• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically assess the traditional Christian Concept of God being eternal.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

´╗┐Critically assess the traditional Christian Concept of God being eternal. (35) The traditional Christian concept of God?s eternity has been highly influenced by the early philosophy of Plato and his concept of the unchanging reality of the world of the Forms, and more modern philosophy of Boethius. It is argued however that the concept of God?s eternity has not only appealed to people because of the influence of early Greek philosophy, but instead Wolterstoff has suggested it appeals to people because the eternal God is different from human experience of life in the physical world. He continues, in this world the idea of God being different and always existing, as it says in the Bible, leads to philosophical understanding of God?s nature as eternal and makes believers? conviction that God is eternal more understandable. The Judaeo-Christian concept of God being eternal can refer to God being timeless (existing outside of time) or God being everlasting (having no beginning and no end, but time does pass for him). The Bible supports this view that God has always existed and will never cease to exist it is written ?I the Lord do not change.? The classical ...read more.

Middle

For Boethius God doesn?t see the future as it happens, instead Boethius argues all time is present to God ?simultaneously?. Christians base their understanding of God being eternal on the ideas of Boethius. However this concept is criticised by Anthony Kenny, among others, who argued that the notion of all time being simultaneously present to God is incoherent. He argues that saying all time is simultaneously present to God means that all time is happening at the same moment and this appears to be incoherent. Kenny?s argument against the traditional Christian idea of God being eternal is coherent and could further suggest that the whole Christian idea of God being eternal is very flawed. Swinburne supports the criticism posed by Kenny stating that he could not ?make much sense? of talk of all events being simultaneously present to God. Paul Helm however suggests talk of God being eternal does not involve the ?reductio ad absurdum? suggested by Kenny and Swinburne; he argues that the eternal God is timeless and acts eternally. Thus it can be understood that the traditional Christian concept of God being eternal is coherent because Helm says God ?timeless in the sense if being time free?. ...read more.

Conclusion

This appears to deal with the problem of God not responding to prayers. However philosophers still bring up the problem of evil, if God sees everything simultaneously surely he can eradicate those who do evil things. On the other hand Wiles argues that the universe is part of God?s ongoing creative activity thus He is always acting, and there is no selective response by God. Others claim God is in time and can act and respond to prayers. A possible solution to the problems raised by the traditional Christian concept of God being eternal is to suggest that God is not timeless, but instead he is everlasting. Everlasting meaning that God always exists and will without end, however time does pass for God. This is perhaps more coherent as this would allow God to act in time and He would not be so restricted. Also it fits more appropriately with God, as revealed in the Bible. The traditional concept of God being eternal has many criticisms, but it can still be concluded that God is eternal but is not the eternal God described by Boethius and Aquinas. Instead God is everlasting, and this way of thinking of God satisfies our understanding of God from the Bible. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christianity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christianity essays

  1. Literary Criticism of Uncle Tom's Cabin [Psychological Lense].

    Haley is enfuriated and cariies himself in an awful manner: "'I say now, Shelby, this yer's a most extro'rnary business!' said Haley, as he abruptly entered the parlor. 'It seems that gal's off, with her young un.'"

  2. Examine the main ideas and strengths of the design argument for the existence of ...

    The idea that the universe is designed is subjective, meaning that there are many different ideas about it. Different observations in the natural world can produce different theories to account for their existence. Also, this proof is built upon an analogy.

  1. Critically assess the view that the two Patrick theory solves the puzzle of Patrick

    Therefore O'Rahilly believes that his arrival date was pushed to 432, and Muirch´┐Ż persuaded readers of his narrative that Palladius had died within a year of arriving in Ireland. According to O'Rahilly, Palladius came to Ireland in 431, laboured for approximately thirty years, and died in the year 461.

  2. Outline the cosmological argument for the existance of God. and plan.

    Leibniz argues that there must be an explanation to the universe and it is illogical to just say there is no cause or explanation, when human nature determines that we need to find an explanation to everything. He says that to deny a cause of the universe is to also

  1. With reference to other aspects of human experience, comment on the view that monastic ...

    In 2008, in Dublin, only three people were ordained into the priesthood. There are many reasons for this, a main possibility being the recent scandal the Church has been involved in in recent years. In 1968, 95% of Catholics went to mass.

  2. Outline the cosmological argument for the existence of God.

    must exist. According to the argument, the existence of the Universe requires an explanation, and the creation of the Universe by a First Cause, generally assumed to be God, is that explanation. In light of the Big bang theory, a stylized version of argument has emerged (sometimes called the Kalam

  1. Critically assess the traditional Christian concept of God being eternal

    Although there are many criticisms over the idea of God being eternal the first criticism is that God knowing all time simultaneously is incoherent. Anthony Kelly famously argued that the notion of all time being simultaneously present to God is incoherent because if all times is simultaneously present to God

  2. Explain the judaeo-christian concept of God as lawgiver and judge

    It also shows that God has patience because God gave the Pharaoh a second chance to say yes. Furthermore, when it says 'The law of the Lord is perfect' it is applying to God, who gave the law to the people of Israel, both judicial and ceremonial law, and also the moral law.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work