• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the application of two ethical theories to a moral dilemma. Discuss the reasons for arguing that one of these theories is more effective than the other.

Extracts from this document...


* Compare and contrast the application of two ethical theories to a moral dilemma. Discuss the reasons for arguing that one of these theories is more effective than the other. (50 Marks) In philosophy there are a wide range of different ethical positions. Many of these might influence what someone believes about a moral issue. One moral issue is euthanasia; it has been labelled a moral issue as it is concerned with what we ought to do i.e. right and wrong concepts that form the basis of ethics. Euthanasia is also a controversial issue as it is a matter of life and death. Death is one of the primary concerns of most individuals and cultures and therefore anything that brings about death will always be contentious. The first question that arises is what is a good moral choice? How can we determine what good is when there are many differing opinions? Is an action good if the nature or intentions of the action are considered good? Or is it the consequences of the action that determine the goodness of the action? ...read more.


Euthanasia is one such dilemma. Supporters of euthanasia believe that a dying patient has the right to end their suffering and leave the world in a dignified manner. Those who oppose euthanasia, on the other hand, believe that no one has the right to end the life of another person no matter what pain they may endure. The word euthanasia originates from the Greek word 'euthantos' meaning a good death and referred to intentional mercy killings. In society today euthanasia has acquired a more complex meaning. There are various types of euthanasia; usually it is when one person does something that directly ends the life of another for example giving a lethal injection. In assisted suicide the provisions of means and the opportunity whereby a patient may terminate their own life. Passive euthanasia is the termination of treatment which is prolonging the patient's life for example stopping a life support machine. Passive euthanasia is usually carried out on people in a persistent vegetative state and those who are terminally ill, to allow a natural death to occur earlier. Therefore pain becomes a factor that can influence someone's decision. ...read more.


After being taken to hospital she was described as being in a chronic persistent vegetative state and it was later revealed that no treatment could restore her to cognitive life. The only thing that was keeping her alive was a respirator. The Supreme Court in New Jersey appointed her father her legal guardian and requested the respirator be turned off. Karen Ann Quinlan remained in a coma for a further ten years until she died naturally. The final case study is that of Tracy Latimer. Tracy Latimer was clearly someone else to her father. Her father decided to end the life of his daughter as Tracy was clearly in no state to make a decision. Would Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics agree with the actions that were taken in each of the case studies? In regard to Euthanasia, a Utilitarian would ask whether the action produce the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Jeremy Bentham was convinced that pain and suffering was an essential factor for a moral universe. Bentham believed that it was pain and suffering that gave you moral rights. Mill however chose to respond to the problem of how we are supposed to make moral decisions. Mill believed that rules could be developed from the Principle of Utility Rachel Seager Synoptic Work ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Utilitarianism VS Kantian Deontological Ethics

    For instance the maxim behind taking your rubbish out each week is to live healthily, because not taking your rubbish out would result in multiplying bacteria and possible spread of disease. Another example, the moral proposition "One should never lend aid to another person unless there is something in it

  2. Compare and contrast the ethical theories of natural law and situation ethics.

    The notion of basing actions on consequentiality is not always helpful because it can be difficult to determine the outcomes of certain situations, especially in the long-term. Humans also tend to look at situations subjectively so it becomes easy for selfishness to taint love.

  1. Examine how Benthams utilitarianism may be applied to one ethical issue of your choice. ...

    If the transplantation is motivated by economic reasons, Bentham would still say that it is morally right, as both sides have decided the transaction is for their benefits, therefore creating greatest good for greatest number. If the transplantation is non-voluntary or involuntary, Bentham would still be for this, as his

  2. RE euthanasia for and against

    In Samuel 1:8-10, an Amalekite tries to tell King David that he had helped kill Saul because Saul had asked him to. This is an example of euthanasia however King David has the soldier executed. More recently, a rabbi on a website (who remained anonymous)

  1. (a) Examine the reasons why some argue that morality is linked ...

    The lawgiver is, of course, God; the guilt and fear that we feel when our consciences prick us is the voice of God.

  2. “Without real freedom there would be no ethical decisions to make,” Discuss.

    receive no praise for correctness in taking the action, as what they have done was done not out of free will, but because they were programmed, or trained to do so. The action says nothing about the moral worth of the agent as it had an external cause, and was not done through free will and intention.

  1. Utilitarianism.After Bentham had established that pleasure and pain were the important factors in determining ...

    did not approve because he believed that it was not "useful" enough. After Mill had recovered he devoted his life to doing good and developing Bentham's utilitarianism, he went on to many great things he became a politician for 3 years, in those three years he became one of the

  2. I will be discussing John Stewart Mill theory on utilitarianism. Then I will point ...

    Another point the utilitarianism view suggests is that humans should maximize their overall happiness. But this would result in the ridiculous conclusion that we should always be doing everything possible to maximize happiness.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work