• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A comparison of two accounts of life after death and an evaluation of the strongest.

Extracts from this document...


A comparison of two accounts of life after death and an evaluation of the strongest. Materialism is the view that the body and mind are inseparable, and for there to be life after death then the body must be resurrected, this is much like the Christian view of life after death. John Hick was a materialist and he argued that, in certain circumstances, it would be possible that the dead could exist as themselves after death, if an exact replica were to appear. Hick uses thought experiments to show the person who dies in this World is the same person who is resurrected in the next. He uses examples of using a character called John Smith. If John smith were to disappear from his home in the USA and then suddenly appear in India with exactly the same characteristics, there would be no doubt that this is the same John Smith. ...read more.


It is also believed that the soul is associated with higher realities such as truth, goodness, justice and contemplation, and if a man spends his life contemplating these realities then the soul can enter eternity after death. This view is supported by Aquinas. According to Aquinas the soul operates independently of the body, and only things that are divisible are open to decay. The Soul is not divisible, unlike the body and will therefore decay and die whilst the soul lives on. This view of the Soul been separate to the body was accepted by Descartes too. Descartes said that it was conceivable for us to survive without our bodies because our identity comes from our soul and it's ability to think and reason. He rejected the idea that we need our bodies to live an intellectually aware and active life. ...read more.


There is also a slight problem with how people will appear when they have been recreated in Hick's theory. If they have died in an accident will they bear the wounds of that accident when they have been re-created, like Jesus still had the holes in his hands. This is not made clear in his theory. The strengths of Hick's theory are that it is supported by the Christian belief that the body and the soul can be resurrected, although Christians usually think of the soul rising to Heaven not the whole physical body. St Paul wrote, 'There are heavenly bodies and Earthly Bodies,' This gives more substance to Hicks belief that there is some kind of body present, not just the soul in the life after death. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christianity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christianity essays

  1. Life after death and problem of evil

    Monism is an example of such a belief. It is the idea that evil is an illusion. What we experience as being evil is just an illusion. However, why should we have to experience evil, even if it is just an illusion? The evil may not exist, or it can be discounted as beneficial, but the suffering associated

  2. RS Dualism Essay

    The classic presentation of dualism is by Descartes. He argued that the body is spatial and in no sense conscious, whilst the mind is non-spatial and is conscious, having thoughts, feelings and desires for example, a regards the interrelationship of the body and the mind, Descartes favoured interactionism.

  1. Cyrano de Bergerac Act V Character List.

    Cyrano says his Gazette is not finished and adds, "Saturday, twenty-sixth: An hour or so before dinner, Monsieur de Bergerac died, foully murdered." He uncovers his head, and shows it swathed in bandages. When Roxane asks what they have done to him, he says "Struck down by the sword of

  2. Christian Philosophy on Death

    or "Please just let me live to see..." "The bargaining can be directed toward God which if the bargain is perceived as accepted can lead to a sense of hope or resignation, or anger, guilt, or fear if the bargain is perceived as denied".

  1. Death and What Next?

    through Jesus Christ our Lord. I also don't believe that God would ever refuse an honest, hard-working person into heaven based on the fact that they did not believe in him during their life on Earth. After all, they will be proved wrong when they enter heaven anyway.

  2. Examine the main differences between Matthews and Lukes accounts of Jesus trial, crucifixion and ...

    His statement is now a reaction to the effects of the death of Jesus, rather than to the death of Jesus itself, as in Mark. 7. Matthew 27: 62-66, The story of the setting of the guard. The sequel is in Matthew 28:11-15.

  1. Outline theories on the immortality of the soul and ressurection of the body

    Biologist Dawkins ask where this soul is, it cannot be found in the body and therefore we have no proof for its existence, and if it does not exist then it cannot be immortal implying that there is no life after death.

  2. Mind and body- Dualism, a Christian view.

    returns to God and enters Heavenly rest. This is what Christians profess in the Apostle?s as well as the Nicene Creeds, when they say, ?We believe in the resurrection of the body and life everlasting.? Let us return to

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work