• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Consider the application of situation ethics on a moral dilemma relating to sexual ethics

Extracts from this document...


Consider the application of situation ethics on a moral dilemma relating to sexual ethics. The moral dilemma I am describing is based upon sacrificial adultery taken from William Bailay. During the war lots of Jewish families were taken away from their homes and separated. One family the 'Belmont's' were taken away by the German troops. The two children were left abandoned by the troops in the mountains, while Mrs Belmont was taken to a concentration camp in Berlin. Mr Belmont somehow managed to escape from the German army and fled back to their hometown in Hamburg where he was reunited with his two children. Mrs Belmont however was stuck in the Berlin concentration camp; a kindly officer somehow informed her that her family were reunited and searching for her. However he could not release her, as there were only two conditions that would allow someone to be released. 1- if someone carried a disease that the camp could not cope with or 2- if a woman was pregnant as she would then be a liability and no use to the camp. ...read more.


Love can justify anything in situation ethics as long as the end result satisfies love.' In this situation the woman seeks to find the best possible outcome. She does not wish to commit adultery but does so in order for her to be returned to her family. So In this circumstance love is the end that is sought and so it satisfies this working principle. An advantage to applying situation ethics to any circumstance is that you can go against laws this again was established earlier. In this case Mrs Belmont was able to go against the law of adultery because in doing so she was providing the most loving outcome possible. In situation ethics you are able to go against certain boundaries as long as the end justifies the means, as love is the end the action has to provide love to be right. However we do also have to look at the disadvantages for applying situation ethics to this dilemma. ...read more.


Her family were obviously desperate to find her and for them all to be reunited, and if this was the case the husband and family should support her decision. If she knew and loved them then she would base her decision on the understanding that they would approve. I am not denying that committing adultery was wrong but in the context of the situation I find no fault in what she did. I am a supporter for situation ethics to some extent but I do acknowledge that it has many disadvantages as well. I support the ethic 'to do whatever is the most loving thing.' As Vardy mentions at the beginning of 'The puzzle of ethics') There are two main quotations that sum up situation ethics, one outlined in the 4th of the 6 working principles and the second quoted by Paul Tillich: 'The law of love is the ultimate law because it is the negotiation of law; it is absolute because it concerns everything concrete.... The absolutism of love is its power to go into concrete situations' I feel that this quote sums up the main point that situation ethics attempts to put across- the principle of love. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Discuss the Relationship between law and morals. Consider how far the law seeks to ...

    The laws on prostitution are still very restrictive and often heavily penalise the prostitute and are light on the client. In terms of homosexual rights, it is only in the past few years that the law began to reflect equality between homosexual and heterosexual citizens.

  2. Consider the application of Situation Ethics to a moral dilemma related to sexual ethics

    However, it could be argued that if Situation Ethics were applied to this dilemma, then Christian homosexuals who followed the teaching of the church that sex before marriage was wrong would be able to take part in sexual intercourse because it would be the most loving course of action.

  1. What is Christian ethics?

    Prayer worship and the teaching of the Church also assist the conscience, which Aquinas described as reason-making moral decisions. Very liberal Protestants may have a situationist approach to Christian ethics. Situation ethics presumes it is not necessary to abandon moral autonomy, nor is it necessary to act in an antinomianistic or legalistic way.

  2. Compare and contrast the application of two ethical theories to a moral dilemma. Discuss ...

    This is where the moral dilemma is created. Such judgements are not medical ones. To conclude that another person's life is not worth living requires that the medical practitioner becomes more than a medical expert. The role of a doctor is traditionally seen as the healer and advocate in the life of the patient.

  1. Sexual Ethics

    The parable of the Good Samaritan if applied to the matter of Homosexuals would provide a good topic for debate. Would those involved with 'Ihatefags.com' stop to help a gay man if he was injured on the street? If not, surely they are not adhering to the teachings of the bible themselves.

  2. "Virtue ethics is of little use when dealing with sexual ethics". Discuss - 35 ...

    However, in some ways this might be too restrictive and it can be difficult for people to balance these things whilst having a good quality of life. Therefore, utilitarianism might be better. In an ideal world utilitarianism wants the greatest number of people to be happy which in itself would promote the idea of justice in a relationship.

  1. Medical Ethics And Organ Transplants

    implemented for ?doctors cannot be trusted? with a body which is so sacred to protect it and put organs of God into good use. It would also bring into the question of those organs which reject the body and what happens to them.

  2. Identify the distinctive characteristics of situation ethics. ii.) Consider the view that situation ...

    Positivism means you have to start with a positive choice and voluntarily want to do good and personalism means to put people first, people are therefore more important than rules. For example, Jesus healed on the Sabbath day, putting people over rules.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work