• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Study the authorship of one book in the bible.

Extracts from this document...


The Pastoral epistles are the letters of 1 Tim, 2 Tim, and Titus, which contain instructions and advice. These epistles are traditionally associated with the apostle Paul, however the authenticity of this authorship was brought into question in 1807 when scholars, such as Friedrich Schleiermacher and J.G. Eichhorn, began to point out the differences in style. Which suggested that Paul, was not in fact the author of the Pastoral Epistles. The Pastoral Epistles present a striking difference from the other epistles attributed to Paul. The epistles are addressed to Pauline delegates, giving instructions to them for when Paul is absent. These epistles present a very different authorial style than any other of Paul's epistles; this raises the question were the Pauline epistles written by Paul? The Deblius - Conzelmann commentary states that the language of 1 Tim, 2 Tim and Titus is a higher form of Hellenic Greek than the rest of the New Testament. The difference in language raises questions. Another issue that needs addressing is that the events portrayed in the pastorals do not directly correspond with the accounts of Paul's life in Acts. In addition all of Paul's writings are to congregations whereas the pastorals are to individuals; this seems unusual for the writing of Paul. Paul was a persecutor called Saul who actively opposed the new Christian religion. ...read more.


The table below illustrates Paul's joint authorship: The Letters of St. Paul Paul Paul, Silvaneus, & Timothy Paul & Sosthanes Paul and Timothy Paul and Brothers 1 Timothy * 2 Timothy * Titus * Romans * 1Corinthians * 2Corinthians * Galatians * Ephesians * * Philippians 1Thessalonians * 2Thessalonians * Philemon * Hebrew * (unknown) Colossians * Prior argued that because Paul mainly wrote letters with others hence it is perfectly feasible to suggest that the Pastoral Epistles are the most truthful to Paul's penmanship, as the others may have been affected by the influence of Paul's writing companions. Another solution is that the Pastoral Epistles were written pseudo-graphically. It is thought that the writer of the Pastoral Epistles wrote them with the requirements of the church in his day, and devised three forged letters giving advice to his aides. The author used several literary devices to create the impression that Paul was writing: firstly ensuring it was normal Pauline letter writing, this includes the address, greeting and personal details. Secondly he created such texts as II Tim 4.13, 1.4 to add appeal to Paul's everyday needs and to strengthen the fiction. He also rooted the church offices of his own day to the personal bond between Timothy and Paul. H.J Holtzmann gave "the most serious assault on the authenticity of the pastorals"3. ...read more.


The bible is becoming more and more inaccessible as time moves on, and although taking Paul's name was unwise, it may have been the only way that followers would have listened and understood their faith in relation to the operation of the church. If we know that it is inauthentic then this may encourage the church now to relate bible stories in a more modern context as well; this may open the beliefs of Christianity to more people, as the stories are more understandable. It is also important in our understanding of the formation of the church in terms of structure and preaching. If Paul were not the author of the Pastoral Epistles then the way in which Christians practice faith does not have to be so rigid with the ways set out in the bible. The authorship of the Pastoral Epistles does matter - Christianity has its foundations in the word of the bible and hence must be sure of all its origins today, meaning the questionable authorship of 1Tim, 2 Tim, and Titus is still worthy of valid debate in present times. 1 P.N. Harrison. 2 Paul the letter writer - 2. Statistical Methods and the pastoral epistles - Michael Prior CM 3 Paul the letter writer - Michael Prior CM 4 Paul the letter writer - 1. The problem of the Pastoral Epistles. Michael Prior - CM 5 1 Tim 6:20 6 Paul the letter writer - 1. The problem of the Pastoral Epistles. Michael Prior CM ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christianity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christianity essays

  1. Situation ethics. Joseph Fletcher developed the idea of making a moral decision for a ...

    people see things from their own point of view and therefore the theory of Situation Ethics could be damaged by the selfishness of humans. He also believed the situation ethics seemed to be prepared to accept any action at all if it fits the required criteria so if there was

  2. A2 Religious Std Authorship of the Fourth Gospel

    with Jesus, and perhaps no contact with Palestine; certainty not by an apostle". First, Barrett raises his concern that the language of the Gospel doesn't fit in with the time it was set to be written in. He states that "The history of the Fourth Gospel in the second century

  1. The Status of Women In the New Testament.

    However, this serves only to establish the increasing likelihood that Jesus' teachings were authentic. 10 Jesus uses his power and authority to try to bridge the gap between men and women in society by his acts of compassion. He is not afraid to be touched by a ritually unclean woman

  2. Outline the arguments of scholars for and against the view that the author of ...

    But he had put in his gospel references to the Beloved Disciple - the highly honoured disciple who years before had died in Ephesus" therefore the evangelist became associated with the Beloved Disciple, the son of Zebedee. However, the most important thing is not who wrote the gospel but the content of it.

  1. ''What is boasted of at the present time as the revival of religion is ...

    The idea of Jesus, a holy man performing good deeds appealed to Mill, but he disregarded the resolute belief that the Bible is law and we must obey what the church commands. So far Mill has been extremely reasonable with his views; he dislikes a controlling religion that disallows liberty of so many things from speech to opinion.

  2. Religious authority. I will be focusing on the way the Bible is used in ...

    The bible is also used as the basis of worship and liturgy. The eucharist or holy communion service is the obvious example of a service firmly based upon the Biblical record. The Psalms are also frequently used in worship, and individual verses in the Bible have been the inspiration for hymns and songs.

  1. With reference to the topics you have ...

    Carrier and Friedman ignore this background, arguing that because Christianity changed some Jewish beliefs, there is no part of Judaism that is informative to Christianity. The little regard that Carrier and Friedman exhibit for Paul?s Jewish background is in direct contravention of the importance Paul clearly places on it.

  2. Dating of the Book of Acts

    In my opinion, which is in support of the opinion of many others, the late date appears to be the least likely. Nevertheless, in order to reach a fair conclusion all suggestions should be taken into account and evaluated. The first argument in support of such a date is the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work