• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Religious and/or moral principles are a hindrance with medical ethics. Examine and comment on this claim, with reference to the topic you have investigated.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

George Thomas 12JB Religious and/or moral principles are a hindrance with medical ethics?. Examine and comment on this claim, with reference to the topic you have investigated. Abortion is the medical ethic of which I have investigated; a controversial topic to say the least. The above statement is one that definitely applies to the problems of abortion. However to understand how the statement can be applied one must come to terms with the definitions and aspects of abortion. Abortion can be defined as the intended termination of an unborn child, a foetus. The abortion act was introduced to the UK in 1967; however in Ireland the approach is still illegal. With abortion there is a criteria that follows: two doctors must certify and allow for the abortion to proceed and an abortion cannot go ahead if the method were to cause any lasting physical or psychological damage. In most cases an abortion can go under way if it protects the life of the mother. The methods of abortion are also an important aspect to consider. There are various methods and treatments a woman can have to proceed with the abortion. For example a woman between 7 ? 15 weeks can take a pill which induces the same consequences of a miscarriage; an early medical abortion. This contrasts then with the late term abortion which relies on surgery and surgical instruments being used to extract and exterminate the foetus inside the womb. ...read more.

Middle

He wouldn?t agree with an induced miscarriage or termination. On the other hand theists like Joseph Fletcher would take an approach with the idea of love. Situation Ethics promotes the idea that an action should inflict the most loving thing. Therefore he would sympathise and take into account the woman?s choice of abortion in this case. I believe that the QOL vs. SOL argument is a very strong one indeed and one that won?t cease to exists as long as religious and moral principles remain in our world. The next topic I will go onto investigate is the idea of viability. Viability is the view that at what point should an abortion be acceptable, or viable? The law in the UK has the cut off point of up to 24 weeks which, with moral and religious principles, causes hindrance to abortion. The hindrance being with moral principles and the cultural evolution. There have been cases where, whilst in the same hospital, women at 22 weeks are going into a premature pregnancy, however another women at 24 weeks is having an abortion. The problem here is that, with the aid of modern day technology, the premature baby will go onto live a completely ?normal?, healthy life. Whilst the possible life of the 24 week foetus will lose its possible life. ...read more.

Conclusion

The final topics of abortion which, through religious and moral principles, are a hindrance are the methods and approaches to abortion. This key aspect of abortion one that does result in much conflict. For example, in China, with the aid of the One Child Policy, many women have faced the consequences of this police. A woman who was pregnant with a child at 8 months was forced to have a late medical abortion. This would have been a highly controversial and severe event which of religious and moral principles would conflict with Bentham?s principles of Utility. This act could some appropriate as it is benefitting the majority?s decision, in China, of the policy. Whereas on the other hand, with religious principles such as karma in Hinduism or the mitzvots in Judaism the hindrance would arise in the supposed ?immoral? act of this abortion. In my opinion this case study is highly controversial as it provides the idea of immorality, with principles causing hindrance within the medical ethic. Overall, when looking back at the statement, I think there is much truth and validity in the claim. However as I have investigated there were solutions that came from religious principles. But to conclude, this investigation has shown that medical ethics such as abortion will face challenges and hindrances with the presence of religious and moral principles and values. AO1 AO2 48 / 50 35 / 36 14 / 15 96% = A ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Practical Questions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Practical Questions essays

  1. Examine and comment on the view that the principle of the sanctity of life ...

    He argues that the principle of natural law depends on establishing the purpose of human life, which Aquinas maintains is to live, reproduces, learn, worship God and order society. He believed that if everything is created for a purpose, human reason, in examining that purpose, is able to judge how

  2. Explain Aquinass cosmological argument

    Bertrand Russell also picks up on the fact that Aquinas contradicts himself by arguing against infinite regression and then argues that God is both unmoved and uncaused, and is an infinite being. The cosmological argument is based on observations and experience, yet Kant argues that we cannot apply human experiences of the universe to things that are beyond our understanding.

  1. Religious Studies - Ethics: Natural Moral Law

    Therefore, Aquinas' assumption that all men seek to worship God may seem unnatural to many and the idea of a God-given moral code within nature is meaningless to those who do not believe in God as a creator. Natural Law holds that there is an objective morality that humans can

  2. Evaluate a Utilitarian approach to Abortion.

    In relation to abortion, this could happen if a foetus is aborted simply because the family do not see a child as fitting with their current lifestyle, which some people would argue is an immoral choice, but it is justified by the theory; this illustrates that the theory doesn?t protect the interests of the minority.

  1. Abortion and Personhood. Explain how the concept of personhood applies to abortion.

    However, what is also important to take into consideration is when the foetus is a person. Firstly, conception is an obvious example. This case is supported by the fact that from the moment of fertilization, genetically the egg contains everything that will make it a unique individual.

  2. Debate Task. Abortion Position Paper

    They trust that every child in the world should be wanted and reducing the amount of unwanted children will lower the percentage of child abuse. They also believe that the world is already overpopulated but since when does the value of a person?s life depend on the amount of people there are in the world?

  1. How are religious and ethical principles used in the abortion debate?

    Given this emphasis, the Second Vatican Council defined abortion as 'an unspeakable crime.' However, the Methodist Church takes a much more liberal and situational approach to the problem; while it accepts that the foetus is 'obviously human', it allows that the circumstances of pregnancy, such as rape, may also be taken into account.

  2. Assess the claim that Free Will and Determinism are compatible

    Again using the example of the robber, hard determinists will counter argue that you have no free will. You will not fight the thief if they have a gun or are stronger then you. This robbery was predestined and inevitable.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work