• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

religion linked to morality

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

A) Outline the reasons why some argue that morality is linked to religion B) Examine and comment on the reasons for arguing that morality should not be linked to religion 'It's impossible to think of a command without also thinking of a commander' (H.P.Owen) Religion is the belief in and worship of a God or Gods, or any such system of belief and worship. Morality is a personal or social set of standards for good or bad behaviour and character, or the quality of being right, honest or acceptable. These two words 'Morality' and 'Religion' represent a dilemma philosophers have been trying to understand for a long time, mainly whether or not these are linked when making decisions or indeed independent of one another. Many people argue that religion and morality are linked, one such argument being religious authority. Many religions, if not all, use holy books that contain teachings that show people what is morally right and wrong, for example the sermon on the mount in Christianity, the torah scrolls in Judaism and the Qur'an in Islam. ...read more.

Middle

This theory states that religion and morality depend upon a common source for their values, for example Roman Catholicism and Natural Moral Law. The positives of this argument show that morality and religion share a common source of 'mystical awareness'. Moreover, many philosophers argue that good is known by intuition, 'That which cannot be defined is paralleled in religious experience'. Plato's euthyro dilemma is an extremely important point in this argument that links morality to religion. 'Is X good because God loves it?' , from this point of view God is all powerful (omnipotent), all knowing (omniscient), omnipresent and omnibenevolent. In addition, therefore, God is the creator of morality and his morality is absolute. However the other point of view from Plato's euthyro dilemma is 'Does God love X because X is good' This point argues that morality should not be linked to religion, as it is saying that God is less powerful, more of a mentor as he points people in the right direction. God commands us to do things because they are true in themselves, independent of God, therefore, he does not create morality. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is advocated by Kant who said humans follow 'Pure Moral Law' which is given by our ability to reason. Furthermore, Sigmund Freud claimed that morality arises as a therapeutic attempt to resolve the conflict between our inherent aggression and the 'cultural super ego' (collective community authority). In conclusion, it is fair to say that there are valid points on both sides of this argument. For morality being linked to religion, the feelings of guilt and responsibility being pointed towards God and the presence of religious authority (i.e. the bible) are strong arguments. This is because they both indicate that we base our moral decisions due to the feeling that we are responsible to someone higher than us, which is particularly strong in the John Henry Newman argument. For morality not being linked to religion, the atheism and Darwin argument are both particularly strong arguments. This is because they both indicate that moral is based more on natural intuition, as atheists' make decisions without religious basis, and Darwin observed that there was some sort of morality in primitive animals, who of course have no rational knowledge of religion. Therefore I conclude that morality should not be linked to religion. Liam Hogan ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Religion and Morality

    The second half of Plato's Euthyphro Dilemma suggests that goodness is separate from God. This would mean for a Christian that they would have to look to a different source to find their moral values, basically eliminating the need for God and Christianity.

  2. (a) Examine the reasons why some argue that morality is linked ...

    If we removed from either the Old Testament or the New Testament those passages concerned with morality - especially about behaviour towards others - we would be left with very thin volumes indeed. It is not entirely unjustified, therefore to say that religion is seen to go in tandem with

  1. "Humanitarian intervention, which is ruled out by realism and the morality of states, can ...

    Prescriptive realists are of the view that humanitarian intervention is possible, but that it is not justifiable, as humanitarian reasons are not legitimate reasons for intervention. Given the costs of military intervention, the state should only use military force when it is required to further its own vital national interest.

  2. Evaluate Korsgaard's discussion of the Universalizability Argument. In what ways does she conform with ...

    Moral identity is a rational psychology. Moral identity is tenable for some reasons. First, moral identity treats the subject as the fundamental aspect of all sorts as human. It makes us humans. It recognizes and asserts that all human endeavors should always be seen as an effort to affirm oneself in his very basic aspect, human nature for instance.

  1. Explain Aquinass cosmological argument

    in terms of the A postreiori knowledge that is visible to all of us, such as the fact that everything has a cause, makes the existence of God seem necessary and almost obvious. The argument that the universe is infinite is also a good one, as everything within the universe

  2. Explore the view that morality without religious belief is impossible

    On the other hand, many would assert that you can be moral without a religious belief. In Maslow?s Hierarchy of Needs, he states that morality can be achieved once five basic conditions are met: food water, shelter, homeostasis and sex.

  1. Does Morality Depend on Religion?

    Euthyphro is asked by Socrates whether the good is good because the gods think it is, or if it is deemed good by the gods because it is good on its own; Euthyphro finds it quite difficult to reach a conclusion with a sense of certainty or any real evidence or reason to support his claim.

  2. Examine the key ideas of one critique of the link between religion and morality. ...

    If God can no longer claim ultimate responsibility of control, his omnipotence is damaged because it means he is not ?all? powerful. Moreover, God depends on his goodness to the extent to which he conforms to an independent moral standard.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work