• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Hick gives the best solution to the mind-body problem. His theory is both scientific and theological in his approach. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Megan Humphries Hick gives the best solution to the mind-body problem. His theory is both scientific and theological in his approach. Discuss. John Hick is a materialist, he believes that the body and the soul are one and at death the body and soul both die. Hick aims to show that the concept of life after death doesn?t depend on human beings having souls in the way Plato and other thinkers believed. He believes that even though the death of our body is the death of the person, there is no separate soul to live on and he argues that this doesn?t rule out the possibility of our existence after death. Although Hick believes that the body and soul both die, he also says that it could be possible for the dead to exist after death as the same person if an exact replica of them were to appear. ...read more.


Hick agreed with St Paul however he believed that he contradicted himself by saying that the soul is immortal and by also saying that we have a spiritual boy. Therefore Hick improved upon St Paul?s ideas using his replica theory. Many philosophers don?t accept that a replica body is still the same as the ?I? that died. Hick tried to solve this problem with a series of experiments to prove that the ?I? that existed in this world is the same ?I? that is resurrected in the next world. He used the idea of a man called John Smith; Hick said imagine John Smith who lived in America, one day his friends watched as Smith vanished without a trace. At the same moment as he disappeared, a replica John Smith appeared in India. Hick believes that this is the same John Smith. Hick then used this idea in a different scenario. ...read more.


The soul is not matter which is unthinking. The physical world in which the body exists, the soul however is immaterial. The aim of the soul, according to Plato, is to break free from the chains of matter and escape to the realm of ideas where it will be able to spend eternity. Plato believes that the body wouldn?t survive death, but the soul would continue. There is nothing scientific about Hicks replica theory; he is simply theological in his approach. By saying that when we die we there is a replica of us in heaven doesn?t make sense, this is because the replica would not be the same person as it wouldn?t have the same genes and DNA as the living individual. This theory also wouldn?t give the families of the dead any comfort especially if the individual died in pain, this is because the replica theory would mean that the person is still the same as they were when they were in pain and therefore isn?t how the families would prefer to remember them. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Plato's Theory of Forms

    Christians now believe that the world is not the only world and that there is another realm where we will live eternally after death, which relieves people who are scared about death. The concept of the Form of the Good has helped to shape the way in which Christians understand

  2. Natural law is the most reliable approach when making judgements about sex and relationships. ...

    Contraception is a very controversial topic. Natural law is against the fundamental principle of contraception (stopping a child being conceived). Contraception quite simply goes against one of natural law's five principles; reproduction, therefore natural law is against any form of contraception, so too is the Catholic Church.

  1. Theories of Resurrection of the body are logically coherent - Discuss

    Ghost in the Machine analogy, where he claims the idea of a separate mind operating the apparatus of the body absurd. Other Monists such as Bertrand Russell suggest that belief in the afterlife is derived from human 'wishful thinking'. He described human fear of death as instinctive, and the cause of a human belief in life after death.

  2. An embodied life in heaven is entirely possible. Discuss.

    Contemplation of the higher realities, allows a person's soul to enter eternity after the death of the physical body. This was the basic understanding behind the teachings of Plato, according to which the physical world of sense phenomena (our senses)

  1. 'A belief in the life after death solves the problem of evil' Discuss

    He said that the soul and body are one. If the body dies then the soul dies. He accepts that there is a possibility for a life after death to exist. He says that somehow after death there will be a physical representation that will make us, who we are.

  2. Discuss the characteristics of the scientific method which makes it superior over other methods ...

    Inductive reasoning, by its very nature, is more open-ended and exploratory, especially at the beginning. Deductive reasoning is narrower in nature and is concerned with testing or confirming hypotheses. Even though a particular study may look like it's purely deductive (e.g., an experiment designed to test the hypothesized effects of

  1. Why does the mind and body problem still exist?

    One way is Dualism In philosophy of mind, dualism is a set of beliefs which begins with the claim that the mental and the physical have a fundamentally different nature. Dualism has been the driving force behind the mind-body problem and has been by far the majority view until recently

  2. The Concept of Life After Death is Incoherent - Discuss.

    Dr Raymond Moody had studied a large number of patients who had said they experienced some kind of out of body experience during a serious operations. In his study he found that there were a great deal of similarities between the cases he had studied.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work