• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Considering the claims of both absolutism and relativism, discuss the importance of situation ethics as a moral theory.

Extracts from this document...


Considering the claims of both absolutism and relativism, discuss the importance of situation ethics as a moral theory. Situation ethics is a predominantly relativistic approach to morality as the fundamental principle of situation ethics is, "Love and do what you will..." (St. Augustine). It basically suggests that a person can do as one wishes as long as their actions involve love. A relativistic approach is a flexible ethical system which can accommodate the wide-diversity of lifestyles found in the word today. It believes that people don't always agree on what's right and wrong, and that different cultures express different moral codes of conduct. Their morals are subjective to situation, culture, religion, time and place and they believe that in reality, there is no fixed objective, prohibiting the dominance of a single culture. Although this may allow more freedom for different beliefs and provide less conflict, as we would all accept each others opinions, this unfortunately is not always the case. ...read more.


Fletcher states that there are essentially three different ways of making moral decisions, Legalistic ethics, Antinomian ethics and Situation ethics. He rejects both Legalistic ethics and Antinomian ethics but later goes on to discuss situation ethics and why it is the best approach to life. He divides his principles into four working principles and six fundamental principles. His four working principles are Pragmatism, which is a proposed course of action which must work towards the most loving end. Relativism, which as explained before, has no fixed rules, however it does contain one, which is to include love in all decisions. Positivism, which is an article of faith that love is the greatest good. The last is Personalism, which states that people come first and morality must be centred around people. With these presuppositions acknowledged, Fletcher then goes on today out the main theory, the six fundamentals, actions aren't intrinsically good or evil, they are good or evil depending on whether they promote the most loving thing. ...read more.


Situation ethics is flexible and can accommodate even Christian believers, as well as enabling people to be true to their emotional and rational feelings, without being subjected to absolutist codes. Not only is it individual to every person but it is a straightforward formulation, anyone can understand and act upon it. Selflessness and love are the important features of most moral codes, therefore the end results should benefit others. Even though it can relate to Christianity, many Christians today reject the theory stating that knowing what the right thing to do in every situation is impossible. Pope Pius XII said, "An individualistic and subjective appeal to concrete circumstances of actions to justify actions in opposition to the Natural Law or God's revealed will..." The idea is said to be too vague and although it means well, does it really work? In the world today people are too focussed on self benefit to follow such a theory. So although if practised world wide situation ethics could be a significant moral theory, unfortunately today the idea is idealistic and the chances of people practicing it faithfully are low. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Can moral absolutism be justified?

    In this case absolutism makes the judgment easier and does not allow for any individual to try and justify the act. It could therefore be suggested that it is in our innate knowledge that rape is wrong, so by using our inherent knowledge and reasoning it is possible to decide whether all actions are right or wrong.

  2. A) Clarify the key features of a deontological theory of ethics

    As such, duties are not conditional but can always be overridden by a more compelling duty, for example a firework hits a girl and her clothes catch fire. She would be seriously burned if you don't put them out but the only liquid around is the milk on the doorstep of a house.

  1. Religious Studies - Ethics: Natural Moral Law

    However, although Natural Law can exist without religion and secular thinkers can relate to Natural Law in a somewhat limited sense, it is so closely aligned to religion that the theory makes little sense without belief in God. The theory also relies on the belief that God created the universe and the moral law within nature.

  2. Examine the distinguishing features of a deontological ethical theory.

    Irrespective of the circumstance and consequences? Although many people would agree that the idea of absolute rules is good, many people have problems with it and say that there are times when making exceptions is morally permissible. The situation of our duties conflicting is again another damaging criticism to Kant's theory.

  1. Describe the main features of Joseph Fletchers theory of Situation ethics.

    Many people agree and disagree with situation ethics and some people even have differing approaches to the theory. Bernard Hoose created a different twist upon situation ethics; proportionalism, which suggests that although Fletcher has some good ideas but the natural moral law is not just a list of absolutes but

  2. Situation Ethics and Moral Decision Making.

    is an ethical theory which maintains that something is moral if I follows the most loving course of action. This theory was developed by Joseph Fletcher who was an Anglican theologian. Fletcher?s theory was heavily influenced by New Testament teaching and is therefore a religious theory.

  1. Outline the Six Fundamental Principles of Joseph Fletchers Situation Ethics

    The sixth and final proposition is ?Loves decisions are made situationally, not prospectively.? This again has been derived by a teaching written in the New Testament that Jesus gave. The bible has always stated that adultery is wrong as outlined in the Ten Commandments.

  2. Utilitarianism ethics is the not the best approach to environmental ethics discuss

    focus should be on whether the actions bring the greatest quality of happiness. Whilst as Bentham composed a mathematical calculation in order to weigh up the amount of pain and pleasure, Mill stated that humans have higher and lower pleasures, higher being for example reading literature or appreciating fine art and lower being physical attributes such as sexual pleasure.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work