• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically assess the claim that the conscience is the voice of reason (35)

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐JAN 2011 Critically assess the claim that conscience is the voice of reason. [35] The origin of the conscience is much debated by both secular and religious beliefs. One may insist that the conscience is the voice of reason and this can be supported by Aquinas? belief in the recta ratio. One may however discuss that the conscience is the voice of God, supported b y the Butler and Newman, or is influenced mainly by society, parents or authority figures, usually supported by secular views. This essay will critically asses these claims. Aquinas believed that the conscience is the right reason (recta ration) and this reason is central to moral life to aid the conscience in choosing right from wrong. If man can use reason correctly, in line with the conscience, then it can help us to understand what it is God sees as good. We must use reason to what is good as some may perform bad actions due to faulty reasoning and thus commit sins; for example this is seen in the event of the man who slept with another man?s wife believing that is was his own wife and thus did not believe he was committing a sin. ...read more.


As the ultimate authority in moral judgements, one may argue that it must be given that it must be given by the ultimate authority in the universe: God. It is ?our natural guide, the guide assigned to us by the author of our nature? that author is God and his voice will guide man to make the right decisions. For instance as man is motivated by both self-love and benevolence, as a benevolent God He will guide man away from selfish love and towards a benevolent society that will ultimately focus on happiness. As God?s purpose for man is to reach eudemonia it is understandable why Butler and Newman may believe that it is God?s voice that guides us towards this through the conscience. A secular approach may deny Aquinas? belief that the conscience is the voice of reason (given by God) and Newman/Butler?s belief that it is the voice of God. For thinkers like Fromm, Freud and Piaget the conscience is instilled by society, authority figures and parents. ...read more.


cannot be implemented universally as this is proven to be insufficient. Though all of mankind possess reason it is the influences of outside agencies that allows man to use the ?conscience? in line with what they have been taught as right and wrong; therefore it cannot be the voice of reason. By discussing Aquinas? support for claiming that the conscience is the voice of reason and analysing it with the concept of the conscience being the voice of God, viewed by Newman and Butler, and the concept that it is instilled by society, viewed mainly by those of secular beliefs. From this one may finally come to the conclusion that the conscience is not the voice of reason. Although it is still much debated, it is clear through history that society and authority figures play a major role in deciding what is morally right or wrong. In addition to Fromm?s authoritarian conscience there is the negative authoritarian conscience that misleads groups of people into doing sinful things; for example the Rwanda genocide in 1994. If all mankind posses reason how can one truly believe that the killing of innocents is the best thing for society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Assess the view that conscience is given to us by God.

    Aquinas states that it is our duty to keep our conscience well informed by going to church and reading the bible as this will avoid us from making the wrong decisions. Even though we cannot knowingly do wrong it may be wrong of us to allow ourselves to have an uninformed conscience.

  2. Conscience is the voice of God - discuss

    First, the idea of moral relativism becomes more convincing as historical and social enquiry lends us more information about other cultures, and although it does not deny Aristotle's universal reason, it does deny a universal understanding of right and wrong.

  1. Assess the view that conscience is not the voice of God, but is learned?

    For Aquinas then, the conscience is having the ability to choose between wrong and right, when faced with difficult moral situations; it is an innate ability to do so based on our principles and our God given ability to decide to do good.

  2. Plato and Nietzsche on Authority

    through the morals in religious scripture - this needn't be a discussion of religious philosophy) about what may be the better decision. Obviously, if we take the Forms to be incorrect (as most people do), then God would be the ultimate good, which means that those that 'understand God' would have to hold the power, rather than philosophers.

  1. Discuss critically the differing notions of power and freedom explored in the 'Gorgias'.

    as a question by Socrates, intuitively and for Callicles this would appear to be false. To avoid being wronged and hence to have real freedom you need power to protect yourself be it political or otherwise. Since doing wrong is involuntary, a consequence of error, you especially need power to protect yourself from this seemingly inevitable occurance.

  2. Was J.S.Mill Right to Claim that Suppressing an Opinion is 'Robbing Mankind'

    One problem with this view is that whilst it does appear to be fairly comprehensive at first it paints a rather idealistic view of truth. Mill's argument assumes that there is an absolute external truth and that this is the ultimate aim of all opinion.

  1. Writing to argue.

    "Let me tell you about a friend of mine. He... ". * Use "rhetorical devices" such as rhetorical questions, "list of three", repetition, etc. to increase the persuasive power of your argument. The most successful arguments are... INTERESTING, ORIGINAL AND APPEALING ORGANISED, PROGRESSIVE AND CONVINCING EASY TO FOLLOW THOUGHTFUL AND CONSIDERATE SUBTLE and SOPHISTICATED IN MORE DETAIL...

  2. Explain and evaluate the role of conscience in moral decision-making

    A smaller space is taken up at the top by the ?super-ego? which is the set of moral controls that are given to us by outside influences. Freud explains that the super ego is often in conflict with the Id therefore our conscience, which is a construct of the mind, is shaped and influenced by our experiences.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work