If God knows what we are going to do, he has no right to reward the good and punish the wicked (35 marks)

Furthermore, if he can interfere with the world but chooses not to, allowing us our free will, he is logically responsible for evil and so can neither blame nor punish us. This is the same as if I saw a man about to rape a woman, and I possessed sufficient force to stop him, but chose to not act saying that both the man and the woman had to learn the extent of their free will and choose to be good like me.  He chose not to help us, and gives us an unproductive punishment in Hell.

So If God knows what we are going to do, does he have the right to reward and punish? This depends on whether his omniscience interferes with free will.

If he sees all time as the eternal present as a result of possessing timelessness (the view of Richard Swinburne) then he knows what we are going to do, what the consequences will be and whether he will intervene which he is powerless to change as he knows it is happening (to him). Therefore, he does not have the right to punish as there was no alternate better action (even from his point of view).

If the is within the same time scale with us and experiences time linearly as we do, not knowing the future as that is logically impossible, then he does not know what we are going to do and discovers with us. He knows the logical extrapolation of every free choice and necessity in the world, as Boethius had it. So he could step in and change the future but chooses not to. As explained above, he is thus responsible and unable to judge lest ye be judged.

In conclusion, God never has the right to reward/punish, because if he knows the future there is no other option for humankind regardless whether God says what will happen or merely knows it. Rewarding and Punishing assumes there are alternative actions. And if God does not know the future, then he can logically intervene and so takes all responsibility for the event, so cannot judge.