• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month


Extracts from this document...


ESSAY 2: DISEMBODIED EXISTENCE CAN NEVER BE EXPLAINED COHERENTLY, BECAUSE IT IS A CONTRADICTION IN TERMS. DISCUSS. A linguistic philosopher heavily supports this statement, since it is a contradiction in terms, using their monistic thoughts. To them life after death, is a contradictory concept, because you cannot continue to live, after you have died; it would be surviving death. The concept of disembodied existence to the linguistic philosopher cannot be coherently explained because it is a contradiction, as they already hold the presupposition of monism, which believes that soul and body are one entity, which cannot be separated. For them a disembodied existence, is not an option and therefore using linguistic philosophy, the premise of disembodied existence does not hold well, because there should be no life after death. Other thinkers have criticised with this type of philosophy, but they themselves are dualists. For example, Schlick argues that it is possible to have life after death, by claiming you could witness your own funeral. It now, becomes plausible that disembodied survival is coherent and not a contradiction in terms, from this point of view, as mind and body after death could have been have been separated, as they are composite natures, to the dualist. ...read more.


As a result, if disembodied existence is to be accepted, for a dualist, the identification of others is not a contradiction, and is logical and coherent. The coherency of disembodied existence can be supported by cases of telepathy, which also regards the workings of mind states, without physical input. Telepathy shows that the concept of disembodied survival is not only conceivable, and can be understood coherently and telepathy is somewhat of tangible evidence, as it can be proved, through stringent tests, also by analysing the records already at our disposal, because the mind can work independently to the body. The other problem, of proclaiming the philosophy of disembodied life after death, is continuation. For us to survive death and even begin to discuss the chances of an after life, there must be this non-stop flow; a continuity of us. The person who dies and survives death should be us, we are the ones to move in to the afterlife. Physco- physical advocate, John Hick's uses his famous, Replica Theory, in order to show that, continuity is logical possibility. Hick's start by saying imagine a person sitting somewhere, and then all of a sudden stops existing in that place, only to exist somewhere else, without journeying to that new place. ...read more.


Other reasons stem from the philosophical reasoning at hand, such as Plato's and Kant's philosophy, which argues for the soul's immortality, and in addition the human capacity to even experience the 'eternal' does seem to mean that there must be something that is eternal is us. It is disputed, admittedly, that even though we can experience little of the concept 'eternal' we do not necessarily have to be eternal. There are qualities that are associated with the divine, that we seem to be aware of , such as compassion and forgiveness, and still we are not divine ourselves. Therefore disembodied survival can not be coherently explained In addition, it is not reasonable to argue from the Platonic version of the immortal soul or the moral argument as represented by Kant, because there is no empirical evidence to support either of these. The immortality of the soul is highly dependent on the world of the Forms which has yet to be proven, just like, the Kantian moral argument, which calls for there to be a God to provide us with the summum bonum in another life. Again, God is an unproven, unsupported concept. An argument cannot be used to prove something else, if it is not proved itself. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Theories of the resurrection of the body are logically coherent.

    4 star(s)

    Having thus established that, overall, a materialist view of the resurrection of the body has the potential of being the most probable and (as shown by the example of the hypothetical cloning)

  2. Conscience is the voice of God - discuss

    For example, Trevor Huddleson fought against his own racist culture by being an Anti-Apartheid activist in South Africa, despite being white. W. H. Auden's romantic expression of the human condition, "We must love one another or die", describes the idea that our morality arises from a biological instinct, and this can be supported by Darwin's theory of natural selection.

  1. Theories of Resurrection of the body are logically coherent - Discuss

    Dualists would disagree with the idea of bodily resurrection, both Christianity's and Hick's theories. Plato one of the earliest theorists behind dualism suggested that the mind and soul are separate, he wrote about how the body is finite, and

  2. Science Solves All The Problems About Where We Come From Discuss

    the behemoth which I made along with you and which feeds like an ox. What strength he has in his loins, what power in the muscles of his belly!" Morris not only seems to have an explanation for the apparent lack of mention of dinosaurs, but also can pinpoint their

  1. The concept of disembodied existence is coherent - Discuss

    Susan Blackmore employs a "divide-and-conquer" approach, assigning different medical causes to different aspects of the experience, but her conclusions are speculative and appear to outrun the data The idea of disembodied survival, even if not logically incoherent, is one we have don't have a sufficient grasp of to allow it to count as a real possibility.

  2. "Reincarnation is a more plausible account of life after death than disembodied existence"

    For Hindus the criteria for preserving personal identity are the memory, personality and beliefs. Hindus also believe birth situation reflects behaviour in previous lives. This is because of karma, which is the doctrine that the sum of a person's voluntary actions in previous states of existence controls his or her fate in future existences.

  1. The Concept of Life After Death is Incoherent - Discuss.

    The idea of Plato's realm of the form involves a permanent disembodiment whilst reincarnation and resurrection usually hold only temporary disembodiments. This raises the question of is a disembodied existence even possible since we have no proof of the soul to begin with?

  2. Conscience is innate. Discuss

    The second conscience which Piaget outlines is the autonomous conscience. This develops after the age of 10, where an individual is able to distinguish between right and wrong before they make their decision about what action they are going to take.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work