• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the view that what makes an action moral is that it is motivated by a sense of duty.

Extracts from this document...


Assess the view that what makes an action moral is that it is motivated by a sense of duty. Some philosophers have taken to the view that a truly moral action can be defined by being motivated by a sense of duty. These particular philosophers are mostly found within the category of 'Cognitivists', a group of philosophers that believe there are moral values by which we should abide, that are absolute and objective. This opposes 'Non-Cognitivists', who believe that although there may be moral values, these moral values are subjective and not part of the real world; there is no realm of transcendent/natural facts. These particular philosophers are seemingly the most opposed to the view that a truly moral action is that which is motivated by duty, but instead take emotivist or prescriptivist views and claim that morality is merely something to express our emotional attitudes, thus implying that a truly moral action is not one motivated by a sense of duty. The key advocate of the theory that a truly moral action is motivated by a sense of duty is Immanuel Kant, who proposed a deontological theory of ethics. ...read more.


However, the neighbour returns the next day, clearly angry and with a murderous attitude asking for the axe back. The man who borrowed it now has to choose between his duty to return the axe, and his duty to prevent the harm of others. W.D Ross corrected this issue with the introduction of Prima Facie duties, or 'first' duties. These are concrete duties which we can use to determine exactly what we should do; a prima facie duty is one which we must unfailingly abide by, unless it is overridden by another duty. A prima facie duty is used to decide what our actual duty is. Using the example of the Soldier who has to choose between staying and caring for his mother, or fighting for his country, would choose to abide by the Prima Facie duties of both non-injury (the duty not to harm others physically or psychologically: to avoid harming their health, security, intelligence, character, or happiness) and beneficence, (the duty to do good to others: to foster their health, security, wisdom, moral goodness, or happiness) ...read more.


This is backed up/followed by emotivism, which also states that our moral beliefs are purely our emotional takes on things which have happened. This view was mainly taken by AJ Ayer, who came up with the "boo-hurrah" theory, which was that there could be an action, such as abortion, and one person could say "boo, abortion" whilst the other could say "hurrah, abortion", which are their separate ideas on whether it is moral or not, but the the only fact that really appears is that there was an abortion. The view that what makes an action moral is that it is motivated by a sense of duty appears flawed. The fact that duties can be conflicted, and in certain cases can lead us to wrong actions (such as presented in the mad axe man example) makes it seem as though it cannot fully account for morality. It seems more like the views of Hume and Ayer that morality is in fact just an emotional reaction to an event seems more realistic and can account for a lot more. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Explain The Difference Between Hypothetical And Categorical Imperatives

    humanity, whether in your own person of in that of any other, never solely as a mean but always as an end, and act as if a legislating member in the universal Kingdom of Ends. The first of the formulations was also named by Kant as the Formulation of the

  2. Synoptic Study, Satre, Engels and Marx

    Sartre has now managed to turn a depressing theory in to a very optimistic one. As, in his own words, "a coward is not a coward because of a cowardly heart or set of lungs" meaning that one chooses to become a coward and, according to existentialism, choose not to be one.

  1. Explain and assess the view that morality is based on self-interest

    A good pen is one that allows me to write on paper, for instance. The last fundamental concept is 'arete' which means 'virtue' however it refers to excelling in particular area of life. It's very much like a habit or a quality.

  2. Nietzsche and Mill on Conventional Morality

    Mill gets round this with the introduction of the harm principle - "one may offend, but never harm". Mill's harm principle comes about from his utilitarian ideal for increasing aggregate happiness. The implications of his method of judging the action and the actor as distinct from one another could be logically manipulated to permit any action.

  1. Examine and comment on a philosophical approach to the moral and religious issues raised ...

    Other philosophers, like Ann Davies, apply similar criteria, concluding that a foetus lacks a right to life because it lacks self-consciousness, rationality, and autonomy. These lists disagree over precisely which features confer a right to life, but tend to propose the necessities of various developed psychological features not found in foetuses.

  2. Happiness or Duty: Aristotle and Kants Approach on Moral Reason

    Ultimately, the individual should show their distress and anger but in a civilized manner; letting the friend know about the wrong doing and the implications of his or her actions. Acting in such a way is morally correct and, in theory, will allow both people to achieve happiness.

  1. Critically Assess the View that, Without a Predetermined Conceptual Scheme, Our Sense Experience Would ...

    This technique works because the computer is unable to perceive the picture, which has a few distinct letters in front of a background of scratches.

  2. What makes a person valuable?

    That?s what makes someone a person or more of a person than others. For example, a murderer who has little consciousness at all in his mind, can?t be deemed as a ?person? since they didn?t rationally look at their action and that is why they took another person?s life away,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work