• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Religious Experience - Edexel A2

Extracts from this document...


Religious Experience Essay "Religious experience does not provide a secure basis for belief in God." Analyse and discuss this claim. Few topics in philosophy and theology cause as much disagreement as religious experience. With its different definitions and numerous types, anything from seeing the Virgin Mary to being relaxed at the sound of your favourite piece of classical music, religious experience has attracted the attention of many scholars, both pro and anti religious experience. Although they can take many different forms, there are several things that link different types of religious experience, although they do not always appear in every experience. They are a personal experience, especially the ones that involve some sort of divine influence. They also have a direct and prominent effect on the person's life. If a person had experienced a near-death experience, and found that they had experienced a pleasant afterlife, then they would be more likely to be relaxed about death. Indeed, there are certain scholars who believe that one can only say that a religious experience has taken place, if there is a change in life. For example, Saul, commonly called Paul, had a famous conversion on the Road to Damascus. ...read more.


Caroline Franks Davis broadly agrees with Swinburne, taking the view, in The Evidential Force of Religious Experience, that with all the inferred arguments for God's existence, the probability is roughly equal for God's existence as not. Religious experiences, however, may tip the balance in favor of God's existence. C F Davis is most recognized in the field of religious experience for her three challenges over religious experiences, aimed mainly at Swinburne's principles of testimony and credulity. The description related challenge challenges the experience on the basis of self-contradiction, or the inherent difficulty that surrounds the use of language as a communicating tool. Since one person may not necessarily use language the same way as another, the use of language as a communication tool is flawed. The subject related challenge challenges the experience on the basis of the individual experiencing them, and the condition that they were in when they had the experience. If the person was under the influence, then their report may not hold as much weight as someone who had a religious experience when they were in a normal condition. However, a common rebuttal is that, just because someone is somehow mentally impaired, it does not nessecarly mean that what they experienced was not real. ...read more.


Although his definition of an experience is vague, his approach to identifying religious experiences is epically based, and is similar to more modern approaches, like those employed at the Hardy Institute. James also refers to the fruits of the experience being more important than the experience itself, a feeling that holds true with modern theologians. If the objections are combined, then it appears that any religious experience can be objected to in some way: a person's state, the language that they use, the experience, or the person themselves can all be used as an objection; Freud and Jung believed that religious belief was a neurosis, caused by the repressed love of the mother, or from "penis envy." Hume took a less scientific route when he said that theists could not be truly trusted, as they are prone to lying, and are devoid of a "good sense, education and learning" to make sure that they are not fooling themselves. In conclusion, if by a secure basis for belief, we mean a feeling of certainty, then religious experience will only boost the faith of those who believe, and strengthen the criticisms of those who do not believe in God. In short, the religious experience debate falls foul of Flew's vicious circle. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philosophy section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philosophy essays

  1. Ontological Argument - Edexcel A2

    Using an analogy of a triangle, Descartes said, in Meditations, that although an actual triangle does not have to exist, the mention of a triangle gives the image of a shape with 3 sides and angles totalling 180�. In a similar way, the idea of God gives the image of

  2. The verification principle offers no real challenge to religious belief. Discuss

    scent and makes no sound, a gardener who comes secretly to look after the garden which he loves". Flew's argument is that religious believers act in the same way as the believing explorer. Flew gives the example of saying God loves people, even if disaster happens.

  1. Assess the view that the different forms of religious experience are nothing more than ...

    from the shrine of St Thomas Becket after she was crying profusely. From these experiences of which many questions could be asked are very unreliable and couldn't be taken as proof for real religious experiences and meetings with a higher power.

  2. Compare and contrast arguments for and against belief in life after death.

    According to Verdic tradition, there is an ultimate reality - Brahman. Everything else is maya - a temporary and finite illusion. Within maya there is a limitless number of souls who all seek union with Brahman. The theory of karma and rebirth is concerned with the soul's journey from illusion to reality6.

  1. Examine the contributions that two of the following may make to a study of ...

    Plantinga argues that to claim that "god exists" is to make an existential assertion. It is not to talk symbolically of mythological of to agree to a certain attitude. Plantinga maintains that when a Christian speaks of the existence of god they are claiming first that a person does exists

  2. Evaluate the claim that corporate religious experience is no more than an illusion

    One might therefore question whether the miracle of Bernadette at Lourdes was in fact due to an illusion caused by her continuing disease, which did eventually kill her at a young age. Although Lourdes is commonly known in Catholicism as a place of healing, there have only been 6 recognised

  1. Does Religious Experience offer a convincing argument for God

    However, the believer remains unconvinced, and insists that the gardener is invisible, has no scent and gives no sound. The sceptic doesn't agree, and asks how a so-called invisible, intangible, gardener differs from an imaginary gardener or even no gardener at all.

  2. Critically assess with reference to William James the arguments from religious experience.

    For some scholars these conflicting claims in different religious traditions cancel each other out, weakening James? claims. Another thing James believed was that religious experiences were valid and objective because of two observable effects they had on people both in the immediate and long term.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work