• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Examine what is meant by situation ethics

Extracts from this document...


Situation Ethics Examine what is meant by situation ethics (14) "Christianity has traditionally been dominated by natural law thinking and Situation Ethics arose out of this background" (The Puzzle of Ethics, by Peter Vardy and Paul Grosch, page 123). In the 1966 an Anglican theologian, Joseph Fletcher published a book called "Situation Ethics" in which he rejected previous deontological ethical systems. It would be wrong to believe that Fletcher founded the idea of Situation Ethics because, as I have already stated, Situation ethics has its foundations in the natural law thinking of the Christian Church. Fletcher claimed there were three possible approaches to ethics. There was the deontological approach where you have a set of rules that may never be broken, no matter what the circumstances. Fletcher believed this inflexible approach created a poor ethical system because it put the law first and made the law the most important thing. The Ten Commandments is a good example of this. Take "thou shalt not steal", is it right to steal a gun from a man who intends to use it to murder his wife? If you believe that the law is intrinsically good and should be put first then you would not steal the gun. ...read more.


The second is Positivism, reasoning within religious faith. People have to be able to see for themselves why love is paramount and the most important consideration. Situation Ethics is dependent upon people being about to see that love is the most important factor. Personalism is the fourth presumption that people should be put first. Deontological ethical systems put the law first; in these systems the law is the most important factor. With Situation Ethics people are the most important and are put before any other consideration. Supporters of Situation Ethics love people not laws. To take the example of the man with a gun who intends to shoot his wife. The most loving action would be to steal the gun for love of the wife because he intends to kill her, the person is put first. If we were simply following the Ten Commandments then the law would be put first, it would be wrong to steal the gun and so we must allow the man to shoot his wife. As well as the four presumptions that Fletcher highlighted in his book "Situation Ethics", there are the six basic principles. These follow on from and extend the presumptions. The first principle is "Only love is intrinsically good; nothing else", with Situation Ethics the only criteria for something being good is that it brings about love; if something does this then it is good and there are no other factors to take into consideration. ...read more.


The sixth and final principle is that, "Love's decisions are made situationally, not prescriptively.". In Situation Ethics there is no way of knowing whether something is right or wrong because the circumstances of each situation are unique. Moral decisions are only possible when applied to a particular example, generalisation and absolute decisions are not permitted. However, for this to work we have to rely on the assumption that people are able to make decisions themselves. Dostoevsky's Grand Inquisitor believed that people could not cope with the freedom given to them and wanted to impose laws instead. For Situation Ethics to work the Grand Inquisitor must be wrong and humans must be able to make decisions for themselves. To conclude, Fletcher, although not the original pioneer of the basic principles of Situation Ethics is the authority we look to simply because it was he who developed these basic ideas and published his book "Situation Ethics" in 1966. The foundation of Situation Ethics is the 'Law of Love', the agape form of love is the most important thing and comes before any other consideration. Also, absolute rules are not permitted because Situation Ethics recognises that each situation is unique and should be treated as such. The only absolute statement that cannot be contradicted within this ethical system is that love is the most important thing. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. RE euthanasia for and against

    Hospices are there to attempt to relieve pain and provide support for a patient, their family and friends. There are only about 100 hospices in the UK so it is very difficult to get a place. The three main aims of hospices are, to relieve pain, to help face death and to care for emotional needs of family and friends.

  2. Essay on Law vs. Justice

    wonder how many companies have not been caught and will the recent highly publicized scandals force change within these organizations. Operating in a non-ethical manner can be very profitable to a company. Unethical behavior can result in huge personal gains for the employees of today's corporations.

  1. Free essay

    Explain What Is Meant By natural law

    Although some aspects of these precepts can be debatable, masturbation is against the primary precept as it does not preserve life. But then one can rebuttal and say that rape would be acceptable as it preserving life. The secondary precepts are more flexible and realistic; they are a specific application

  2. Business Ethics

    (Business ethics, Andrew Crane and Dirk Matten, 2007, Oxford, pg 9-11) Ones of the case study show in business ethics is McDonalds. McDonald's fast food chain was very close to winning the Business Ethics award for environmental excellence in 1999.

  1. Explain What Is Meant By Situation Ethics.

    All anyone should do in any situation is to determine what the most loving course of action would be. Fletcher used the example of a woman in a prison camp that became pregnant in order to be released, therefore it may have been the right thing to do, as she

  2. The Ethics of Stealing

    This is similar to saying we should always tell the truth. The idea of cultural relativism can also be used as a counter argument, in many cultures, if not all, stealing is deemed a wrong. If you steal, you are punished.

  1. Medical Ethics And Organ Transplants

    would be over looked and relies on everyone to have Christian beliefs. In ?The Brothers of Karamazov? Ivan says ?without god everything is permitted? which advocates people to act in an immoral way. This poses the question of the non-believer who states that they have no reason to act morally

  2. Explain what is meant by a Natural Law approach to ethics

    Natural law has developed an approach in how to judge a person?s actions through interior and exterior acts. To follow our purpose and obey natural law our interior and exterior acts must be good and have the best intentions to obey god.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work