has great implications for the questioning in police interviews as it can lead to confabulated evidence Although this study suggests that EWT is unreliable the criticisms it received do not necessarily suggest this. The fact that this was an artificial experiment in which a video was used suggests it is not as emotionally arousing as witnessing an event first hand. This potentially effects recall which is proven in later study by Yuille and Cutshall (1986) in which participants who thought they had witness a real robbery gave a more accurate description of the robbers. A further area to consider is the issue of reconstructive memory. ...read more.


Bartlett found that the recalled stories were far shorter than the original. In some parts the story had been changed to match that of the participant's cultural perspectives. The recalled versions eventually became fixed in the participant's minds. This study gives more evidence that EWT is unreliable as the essential meaning of a story/event is remembered, but any gaps are filled in with information to make the story easier to remember, the story is effectively skewed to fit the individual's schema. Although the results show that the story/event was remembered it also shows that small gaps were not remembered. It is these small gaps that could complete the jigsaw to a crime proving EWT is unreliable. It was argued that if participants were told from the start that they had to remember the story accurately from the beginning then total recall would occur, this was proved in a further study. However, in everyday situations we witness many events and we do not pay full attention therefore it is not a valid point to suggest this argument. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Cognitive Psychology essays

  1. Report on Psychological Research into Eyewitness Testimony

    The witness usually understands the importance of accuracy in the information they are giving and is often reminded of this fact, yet real life cases and laboratory studies have shown that recall is still not entirely accurate. It has also been said that due to the nature of Bartlett's experiment the results may not be consistent.

  2. The Effects of leading questions on Eyewitness Testimony

    The data was collected by a single female A level Psychology student researcher. Apparatus * Standardised Instructions (devised by researcher) See Appendix ii * Remote control * 20 Sheets of Paper * 20 Pens * 20 Chairs * A hat (or something else that can be used to draw the ballot)

  1. "Eyewitness testimony differs from many other aspects of memory in that accuracy is of ...

    if people read a story from a different culture, then it would contain words and concepts that were foreign. The readers's prior knowledge might then affect the way it was recalled e.g. making the text more acceptable from the viewpoint of their own culture.

  2. "Eyewitness testimony differs from many other aspects of memory in that accuracy is of ...

    Bartlett (1932) carried out research on reconstructive memory. He claimed that in order to make sense of an event we go through a process called " effort after meaning." Instead of storing an exact replica of the event, we combine it with elements of existing knowledge and experience to form a reconstructive memory.

  1. "It is clear that eyewitness testimony is entirely unreliable".To what extent does psychological research ...

    For example, the questions influenced the answers given by participants, demonstrating how recall can be biased by language or schema. The study also reveals how police questioning can really have a dramatic effect on how a witness remembers an event.

  2. How reliable is Eyewitness testimony

    Loftus and Palmer (1975) showed their participants a series of projector slides of a multiple car accident. The participants then answered specific questions. It was found out that the information implicit in the question affected memory, even though the questions apparently only differed slightly.

  1. To what extent had psychological research shown Eye Witness Testimony to be reliable and ...

    Another study that may help to support this idea is Bartlett's schema theory. Participants were told a story called "The War of the Ghosts" and were then asked to recall it after different intervals of time. Bartlett found that participants subconsciously changed the story to make it familiar to their

  2. Describe and Evaluate Research by E.Loftus into Eye Witness Testimony, the implications of the ...

    the ?shoe rapist? who kept shoes from his victims whom he raped. Effective profiles can help police with strategies with interviewing suspects, and in one case a man who needed control gave a confession after being led to believe he was ?helping? the investigation.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work