• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

1. A) Morality is derived from religion and its teachings

Extracts from this document...


1. A) Morality is derived from religion and its teachings B) Morality is independent of religion and its teachings Discuss these two claims (40 marks) Before exploring either of these two claims, it is important to primarily, identify what exactly 'morality' is. The dictionary definition is "conformity to the rules of right conduct; moral or virtuous conduct." Meaning that to possess morality a person must be in accord with standards of ethically good behaviour. However there is much question as to where exactly morality derives from. It has since been, an ongoing debate as to whether morality is derived from religious roots, or separate from religion altogether. Many believe that morality is derived purely from religion and its teachings; this term is known as Heteronomy. Consequently, a heteronomist would agree with statement A. Heteronomy trusts that morals are traced from religious authority, depending on the particular religion a believer is from. A Christian heteronomist would explain that their morals firstly come from the Bible, New Testament, 10 commandments and Holy Scriptures. And secondly from the voice of God - in the context of the Pope and their own conscience and reason. ...read more.


Key supporters of Theonomy include Hastings Rashdall and Iris Murdoch. Rashdall would argue statement A, by believing that without God our morals would have no value. He argues that morality must have firmer foundation than human thoughts and wishes! Rashdall would say that a life filled with belief in God is definitely more likely to be a happier and more fulfilled life complete with moral goodness. Correspondingly Iris Murdoch acknowledged that human inclination for morality exists, but that it is God-given. Murdoch argues that everyone has an awareness for right and wrong and that it comes from God. In great contrast to either heteronomy or theonomy, a great amount of people believe that morality is derived independently of religion and its teachings. This term is known as Autonomy, and is in accordance with statement B. An autonomist would instead believe that our morals are derived from secular authority; such as law and governments and initially the influences of school and parents (upbringings). In his 'Euthyphro Dilemma', Plato sustains this argument of autonomy. Plato presents the dilemma of morality and God through his characters Euthyphro and Socrates. The characters debate the on-going issue of "Are things good because God commands them? ...read more.


Taking into consideration each of the claims respectively, I have decided that autonomy provides the strongest claim to morality, for me alone. I feel that theonomy is the weakest claim to the source of morality, as it depends solely on a "God" or supernatural being; which for me poses many problems. I believe that theonomy can be taken very seriously as a good claim to morality, as the links between religion and early morality are undeniable. For example moral language is derived from religion evidently pointing to religion for ethical authority . However I feel autonomy is the strongest claim as secular authority plays two key roles in our rapidly varying society. Secular authority holds great influence on us through media, advertising and technological advances. For example the large majority of teenagers, today, will have very differing morals to that of their grandparents due to television and other such publicity; which has shaped their morals (for the worst?) Also secular authority is present in the upkeep of our country; through laws being enforced and the increase of government control, proving a source of morality- that cannot and must not be ignored. ?? ?? ?? ?? Paris Fisher-Aziz ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Anaylse of the critiques of Religion and Morality.

    his daughter greets him, she fully accepts the obligation and Jephthah in the end defeats the Ammonites?

  2. religion linked to morality

    of what the consequences may be is selfish, and takes away freedom. An additional argument that supports that religion should not be linked to morality is the evil and despicable actions of so called religious leaders that justify them on account of their religion, for example Osama Bin Laden, the twin towers and his Islam religion.

  1. Religion and Morality

    The second half of Plato's Euthyphro Dilemma suggests that goodness is separate from God. This would mean for a Christian that they would have to look to a different source to find their moral values, basically eliminating the need for God and Christianity.

  2. The arguments for and against the view that morality is dependant on religion, and ...

    to leading to a greater means, yet a person who follows natural moral law cannot produce this sperm via masturbation. In cultures where there is seen to be no God, or no God which promotes moral goodness there is still moral goodness, look at indigenous tribes.

  1. `Always tell the truth and Always keep your promises' Kant's Categorical Imperative.

    without considering that as rational beings they ought always to be esteemed also as ends, that is, as beings who must be capable of containing in themselves the end of the very same action.' (pp. 47-8) We can clearly see the connection between the second formulation of the categorical imperative and the second discussion of the promise-keeping maxim.

  2. Discuss critically the belief that conscience is the voice of God.

    Yet to make conscience into God is a highly dangerous thing to do. Firstly, conscience is by no means an infallible guide and secondly, it is unlikely that we shall be moved to worship, love and serve a nagging inner voice that at worst spoils our pleasure and at best keeps us rather negatively on the path of virtue.

  1. The Ethical Debate Concerning Cloning.

    To say so, however, is to use the word religion in Tillich's sense of one's "ultimate concern." Religion is what we hold to be our first-order value or highest good, the "imperative" that pushes us on to do what we do.

  2. (a) Examine the reasons why some argue that morality is linked ...

    - suggests that the essence of Godly and Godlike living lies in morally good behaviour. Profound ethical teachings can also be found in the Books of Proverbs, Job, Ecclesiastes and the Song of Solomon (known as Wisdom literature); and in the utterings of the Prophets (Hosea, Micah, Amos, Isaiah, Jeremiah)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work