Compare and contrast the key features of Natural Moral Law & Virtue Ethics

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Compare and contrast the key features of Natural Moral Law and Virtue Ethics Virtue Ethics is a character based ethical theory. This means that it looks at the virtue or moral character of the individual carrying out an action, rather than at ethical laws, or the consequences of particular actions. Rather than attempting to reason what should be considered 'good' or 'bad', virtue ethics focuses on how adopting certain attitudes may lead to certain fulfilments. Virtue ethics is principally concerned with the idea of the human character and asks how you can be a better person. In this way it is different to many other ethical theories as it puts right character before right behaviour. It argues we should be less concerned with actions and consequences, and much more with the character of the moral agent. The question 'what is it right or obligatory to do?' is nowhere near as important in virtue ethics as the question, 'how should we be?' The principles of virtue ethics are that 1. An action is only right if it is an action that a virtuous person would carry out in the same circumstances. 2. A virtuous person is a person who acts virtuously.

Middle

The Aristotelian 'Theory of Causes' is important to understand here because this states that everything has a final cause or purpose. In relation to natural law, this means that anything that interferes with that purpose is to be considered 'wrong'. Thomas Aquinas applied Aristotle's theories to Christianity. He posited that natural ethics was not only learned from observation of the natural because it seemed that the cravings of the body, which were by all means natural, were not all moral. As such he thought that in order to discover what is good we must use observation in combination with excellent reason. He believed that reason could be corrupted by the trials of human existence. With his reason he induced that the moral laws could be broken down into four precepts (in order of precedence); 1. Eternal law - The mind of God 2. Divine law - Our perception of the mind of God (the bible) 3. Natural law - Derived from observation of the way things "should" be and reason. 4. Human law - The laws created by the current earthly authority. An important aspect of natural law is that of exterior and interior motive. This means that an action must only be in itself moral (E.G.

Conclusion

For example, if reproduction is one of the final causes, how can we explain those who are homosexual or infertile? Furthermore, if one considers the possibility that homosexuality may derive from genetic traits, and therefore be a part of someone's nature, the final cause of reproduction has no basis. If this were the case, it could be said that sexual intercourse has as its purpose recreation and not reproduction. Vardy and Grosch have also challenged Aquinas' final cause of reproduction in 'The Puzzle of Ethics' with this argument, stating the possibility that the function of genitalia is pleasure and not reproduction. Whilst Natural Law upholds the idea that some things, such as the preservation of human life, have intrinsic value, one could also observe that Aquinas' thinking is typical of its time. His belief that every individual has a purpose and function that is God-given and unchangeable could be considered outdated. Alongside this argument, although Natural Law is supposedly a Christian ethic, Jesus opposed the legalistic morality of his time, the Pharisees. Although the weaknesses of Natural Moral Law outweigh the strengths, given the above criticisms, it is worth noting that natural law may not be as rigid as it first appears. Aquinas accepted that while the primary precepts were unalterable, the secondary precepts were subject to change owing to particular circumstances

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related AS and A Level Christianity

  1. What are the advantages of utilitarianism? Identify the main problems of utilitarianism

    Consequently, the emphasis in utilitarianism is on consequences, not intentions. We often speak of "utilitarian" solutions in a disparaging tone, but in fact utilitarianism is a demanding moral position that often asks us to put aside self-interest for the sake of the whole.

  2. Situation ethics. Joseph Fletcher developed the idea of making a moral decision for a ...

    An example of this is that people can say they have nothing against Black people but they can deny them simple justice but then that would not be following the guideline of 'love thy neighbor.' Overall, Fletcher feels that the best moral decision is made when love, not law is applied to a situation.

  1. Examine the main ideas and strengths of the design argument for the existence of ...

    Also, this proof is built upon an analogy. If we find things in the universe that are troublesome, then by analogy, that would imply there is no designer. Another weakness of some arguments, for example Payley's or Swinburne's, is that scientific data can support the opposing argument. However this offers more acceptance and sustainability to the other opposing

  2. Explain Aristotles Virtue Ethics and how this has been developed by later thinkers

    Aristotle illustrates that once the virtuous means have been found it is also important to be able to control one's emotions and behaviour towards other persons in different situations to fully cultivate them. Basically, if persons are to be virtuous rather than simply emotive towards other persons self-control is also essential.

  1. Assess whether the problem of moral evil casts doubt on the existence of God

    God did not create this world (P1). C. Therefore either God is not omnipotent, or He is not omnibenevolent. But perhaps Mackie is missing the central point of the free will defence. God can give freedom, but He cannot control the free - that would be a logical contradiction.

  2. What are the moral and religious differences, if any, between euthanasia and suicide? Why ...

    There are also family members to consider who may be left quite hurt and bewildered by shock of a sudden suicide. It is likely that a suicide person may gain more sympathy if they take their life quietly without seeking attention as in the case of Dr David Kelly6.

  1. Compare and contrast the marriage ceremonies of Christianity and Islam. For both, explain ...

    and give presents to the new husband and wife in both religions. It is a custom for a Christian bride to wear a white or cream wedding dress as white is a symbol of purity. The bride also gets married in a veil which covers the face and the bridegroom lifts up at the beginning of the ceremony.

  2. Critically assess the view that the two Patrick theory solves the puzzle of Patrick

    This draws O'Rahilly to the assumption that Palladius' full name was Patricius Palladius, as Patricius was a common name at this time. He concludes that in Ireland he was referred to as Patricius, where as in the Chronicles of Prosper, they used his surname.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.