• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Criticisms about Agustinians Theodicy, and the strengths and weaknesses.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Criticisms about Agustinians Theodicy, and the strengths and weaknesses. A theodicy (literally 'righteous God') is and argument that suggests god is right to allow the existence of evil and suffering because in some way or another, they are necessary and essential. The Augustinian Theodicy; Augustine starts from the point of view that God is perfect, the world he created reflected that perfection, this is evident in Genesis as after each day of creation 'God was pleased with what he saw'. He continues by suggesting that evil is not a substance, it is the absence of good. So sin and death enterd the world through adam and eve and their disobedience to god, because they ate the apple from the tree when god told them not too. ...read more.

Middle

We all share in the evil nature brought about by Adam and Eve because we were seminally present in them, so therefore we deserved to be punished. However, God is justified in not intervening, because the suffering is a consequence of human action. Augustine was criticised about his theodicy, to begin with one of the principal critics of the Augustinian Theodicy is F.D.E Schleiermacher. He argued that it was logically contradictory to claim that a perfectly created world went wrong, since this implies that evil created itself , which is a logical contradiction. Either the world was not perfect to start with or God made it go wrong; so it is God and not humans who are to blame, and the existence of evil is not justified. ...read more.

Conclusion

Augustine's view is also inconsistent with the theory of evolution which asserts that the universe began in chaos and is continually developing, not diminishing over time. Also Augustine's view that every human in seminally present in the loins of Adam is biologically inaccurate. The last criticism, is a moral one within Augustinian's theodicy which concerns his concept of hell. Hell appears to be a part of the design of the universe which implies that God must have already anticipated that the world would go wrong, and have accepted it. Hell is a place of eternal suffering, so therfore it seems to contradict the existance of an all loving God. Finally, although Augustine argued that God's selection of some people for heaven shows his mercy, others would argue that it displays irrational inconsistency, further questioning God's existence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Describe the main strengths and weaknesses of the cosmological argument for the existence of ...

    God's existence is a necessary presupposition of there being any moral judgements that are objective, that go beyond mere relativistic moral preferences; such judgements require standards external to any human mind-that is, they presume God's mind.51 Although, a person may know that God is omnipresent but that does not mean they fully understand his being.

  2. HOW EFFECTIVE IS THE AUGUSTINIAN THEODICY IN EXPLAINING THE EXISTENCE OF EVIL & SUFFERING ...

    Either the world was created imperfect or God allowed it to go wrong. Perhaps the most important criticisms are moral as they challenge God. Being omniscient, God should have known that things would go wrong and being omnipotent, 'He' could have made creation better and less flawed.

  1. Augustine's theodicy

    by people who can easily be falsified and could be seen as metaphor. Evolution has proved that mankind has evolved for millions of years from particles of matter. This means that Adam and Eve and the Fall can only realistically be taken metaphorically.

  2. Do the Strengths of the Design Argument out way the Weaknesses

    Here the Design Argument has a definite weakness; because the whole point of the argument it is to prove the God of Classical Theism. There are many possibilities for this designer of the cosmos. The designer could be female or male; there could be many designers/ deities and so forth.

  1. Explain and evaluate Augustine's Theodicy

    sin committed by Adam and Eve, inheriting it as a part of their human nature and God being a just God continues to punish people for Adam and Eve's disobedience. However this goes against the idea of God being omnibenevolent, as why would a loving God make innocent people suffer

  2. discuss the claim that any belief in life after death is a theodicy in ...

    Also, what about babies who died very young, would heaven be wasted on them? If we were resurrected in a replica of our present physical bodies what will happen to those who were born disabled or lost limbs due to various accidents, if they were to keep their present bodies

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work