• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Any Account of the State of Nature Convincing?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Is any Account of the Condition of Mankind in the State of Nature Convincing? (30) The State of Nature is a hypothetical state where there is no government, no state, and no laws to rule over mankind, which allows us to understand the question of 'why should I be governed?' The movement from the State of Nature to a government or a state, many philosophers argue, is based on the need for a social contract, supported by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau. The social contract is an agreement between the people to live together under the laws in our society (according to Hobbes, this contract can either be tacit or explicit), though the reason that we enter this social contract differs due to the many conditions of the nature of mankind in the state of nature, as each account offers a very different view on humanity. Hobbes depicts a savage State of Nature (referred to as a 'State of War' in Leviathan), and to understand this State of Nature, we must first understand its components - people. ...read more.

Middle

John Locke, in complete contrast to Hobbes, however, views the State of Nature with regards to 'morals'. Both Locke and Hobbes agree that the State of Nature is a state of perfect freedom and equality, and that we all have the right of self preservation, but there are limitations on what we may do, given by the 'Law of Nature'. This 'Law of Nature' is that no person may subordinate another; harm his life, health, liberty or possessions. Essentially, one can do something so long as it is not detrimental to other people. The State of Nature, therefore, is a state of liberty, governed only through the 'Law of Nature'. This Law of Nature is discovered through reasoning or through God, as we are all God's creatures and have a natural understanding that we cannot harm one another, which allows the State of Nature to be peaceful, and, by extension, the condition of mankind to be peaceful and moral. ...read more.

Conclusion

So it is compassion which acts as a powerful mean to restrain people to harm others. Rousseau pictures the savage man as a solitary human being, able to survive alone. His speech is not yet developed and cannot express opinions on things. The peculiarity which distinguishes him from the animals is, according to Rousseau, the free will and capacity of self-improvement. Finally, he advocates that it is the capacity of self-improvement to have brought progress to mankind and misfortune with it. I think that the picture that Rousseau has drawn of the State of Nature populated by "noble savages" more similar to animals than civilised human beings (such as in the theories of Hobbes and Locke) may be a plausible vision, though I do not necessarily agree with his dark view of human development. Rousseau's beliefs that civilization and progress led to a state of war, bringing evil and misfortune into a "purified world" which was still blessed by ignorance, is certainly coherent with his argument. However, I find more challenging trying to imagine how the state of nature would be if populated by developed and civilized human beings as in Hobbes' and Locke's views. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Discuss some of the issues raised in Meta-Ethics. How convincing is the view that, ...

    This is known as a 'value proposition' and it is this element of the equation that gives the conclusion (B) its moral force. But exactly why does Moore refer to this straight shift from an 'is' to an 'ought' a misleading notion?

  2. Humans are Eternal Beings

    Descartes believed, as another dualist, that both mind and body were separate. To understand Descartes' need for certainty, and his subsequent statement of 'cogito ergo sum', it is important to contextualise him. The 16th century was a time of great upheaval; the many paradigm shifts of the scientific community, and the morality-inducing Thirty Years War had many questioning their morality.

  1. Just War

    - Declaration of the Quakers to Charles II 1661 Reinhold Niebuhr criticised the naivety of absolute pacifism as neglecting the equally important biblical principles of justice and the wrath of God whilst over emphasising peace and reconciliation. He argued that pacifists equally shirk their responsibility for striving for justice and

  2. Modern life-prolonging technologies have sharpened some ancient dilemmas on the value of life.

    that our medical cleverness has forced us to face and to make. No one would develop a list of factors defining a life not worth living unless the tragedy of competition for scarce resources had made it absolutely necessary, or unless our medical cleverness and old moral habits had led us to prolong vital signs under grotesque, inhumane circumstances.

  1. The Dreamings as being fundamental to Aboriginal cultures & societies

    Protectn Board est.'d 1883 ( missionaries b/cm interested in welfare of Abor. ( Abor. b/cm increasingly institutionalised ( Abor. b/cm dependant on govt. & reserves ( 1915 ( Amendments to 1909 Act, granting power to remove children fr. their parents for training: Stolen Generation ( 1940s-1950s ( Eur.

  2. Does the "War on Terror" mean the just war doctrine is dead?

    would lead to the capture of Osama Bin Laden and later the revelation of where Iraq was holding its Weapons of Mass Destruction. This is one of the most obvious and extreme case of human rights violations by a western country at the turn of the twenty first century, because

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work